Is the example everyone uses Adam Fox? Justin Schultz was the same.
To back you up there was a fair bit of concern (not sure if it was Smoke or just worry) that Johnny G would not sign here in Calgary, and that he would go UFA route to be closer to home.
That sabers Goalie is (Portilo?) is currently going through it. I do not remember if there was a concern a year ago though.
Justin Schultz was in his final year, he stopped communicating with Anaheim, he wanted to play in Canada (not just Alberta), and once again, there's documentation/reports of a player not wanting to play for Anaheim.
Gaudreau is a UFA. Plenty go home to play after spending years playing professionally for other teams.
Portillo's issues of signing with Buffalo are tied to the goalie depth in Buffalo's organization. Not wanting to play for only one team.
Faber met with Blake. Declined signing a contract because he wanted to spend another year in college, got traded, and proceeded to spend another year in college. After the trade, there's no quotes of "I told Blake I wanted to stay closer to home long-term" or "I asked for a trade". Nobody has picked up any mentions of him telling Blake "I'll never sign with you." Blake hasn't even hinted the motivation behind trading Faber was related to his refusal to play anywhere but LA.
Don't you think if there was any truth to that, one of the many journalists, podcasters, blabbermouth family/friends would have found something amidst all this smoke?
It's very possible this is all true, and Faber would have signed only with Minnesota and forced the issue. But the fervor in which this gets pushed as fact doesn't make sense.
I'm sure Faber's a great kid who's over the moon at his situation. It couldn't work out better for him. And I'm happy his family also has him near by. Heck, maybe Blake just included Faber to do the kid a solid, knowing his family situation and he wanted Fiala anyway. But those are all speculative. There's just no further facts or evidence supporting your claims.
You don’t know that the smoke meant nothing, just like I don’t know that the smoke meant something.
But I would do the Fiala/Faber trade one hundred times out of one hundred, so who really cares whether or not Faber wanted to play here or Minnesota. Fiala is a top 32 player in the league.
And that's fine. I still think the trade needs time to marinate before jumping to a conclusion.
It's cool to like/love the trade. Fiala's a fantastic player. Just don't confuse fact with speculation to justify or rationalize it further.