KevSkillz4
Registered User
- Apr 11, 2016
- 7,818
- 13,132
Value of: Josh Anderson
- Thread starter KevSkillz4
- Start date
40-50 points per season…When?
He broke 40 points, once, 3 seasons ago and only broke 30 one other time, in 2017/18. Every other season has been below 30.
5.5m AAV, for 5 more seasons, for 20+ points, is a bit high
KevSkillz4
Registered User
- Apr 11, 2016
- 7,818
- 13,132
47 points with Columbus and on pace 43 points this year.
The Nuge
Some say…
I just can’t see much value for a 35-40 point guy at 5.5 per with that much term left. He’s a guy everyone would want, but contenders just can’t afford to spend that much on him. If Montreal is blowing it up and wanted to retain 1.5 million or so I could definitely see them getting a 1st and a good prospect though
KingsHockey24
Registered User
- Aug 1, 2013
- 14,498
- 13,256
No way we trade him. None.
He's doing wonders for our future in Suzuki and Caufield, and is the perfect candidate to be our Captain. He's not crazy expensive, he's a Habs fan, and he appears to be happy here.
He's doing wonders for our future in Suzuki and Caufield, and is the perfect candidate to be our Captain. He's not crazy expensive, he's a Habs fan, and he appears to be happy here.
KevSkillz4
Registered User
- Apr 11, 2016
- 7,818
- 13,132
Why his contract is bad? 5,5 for a player like that it's ok. Looks the contract of Tom Wilson. Yeah he product more, but he play with Backstrom and Ovechkin too.
Habs Halifax
Loyal Habs Fan
You won't get the right value with Anderson on HF boards. Signed through prime years and a type of forward that is not readily available. Most Habs fans including our management are not shopping Anderson. MSL said it himself, he wants the Caufield / Suzuki / Anderson line to stick for a long time.
Anderson is not consistent but he has different levels to this game he has proven to play at. You can clearly see the difference with him playing under MSL and with Suzuki and Caufield in recent games. And this big body that can skate and shoot the puck is a valuable asset in the playoffs.
Anderson is not consistent but he has different levels to this game he has proven to play at. You can clearly see the difference with him playing under MSL and with Suzuki and Caufield in recent games. And this big body that can skate and shoot the puck is a valuable asset in the playoffs.
Last edited:
pth2
Registered User
- Jan 7, 2018
- 3,431
- 2,723
This thread won't end well. Anderson doesn't post huge numbers, is over 22 and has a long-term contract. Fans here will see him as overpaid and over the hill and suggest the Habs buy him out.
You have to actually watch Habs games to have an idea of how much he contributes.
You have to actually watch Habs games to have an idea of how much he contributes.
LOL at this negative value crap. People on this board really need to get a clue.
BLNY
Registered User
Given recent comments by MSL, I would be shocked if Montreal moved him as part of the rebuild/retool.
bert
Registered User
Its pretty obvious he has been a 35 to 45 point player the last 4 seasons when he is healthy. I never understand when people on these boards post stuff like the poster you quoted. It doesnt take much work to actually look at the body of work and also understand the player brings more than just scoring.
Defending Habs in multiple posts has me feeling kinda weird but its true physical players just arent what most HFers like. They cant be quantified in charts.
Habs Halifax
Loyal Habs Fan
Yzerman quote when the Blue Jackets upset them... "We had no answers for Anderson". Then you come along and look at his 3 pts in 10 games and say he is a ghost in the playoffs.
Just face it, you don't even watch him in the playoffs. You know what this reminds me of? Patch sucks in the playoffs so his value sucks. Remember those obsessive posters when the Habs were shopping Patch?
I really Like Anderson, hey may not put up 60 to 80 points but there aren't Many forwards left in the league like him. I'd take him on the leafs just depends on cost and salary going back. I'd pay a 2022 1st, 2023 2nd, kral, kerfoot and dermott. The two roster players can be traded next deadline for a few picks as well.
HugeInTheShire
You may not like me but, I'm Huge in the Shire
He's in a weird spot for most teams, he might be a little overpaid for what he brings but it's the amount of years left that most teams can't comfortably take on.
No chance he's negative value, just a difficult contract
I think this place underrates certain players values and Anderson is on of those players.
I also think he has more value to Montreal than he'd fetch in a trade
No chance he's negative value, just a difficult contract
I think this place underrates certain players values and Anderson is on of those players.
I also think he has more value to Montreal than he'd fetch in a trade
Habs Halifax
Loyal Habs Fan
When the cap rises in 2 or 3 years (after the NHLPA pays of their outstanding balance), That Anderson contract will age well when other contracts that are expiring will require hefty raises. Good luck getting a power forward like Anderson in 3/4 years at that cap hit.
A lot of people don't understand that if you sign someone past the flat cap years, the Agent is going to make you pay for those years with a much higher cap hit. This is basically why we gave him $5.5M for 7 years where if we settled for 4 years, it would have been less. But then he's getting more than $5.5M when the cap is $90M+
Remember this... cap was projected to be $84M - $88M (depending on escrow) before Covid came along. And now we have one more team generating revenue with new US TV deals. It's basically why Jones and Nurse got massive long term deals. The agent is not going to play nice in the 3+ years of term.
Viqsi
"that chick from Ohio"
Chop off the last few years of that contract and we'd gleefully take him back yesterday. But otherwise... well, we ultimately willingly (if reluctantly) gave him away for a reason.
Was pissed when the Jackets traded him to a rival team as a Rangers fan. Underrated player back with the Bluejackets.
Habs Halifax
Loyal Habs Fan
It's the other way around. His $5.5M AAV is going to look very good in the back half of that contract when the cap rises significantly in 2/3 years.
Pay attention to the terms that are being awarded recently. NHL GM's who sign guys past 2/3 years are going to pay big time for those UFA years when the cap is north of $90M.
Signed from age 27-32. Prime years and people think this will not age well?
Bookmark it.
Habs Halifax
Loyal Habs Fan
People are stat checking too much. Anderson is rare to acquire and the Habs got lucky with being able to trade Domi and a 3rd for the injured Anderson. I didn't expect Domi to fall off a cliff like that (bet you the Blue Jackets didn't as well) but I knew what we were getting with Anderson and it's much deeper than points.
- Apr 20, 2016
- 5,765
- 6,812
One of those players that passes the eye test, he's very noticeable on the ice, he just doesn't translate it into a lot of points. Probably a little overpaid, but a guy most teams would take.
