F A N
Registered User
- Aug 12, 2005
- 19,797
- 6,536
I'm a very pro player poster.
It is not a matter of "hating" on a player to be critical when warranted
The issue with Lekkerimaki was his compete and tempo. He's incredibly skilled. Top10 worthy skilled hence the high ranking but he's smallish and has shown a tendency to stop battling or skating when engaged which isn't something that gets ironed out in a gym by getting stronger and its not a great cross over trait for adapting to smaller ice and much less time and space.
It's similar to Sven Bartschi who had all the skill in the world but lacked a NHL high level motor. There's a big gamble that you can change a trait that is mostly innate. I always think of a guy like Brendan Gallagher that became so valuable because of his motor
Now obviously PA was extremely excited to get JL and has his reasons for choosing him. Nobody is suggesting from their sofas that they did more scouting and diligence than our amateur scouting staff. My issue has been that small skilled wingers with compete issues no matter how skilled are not that valuable and impactful. A 15 OA has to have impact and value.
For the record none of this is hindsight I said in the draft thread what my reservations were with JL and had Kulich Chesley Yurov Ohgren all ahead of Lekkerimaki. Bischel and Pickering were high risk high reward and I would have felt those were better gambles given the payout if they hit but had JL higher because of IQ concerns which is a huge red flag for my player evaluation process
Anyway I am just a fan that wants our drafts to workout and we don't have enough high picks to flub them. I struggle with the process of evaluation is all. Not saying mine is better.
That is where the frustration and criticism comes from I obviously want him to be a star
I was actually kind of shocked when PA was captured in the behind the scenes video essentially saying that at some point everybody competes. I mean I get what he's trying to say, but it's such a big departure from the Canucks looking for high character high motor guys. Obviously, we're not talking about lazy player but I agree with you that especially for top 6 or bust type players, the drive and willingness to put in the work is what separates "the difference makers" from the average 2nd line player who is out of the league before they are 30. There are so many players with NHL skill and shot who never make it because they aren't able to create the time and space to use their skill and shot.
At the end of the day, the Canucks had him 7th on their list. So this is as much of a home-run pick at 15 as it gets.