TP70BruinsCup
Let’s Go Bruins👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Yep, Judd is doing just like he did on the radio which was always easy to listen to. Just talk about the game and tell us what’s happening
NESN Judd Sirott named new voice of the Bruins
- Thread starter Gee Wally
- Start date
Only two games in, and I can't stand him already.
If you are a professional announcer, one of your primary skills must be clear diction. Judd's diction is appalling.
If he says "Lin-holm" one more time I will scream and we have two of them. It's LinDholm, idiot. Here are some of his other obvious ones, "killin,'" "inner the zone," and "back in" versus "back end." He also has trouble with "penalty," "send," and "sent."
Maybe he can spend next summer taking diction lessons.
The good thing with Center Ice is that you have a choice of home or visitor broadcasts. I can always flip to NESN between periods and after the game.
No offense to Razor, but I don't like the new feature of having his during-game commentary. It's not him I don't like, it's the feature.
If you are a professional announcer, one of your primary skills must be clear diction. Judd's diction is appalling.
If he says "Lin-holm" one more time I will scream and we have two of them. It's LinDholm, idiot. Here are some of his other obvious ones, "killin,'" "inner the zone," and "back in" versus "back end." He also has trouble with "penalty," "send," and "sent."
Maybe he can spend next summer taking diction lessons.
The good thing with Center Ice is that you have a choice of home or visitor broadcasts. I can always flip to NESN between periods and after the game.
No offense to Razor, but I don't like the new feature of having his during-game commentary. It's not him I don't like, it's the feature.
CharasLazyWrister
Registered User
I think Jack was often annoying but tolerable in his “prime”. Even funny on occasion. It’s when he started to slow down where it just became straight stupid like 100% of the time.
PlayMakers
Registered User
The first Pasta pun was funny. The second one was a bit redundant. If he drops a third I'll be annoyed.
He is very professional and easy to listen to, but I miss Jack's enthusiasm. It seemed like every game was Xmas morning to him.
He is very professional and easy to listen to, but I miss Jack's enthusiasm. It seemed like every game was Xmas morning to him.
As a lifelong out of market B's fan that only cares about hockey and absolutely loved Jack's passion and commitment (but completely understood how he could get on peoples nerves but kinda found it funny more often than not anyhow...) I had no idea who Judd was until he got the gig, I think he is doing fine. I always enjoy Brick's insight into the game and I feel that he is getting a little more space to chime in now, and that is no dig on Jack.
Was already very familiar with Judd from the radio, so this has been an easy transition for me. Think he's doing fine on TV, probably even slightly better already than his radio call. Not an amazing, top tier commentator, but solid. Calls the play professionally without overwhelming it, little bit of warmth and humor, gives Brick space to do his thing. That's quite enough for me. No complaints.
- Sep 22, 2011
- 11,809
- 12,945
Goal call still sucks, but at least he gave us one game before breaking out the "He scooooooooooooores". Otherwise, a refreshing change from the buffoonery of the past.
Buffoonery is exactly what the problem was. I'll take Sirott's (U of Michigan grad, can't be that ignorant) diction quirks over Jack's childish ranting and trite sayings any day and every day.
This broadcast is fresh air compared to the what we had over the last 2 or 3 years.
I sincerely have sympathy for his medical issues, but when I can't do my job as I should, I'll get replaced as well.
This broadcast is fresh air compared to the what we had over the last 2 or 3 years.
I sincerely have sympathy for his medical issues, but when I can't do my job as I should, I'll get replaced as well.
DoubleBack
Registered User
- Apr 29, 2024
- 349
- 735
I can't say enough how much I love that there have been no spoons or spatulas on the ice this season. In fact no utensils or garden tools at all so far.
Last edited:
Si Hopkins
Registered User
People have been pining for basic for years. Well, we're here.
Judd's nice. Maybe he'll develop a personality over the coming years.
Judd's nice. Maybe he'll develop a personality over the coming years.
