Kessel, JvR, and Kulemin in Sochi

leafsfuture

Registered User
Mar 30, 2008
6,134
183
Chicago's captain has lead his team to 2 X Stanley Cup and earned a Conn Smythe trophy in the process. His character and leadership is through the roof.

I wouldn't be surprised if we see Toews given the assignment to go head to head against Kessel's line and Bergeron asked to keep Kane in check. Both team Canada players playing 200ft games.

That is of course if its Canada verses USA in the semi finals baring any upsets. :crossfing

I dont disagree about his leadership skills, and personally If I was Babcock I would have seriously considered making him our Captain.

That being said, this whole 2x Stanley Cup and Conn Smythe thing is getting a bit out of hand. Dont get me wrong, hes the leader of the closest thing we will get to a dynasty in the modern era, but when Patrick Kane is your wingman, and you have Duncan Kieth on defence you have a lot of help.

For example I have read legitimate news articles that have called him a "sure fire Hall of Famer", and maybe he might end up one, but sometimes his skill level gets a tad overrated because of (as everyone like to joke about) the intangibles.
 

LeafsMonster

Marlanderthews
Feb 3, 2012
21,026
569
Toronto
Cool, Kuli was on the pp with malkin, setting up a screen. Made a good play to get the puck back to his player after the player lost it. But he stepped out of the way of a shot too fast and the goalie saved it easily.

Nice to see him given that opportunity.
 

achtungbaby

Registered User
Oct 31, 2006
4,792
25
Not too bad of an option.

I guess the question is:
a) Is Kessel a 30 goal, 75 point player that's having a one off ridiculous year?
b) Or is Kessel a 45 goal 100 point guy who is finally having his breakout season?

If it's option a (which I think is the much more likely option), wouldn't be too bad of a decision.
But if he turned out to actually be option b... we would look pretty silly.

Shhhh.... Don't even mention life without Kessel. :) If the Leafs fall off another cliff after the Olympic break, trading Kessel should definitely be considered carefully. Kessel's best season to date has come in a contract year, hopefully that had nothing to do with it. He'll be 27 to start the season and will either be entering his prime, if you subscribe to the traditional prime years being 27-32, or his prime years are close to over if you subscribe to what other folks believe (that prime years end between 27 and 29 on average). Either way the Leafs have a window of 2-5 years where Kessel will be at his best. Are we going to be cup contenders during that time frame?

If you don't want to be attacked the answer is "yes". We'd need a few prospects to seamlessly make the jump to the bigshow and have a lot of other things go our way for that to happen. My heart wants to believe it by my head tells me it's not likely. Who knows though, just my opinion.
 

SprDaVE

Moderator
Sep 20, 2008
54,583
38,509
Not too bad of an option.

I guess the question is:
a) Is Kessel a 30 goal, 75 point player that's having a one off ridiculous year?
b) Or is Kessel a 45 goal 100 point guy who is finally having his breakout season?

If it's option a (which I think is the much more likely option), wouldn't be too bad of a decision.
But if he turned out to actually be option b... we would look pretty silly.

For someone that's so against mediocrity, entertaining the idea of trading Kessel is so against what you want to accomplish.

You build with him on the team, not without. The guy just turned 26 years old back in October, has put up a few 30 goal campaigns all ready with PPG campaigns. He's always been pretty much healthy as well, which is unheard of in pro hockey. You have to be a special kind of idiot, no offence, to be against mediocrity but then to turn around suggesting trading Kessel may be a decent option because of some weird reasoning.

Trading him will very likely put us back into a tail spin of uncertainty, if not worst then mediocrity.
 
Last edited:

SprDaVE

Moderator
Sep 20, 2008
54,583
38,509
Funny how the goal posts keep moving for Kessel. First he wasn't a first line player, then he wasn't a franchise player, and now the best people can do is say he isn't the best player in the league, and try to pretend he isn't good enough to produce 80+ points even though he's been producing more than that for 3 years now.

I don't think people realize how this is actually a compliment to Kessel, being compared to the best in the league, even if some say he's not quite as good as some of them.

Considering the hate, humiliation and finger pointing Kessel, the Leafs and us the fans have suffered through the last few years, I'm quite ecstatic to have one of the best offensive players in the league even if he isn't the best.

This trade has turned out so well for us.
 

ULF_55

Moderator
Feb 27, 2002
87,183
18,894
Mountain Standard Ti
Visit site
I don't think people realize how this is actually a compliment to Kessel, being compared to the best in the league, even if some say he's not quite as good as some of them.

Considering the hate, humiliation and finger pointing Kessel, the Leafs and us the fans have suffered through the last few years, I'm quite ecstatic to have one of the best offensive players in the league even if he isn't the best.

This trade has turned out so well for us.

I did not like the trade, I thought it was premature.

How can you not like Kessel though?

Who won it?

I think we'll have to wait and see the outcome on that.

Too many are quick to decide without knowing the results, whether it is calling a prospect a star or bust, or trade a win or loss.

I really don't care what he does for an opposition(Americans) team though.
 
Last edited:

achtungbaby

Registered User
Oct 31, 2006
4,792
25
I did not like the trade, I thought it was premature.

How can you not like Kessel though?

Who won it?

I think we'll have to wait and see the outcome on that.

Too many are quick to decide without knowing the results, whether it is calling a prospect a star or bust, or trade a win or loss.

