Raccoon Jesus
We were right there
I am not. Its actually just what I said. He will be in due to his longevity, not his peak performances. I do often wonder if he had gone balls out earlier in his career maybe his teams would have fared better or had better seedings, but who knows.
But I do take issue with the Conn Smythe, he was never in contention due to rather pedestrian Conference and Cup Finals series both years. First two rounds, absolutely. Last two? You could argue Dwight King had a bigger impact.
But would you consider Ryan O'Reilly a superstar? Dude has had a very similar career. Selke, a Cup, a slightly lower points percentage but a better leader. That's were I see Anze, in the Toews/Bergeron/O' Reilly mix, not up there with Crosby on the top shelf.
I don't think ROR belongs in that tier at all. a 58 point pace is far different than a 72 point pace, partiuclarly when the peak is 64 points, and he's only played 2 complete seasons in his career. If he's in it, he's at the very bottom of it, and Kopitar the very top. Yes, AK is below Crosby tier but at the absolute top of the Toews/Bergeron tier.
Im as big a Byfield fan as anyone but I don't think you're seriously suggesting he enters that Crosby tier with McDavid, even Matthews, Eichel.
Its not outlandish to project Byfield to be a superior peak offensive player to Kopitar.
Let's call our shots on this if its so goddam shocking. Do we or do we not think that Byfield will hit a higher season total than 92 points or have more than two seasons over 80 points? Because that's the point here. Peak performance, not duration.
Era adjusted? We'll see.
92 points these years is good for like 50th in scoring