I also think a lot of people sound like they are overrating some of the returns being discussed. I mean, it's not that guys like Mercer or Norris are bad players. They're pretty good. Decent. But we're not talking game-breakers or players who will be top stars on our team. I know Saros is having a down season, but he has been a legitimate All-Star and top player at his position league-wide the last few years. He was a game-breaker for us a lot of nights the previous few seasons. I don't want to trade a star player for just some decent 2nd line depth. I don't care about the league-wide precedent on goalie valuation. We have time, we're not in any position of desperation, there's no need to take just the first half-decent young player offered.
Just because you don't care doesn't mean GM's around the league are all of a sudden go, hey, PS doesn't care about goalie valuation, let's trade for Saros and give NP a load of quality.
I get why BT is asking for the moon and good for him. It gives him wiggle room to negotiate down to a point where he thinks he's getting good value in return.
I would love for us to move Saros and get a top 3 forward, preferably a center. History tells me that's a pipe dream as I don't of any goalie of Saros's level that got moved a player of that ilk.
So where does that leave us, more than likely at what you described, 2nd line depth, hopefully a 1st and possibly another add. Is it what I want, no but is it realistic, I'd say it is.
Adding a quality 2nd liner who can pot 50-60 points is something we desperately need. While we also need a top 3 forward or two, it's not going to happen in any deal for Saros unless some team gets super desperate and I don't see that happening.
The other piece of this is, move Saros, get quality pieces for him that you use to build your team around or bundle with other quality pieces to land the top end talent you need. It's not that easy and it's going to hurt but say a team like Vancouver can't re-up Petersson, do you offer them a huge package of quality players, do you offer sheet him?
This is not directed to you but why the need to hold on to Saros? He's been great in the regular season for us in the past. He's never won a playoff series. While an elite goalie can alleviate the pains a team has in the regular season, very rarely do you see them elevate their team in the playoffs. Playoffs is a full team game where everyone has to give everything, which is why more rounded teams with lesser goalies have beaten us in years past.
I'm indifferent if we move him before the TDL or at the draft/offseason.
The thing we have going for us if we move him before the TDL is, we use that as leverage to the buyer to say, hey, you're getting him for 2 playoff runs. It also gets rid of the distraction, is he staying or going.
If we wait til after the season, it opens up a lot of options but do we get a package that is better than the one we'd get in the next couple of weeks?
I'll leave you with a question, what do you think is fair value for Saros?