Value of: John Gibson
- Thread starter bsu
- Start date
SI90
Registered User
bsu
"I have no idea what I am doing" -Pat VerBleak
- Sep 27, 2017
- 28,539
- 29,293
Walked to the bench and said he was done... The first one might have been because they were on a back to back in Canada though and wanted to play both games.
ManByng
Oilers cup 2025
Oilception
Registered User
As an oiler fan I would offer a lot. Guy is the right age for the core and signed for a lot of years.
Problem is Anaheim would have to take some contracts back (ex. Kassian or Koskinan)
M
Problem is Anaheim would have to take some contracts back (ex. Kassian or Koskinan)
M
Ragdoll
Registered User
- Feb 15, 2018
- 1,214
- 1,645
If Anaheim is really making Gibson available (doubt it) then the Oilers need to be all over this guy.
ManByng
Oilers cup 2025
Koskinen for sure and it might be attractive because of the fact that he’s a UFA after the season so they can let him walk if he sucks of re-sign him for less if he doesn’t. I’d be asking for Skinner and a 1st from the oilers if I’m the Ducks but I feel the Oilers would be cool to this!
bsu
"I have no idea what I am doing" -Pat VerBleak
- Sep 27, 2017
- 28,539
- 29,293
No chance Ducks trade Gibson to oilers and then even pick up Kassian or Koskinen for it.... it's massively unrealistic.
Eggtimer
Registered User
ManByng
Oilers cup 2025
A1LeafNation
Good, is simply not good enough!
- Oct 17, 2010
- 27,649
- 17,719
23GA in the last 5 games, pulled twice.
Looks like an Oilers goalie to me.
Looks like an Oilers goalie to me.
SI90
Registered User
Snipesaitl
Registered User
- Jul 3, 2019
- 58
- 197
Posted this offer on the Oilers board:
1st + Holloway + Skinner
Would this be enough for Anaheim to deal him to a divisional rival?
Koskinen would have to go back for cap but his deal expires at the end of this year.
1st + Holloway + Skinner
Would this be enough for Anaheim to deal him to a divisional rival?
Koskinen would have to go back for cap but his deal expires at the end of this year.
Unless Gibson asks for a trade or they are very, very high on Stolarz, I doubt it. Anaheim is looking to finish their rebuild sooner or later with the emergence of Terry, Zegras, and Drysdale, and winning and developing these players is more important than another shiny pick and prospect. Add on that this years UFA goalie pool is paper thin, I doubt Anaheim actually considers moving Gibson for anything less than an overpayment.
hotcabbagesoup
"I'm going to get what I deserve" -RutgerMcgroarty
As a recently converted Oiler fan, I just grimace and say that's too much. Holloway is almost here and Gibson has really bad body language when he loses (not as bad as Mike Smith but it's more of the same), he just cannot handle streaks of losses. And I really want to see what Holloway can do. Go oilers.
Hamilton Bulldogs
Registered User
- Jan 11, 2022
- 4,039
- 5,790
Trading Gibson would be a terrible idea. For a handful of reasons.
1. Hes a fantastic goalie on a great contract that could actually lead this team to success in the playoffs.
Yes his body language at times can be poor but so was Patrick Roy's. I'd much rather have a guy who hates losing then one whos satisfied with losing and has no aspirations of winning a championship. Tonight's game was awful. The Ducks have been horrendous for the past few years and when they finally have a meaningful game, they completely shit the bed. On one of the goals, a kings player was right in Gibsons face and no one on the Ducks did a damn thing and then seconds later the Kings scored. This lack of effort from the Ducks is why Gibson was likely pissed. Most teams behave like animals if you get near their goalie, earlier this season Copp destroyed Gibson and the Ducks did very little in retribution. The sad truth is, this Ducks team very soft and that can be disheartening for a goalie who usually has to fight off opposing teams players by himself.
2. Who replaces him?
Storlaz has never been a number one. Trading a franchise goalie and replacing him with a guy whos career high in wins is 8 is a questionable decision at best. If Storlaz doesn't work out, that puts pressure on Dostal. The Ducks did it right with Gibson. He wasn't forced to take over, he eventually earned the starting job but there was never a time where the Ducks were desperate for him to start.
3. Quality of the team.
Lindholm is likely gone come summertime and if you trade Gibson this team could easily be a lottery team again next season and probably for the next few seasons after. I don't know how wise it is to have Zegras, Drysdale, Terry and McTavish have 5-6 seasons as the basement dwellers of the league. Eventually dudes want to at least taste a winning season and if they don't, its possible they bolt.
4. Value
How many times do goalies get big hauls back? Luongo, Hasek and Roy were all at one time traded while still being elite and most of them got very little. I can't imagine the Ducks getting anything amazing for Gibson as historically goalie's don't have a whole lot of value on the trade market.
1. Hes a fantastic goalie on a great contract that could actually lead this team to success in the playoffs.
Yes his body language at times can be poor but so was Patrick Roy's. I'd much rather have a guy who hates losing then one whos satisfied with losing and has no aspirations of winning a championship. Tonight's game was awful. The Ducks have been horrendous for the past few years and when they finally have a meaningful game, they completely shit the bed. On one of the goals, a kings player was right in Gibsons face and no one on the Ducks did a damn thing and then seconds later the Kings scored. This lack of effort from the Ducks is why Gibson was likely pissed. Most teams behave like animals if you get near their goalie, earlier this season Copp destroyed Gibson and the Ducks did very little in retribution. The sad truth is, this Ducks team very soft and that can be disheartening for a goalie who usually has to fight off opposing teams players by himself.
2. Who replaces him?
Storlaz has never been a number one. Trading a franchise goalie and replacing him with a guy whos career high in wins is 8 is a questionable decision at best. If Storlaz doesn't work out, that puts pressure on Dostal. The Ducks did it right with Gibson. He wasn't forced to take over, he eventually earned the starting job but there was never a time where the Ducks were desperate for him to start.
3. Quality of the team.
Lindholm is likely gone come summertime and if you trade Gibson this team could easily be a lottery team again next season and probably for the next few seasons after. I don't know how wise it is to have Zegras, Drysdale, Terry and McTavish have 5-6 seasons as the basement dwellers of the league. Eventually dudes want to at least taste a winning season and if they don't, its possible they bolt.
4. Value
How many times do goalies get big hauls back? Luongo, Hasek and Roy were all at one time traded while still being elite and most of them got very little. I can't imagine the Ducks getting anything amazing for Gibson as historically goalie's don't have a whole lot of value on the trade market.
i am against trading a lottery pick for a goalie. adding holtz to the ask is unreasonable.
Easy no....Come back to earth when u do give us a call...All honesty why would u trade him ....
- Jul 25, 2012
- 41,747
- 38,227
- Jul 25, 2012
- 41,747
- 38,227
I’d say would make more sense at draft…. But I assume the devils 1st would be enticing. Obviously devils arnt going to do it if it lands in top 3…. But if it’s 4-10 I could see devils making the move… prob another piece depending on where pick is
