In a normal NHL team environment and a normal player-coach relationship, yes. A player should be punished. Not in this case. For the following reasons. The coach publicly encouraged, created, seeked and created a work environment where off ice confrontation with his players happened. Like a crack addict, Tortorella had to have this. He called it healthy and a necessary part of player and team development. This coach is clearly a deceitful, dishonest coach with obvious personality flaws. York in the past was sent to the AHL in part due the coach did not like how he acted and responded to off ice confrontation. To paraphrase, called him weak and soft. Now when York reacted in the way that the coach was asking for and encouraging, now he gets scratched for it? LOL The Flyers front office shouldn't put this mess behind them. They should be fired for it also. The enabled Tortorella, they allowed this environment to foster and grow. They are also responsible for it. It's called a hostile work environment. They hitched their wagon to this guy! Hilferty called Tortorella the team's "spiritual advisor". Are you kidding me! It's not alls well that ends well. This team is colossal mess of dysfunction and absurdity.