I'm not disagreeing with you. But I think most posters are looking at it from what they want, instead of Hilferty's perspective.
Hilerty's perspective is Torts and Briere are in charge.
I agree with Hilferty. I don't want Doug Wilson or Scott Mellanby as the de facto GM. I want Torts and Briere making decisions.
Honest to God, my biggest reason for not liking this decision is the way torts talks and explains himself and his thoughts on the game today, he's stated several times, he doesn't like overly skilled players, he prefers grinders and thats all fine and well, you do need some players who can do some work in the dirty areas, but you're not winning without skill and creativity, you need skill and to take chances to create offense, can't just skate it in, shoot and score and be effective, can't really win with a dump and chase method, you give up the puck entirely to much, you need a solid mix of skill and dirty work, but torts makes people believe he's incapable of incorporating that kind of system, because of the shit he says and does, now I get it, you want players to play responsible, you want solid effort, you want 2 way play, but like I said you need skill, it's a different league completely since he's won a cup, it's a different league from when Jones played, hell it's even vastly different since briere's last game, there is really no reason for Deslauriers type of player in this league, if he was more like a 4th liner of the kings cup days that's different, they were physical and sound defensively, but he's not that, now I give credit where credit is due, he's made a believer out of me with Tippett, everyone knows I hated him since he was traded for giroux, because I thought he was a big fat bust, but I've been wrong, and I'll admit I was wrong if these guys build a proper team, but with the things they say and do, it's extremely hard to get behind them, because it really seems like the game has passed them bye, there I zero reason for an enforcer to be an 82 game staple for a team in this day and age when fighting has started going the way of the dodo birds
I'm not looking at fighting or arguing about it, but if you're wondering why so many are against what's happening this is why, they also say they have a plan, but so did the last group, and there weren't any, it seems like they're hoping for a miracle like drafting the next giroux with a middle to late pick to change their fortune