Roll 4 Lines
Pastafarian!
Interesting. On Saturday I was wishing he'd stick to calling the game, and not be yakking about, who knows what while shots are being taken on goal!
Ludwig Fell Down
Registered User
Reminds me a bit of Don Orsillo, who broke in announcing Sox games by the book, and developed a personality which was easy with Remy alongside him. I think Brick will do the same.
And when I was watching the other night and had my laptop on, for a solid minute I thought I had the radio on and then realized I was in front of the tv. Gonna take me a minute to get used to.
Ozzy Osbourne
Registered User
- Nov 14, 2023
- 1,604
- 1,834
I think he will develop more personality as the season goes on. I’m just happy we didn’t get stuck with the guy who filled in for Jack last year.
Orsillo was awesome. I wish NESN would bring him back and get Eck out of retirement. Those two would bring some excitement to a boring, faceless product.
Ludwig Fell Down
Registered User
Boring and Faceless. I think you just came up with the title to John Henry's autobiography.
mikelvl
Registered User
I think Judd's fine. But I have to admit, when Charlie Coyle got called for that phantom high sticking penalty in the home opener when he was like a mile away from the guy, I couldn't help but wonder what Jackie Boy's reaction would have been.
Chevalier du Clavier
Écrivain de ferrage
- Jul 20, 2005
- 4,637
- 3,615
He’s on Reddit. I don’t know how he reacted to that, but this is his response to the Brazzeau goalie interference vs. the Habs.
- Sep 22, 2011
- 11,809
- 12,945
Jack Edwards and Reddit were made for each other, and I'm not saying that in a positive way.
With respect to everyone else’s preferences, I personally can finally listen to the Bruins feed again instead of opting for the opponent’s or mute. I’m ok with the new guy. Just call the game so that if I happen to look away or if something is developing behind the play, I know what’s going on.
But then, I’d probably be a lot happier without color commentary, intermission shows, and player interviews, so take my opinion with a grain of salt. I’m also the guy that hated all the extracurricular activities at live games, and preferred the old analog scoreboard and an organ player. I guess that mindset doesn’t sell anymore.
But then, I’d probably be a lot happier without color commentary, intermission shows, and player interviews, so take my opinion with a grain of salt. I’m also the guy that hated all the extracurricular activities at live games, and preferred the old analog scoreboard and an organ player. I guess that mindset doesn’t sell anymore.
Sirott is fine, keeps the show on the ice for the most part. He misses some details that Edwards used to nail, but that's unsurprising since Jack's game preparation was among the best in the league.
I am Bettman
Registered User
- May 23, 2022
- 696
- 1,570
Jack should take over narration for behind the b or something like that where he can stay connected but also have as many takes as he needs.
Don't know where else to put this, or if it's been posted already. Mods, please move as you see fit.
nantucketcurrent.com
Catching Up With Nantucket Summer Resident, Voice Of The Boston…
Nantucket Current is the island's leading online news source. We deliver the news, stories, and people of Nantucket, unbiased and unfiltered.
nantucketcurrent.com
That's a great interview. Such honesty about certain players. Not the 'homer" interview I expected.Don't know where else to put this, or if it's been posted already. Mods, please move as you see fit.
Catching Up With Nantucket Summer Resident, Voice Of The Boston…
Nantucket Current is the island's leading online news source. We deliver the news, stories, and people of Nantucket, unbiased and unfiltered.
smithformeragent
Moderator
Wow I didn't notice that. I'm going to give it another try next game because those board ads are annoying and distracting as f***!
GatorMike
Registered User
FWIW, my only issue with Judd so far is that he's still calling games as if he's doing radio play-by-play.
Slightly too fast for TV, and too much time spent describing where the puck and/or players are on the ice. It's not necessary - we're watching. We can see where the puck/player is.
Slightly too fast for TV, and too much time spent describing where the puck and/or players are on the ice. It's not necessary - we're watching. We can see where the puck/player is.