Pretty much how I felt. The moment those picks were gone we weren't patiently rebuilding and letting the chips fall where they may, we were trying to improve the team immediately to make sure those picks weren't too high. Also, if we were going to go all in like that, I would have preferred a center or a top defensemen.

Kessel is a heck of a player though, can't deny that.
 

SprDaVE

Moderator
Sep 20, 2008
54,583
38,509
I did not like the trade, I thought it was premature.

How can you not like Kessel though?

Who won it?

I think we'll have to wait and see the outcome on that.

Too many are quick to decide without knowing the results, whether it is calling a prospect a star or bust, or trade a win or loss.

I really don't care what he does for an opposition(Americans) team though.

Tough to call a winner here but either way I don't really care to declare who actually won. All I know is that we have a player that we can build with for the next few years at the very least.
 

Holymakinaw

Registered User
May 22, 2007
8,637
4,514
Toronto
Tough to call a winner here but either way I don't really care to declare who actually won. All I know is that we have a player that we can build with for the next few years at the very least.

We have Kessel to build around......AND we have 24 year old, former 2nd overall pick JVR to build around.......AND two of our own very high draft picks in Kadri and Rielly to build around, too. We haven't had that much pure and upcoming skill in years.

Those four right there are on par, or soon will be on par with, ANY "four great YOUNG pieces" on ANY team in the league. And Kessel is simply the best of our bunch.

It's a good bunch, and fun to watch.
 

The Podium

Registered User
Feb 19, 2010
22,969
10,280
Toronto
Not too bad of an option.

I guess the question is:
a) Is Kessel a 30 goal, 75 point player that's having a one off ridiculous year?
b) Or is Kessel a 45 goal 100 point guy who is finally having his breakout season?

If it's option a (which I think is the much more likely option), wouldn't be too bad of a decision.
But if he turned out to actually be option b... we would look pretty silly.

So a near 200 games over a point per game and you question whether this season is an outlier? I know you have questionable opinions and that is on your own terms but to blatantly ignore fact is borderline delusional
 

Trainspotter

Registered User
May 28, 2013
424
0
So a near 200 games over a point per game and you question whether this season is an outlier? I know you have questionable opinions and that is on your own terms but to blatantly ignore fact is borderline delusional

More like Standard Operating Procedure around these parts.
 

The Blue Devil

Registered User
Nov 9, 2009
5,682
1
Shhhh.... Don't even mention life without Kessel. :) If the Leafs fall off another cliff after the Olympic break, trading Kessel should definitely be considered carefully. Kessel's best season to date has come in a contract year, hopefully that had nothing to do with it. He'll be 27 to start the season and will either be entering his prime, if you subscribe to the traditional prime years being 27-32, or his prime years are close to over if you subscribe to what other folks believe (that prime years end between 27 and 29 on average). Either way the Leafs have a window of 2-5 years where Kessel will be at his best. Are we going to be cup contenders during that time frame?

If you don't want to be attacked the answer is "yes". We'd need a few prospects to seamlessly make the jump to the bigshow and have a lot of other things go our way for that to happen. My heart wants to believe it by my head tells me it's not likely. Who knows though, just my opinion.

Which season are you talking about? He's has one ppg, 1 above ppg and is currently above ppg this season. Maybe you should be shh'ing yourself.
 

achtungbaby

Registered User
Oct 31, 2006
4,792
25
The average is about 27-32. Kessel is a guy who will still be scoring until he 36-37.

You're a traditionalist in that sense. This article has the average NHLer playing their best years from 24-27. Their research was done in 2010 though, who knows what the data looks like now. There's not a whole lot of guys who produce a lot into their mid 30's, what about Kessel makes you think he's one of them? I'm not saying he won't be, I just believe it's impossible to determine.
 

Mikeyg

Registered User
Dec 26, 2011
8,884
2,579
leaf's lunch is saying that big phil is the greatest player in the world right now, its being live steamed on tsn
 

Cor

I am a bot
Jun 24, 2012
69,648
35,246
AEF
You're a traditionalist in that sense. This article has the average NHLer playing their best years from 24-27. Their research was done in 2010 though, who knows what the data looks like now. There's not a whole lot of guys who produce a lot into their mid 30's, what about Kessel makes you think he's one of them? I'm not saying he won't be, I just believe it's impossible to determine.

The style he plays. He's not physical, has really only had one injury (his shoulder), his only other serious injuries were Cancer and Mono.

His body has a lot less wear and tear then most others in the NHL. Usually leads to a longer life span.

Obviously it is impossible to predict, but as of right now, chances are high that Kessel will produce into his mid 30's
 

The Podium

Registered User
Feb 19, 2010
22,969
10,280
Toronto
You're a traditionalist in that sense. This article has the average NHLer playing their best years from 24-27. Their research was done in 2010 though, who knows what the data looks like now. There's not a whole lot of guys who produce a lot into their mid 30's, what about Kessel makes you think he's one of them? I'm not saying he won't be, I just believe it's impossible to determine.

Plays a lot like Selanne, you don't hit and rely on speed smarts and release these aren't things that tend to wear down.
 

achtungbaby

Registered User
Oct 31, 2006
4,792
25
Plays a lot like Selanne, you don't hit and rely on speed smarts and release these aren't things that tend to wear down.

True enough, though we should note that Selanne was always known for keeping himself in tremendous shape. Even Kessels biggest fans wouldn't accuse him of the same. Let's hope Phil turns into a gym rat as he ages. :)
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad