This team would look a lot better today with Schenn and Simmonds too. 1The only thing keeping that trade from being maybe the disaster in franchise history is the Cup win, and they had to double down on another big trade before the Richards deal was ultimately worth the risk. Without the Cup win, the Penner deal is a pretty bad one too, even if they rid themselves of Teubert in the process. There's a couple guys they missed out on with that 2011 pick.
You can say the Penner, Richards, and Carter deals are all different than Lucic, and that's true, but the context of when the trades were made is different too. I can't know this since I'm not in Lombardi's brain, but my theory is that I don't know if they make the Lucic deal if they at least make the playoffs in 2015. If they did, Carolina gets the 2015 pick, but they can't win the McDavid lottery with it. However, since they missed the playoffs, Carolina got the 2016 pick. Since cracks are starting to show by the team actually missing the playoffs in 2015, 2if they miss in 2016 as well, and Carolina wins the Matthews lottery with that pick, we never remember they won the Cup twice. Losing Matthews would be the only topic of discussion ever posted on this board again.
3Of course, the nadir, crux, or fulcrum of all of this is Voynov. If he had been around, there's at least not as big of a need for Sekera. Maybe they trade for him anyway, but they're not anywhere near as desperate. Maybe they use the Sekera assets for a longer term version of Lucic. Maybe they keep the pick. Whatever they would've done, Voynov, more than anyone else, is the player they currently need, and have needed for the last 3 years. With all the other roster issues they've had, they didn't need Voynov as the cherry on top, but that's exactly what they got.