A couple points -
I think Howie is getting his market value. I can live with the deal as long as there is no NTC
But still, when have the Red Wings had "World Class" defenses? 1997 was probably our best, but we still had old Murphy, old Festisov and old Rouse.
1998 we added Macoun and Anders eriksson after losing Konstantinov and...I forget who else we lost.
2002 we had Lidstrom and Chelios, but Fischer was 21 and mistake prone. Olausson was old. Duschene and Olausson were at the end of their rop.
2008 was probably one of our best with Lidstrom and Rafalski, Stuart and Kronwall. But we Lebda and Lilja...
The Wings haven't been running world class defense groups. And they've not had the 6'4 stay-at-home, physical guys either.
They win with a defense that moves the puck and forwards who keep the puck, and centers that play excellent defense.
When you do that well, you minimize what's required of you're goalie -- just as Hitchcock and Tippett minimize what's required of their goalies.
Murphy wasn't that old in 1997. He turned 36 that March and still had plenty in the tank. By 99-00, he was old. And by 00-01, he was just embarrassing himself. But in 97 he was still in good playing condition. That's a nitpick, but worth noting.
So there are two common threads to the 97, 98, and 02 teams:
1. They had so much skill at forward that they could play keepaway most of the game and had the discipline to minimize chances against when the other team did manage to get the puck. You can't get scored on when you have the puck. Well, it's really hard to do, anyway.
2. The defense was balanced perfectly, even if it wasn't packed with superstars. Lidstrom and Murphy complemented each other perfectly in 97 and 98, as Lidstrom and Olausson did in 02 and Rafalski in 08. They had Vladdy in 97 - that's nuff said right there. Fetisov and Rouse were both old but they played defense - this team would do well to have a couple old guys that don't play the puck much but actually know how to play defense. Shocking, I know. And then in 02 they got great play from Duchesne and Chelios was dominant.
2008 was a little different, as they didn't really have the elite skill of the earlier Cup teams. They did have two brilliant and balanced pairings in Lidstrom-Rafalski (before his wheels fell off) and Kronwall-Stuart. Those pairs could play 50 minutes a night and cover basically all of the tough matchups and special teams minutes. That left about 10 minutes a night against 3rd and 4th liners for Lebda and Lilja, who managed to play their best hockey in that playoff stretch.
To your last point, the defense has been gradually moving the puck less and less, and the offense has been gradually keeping the puck less and less. To the point where it's now pretty far out of whack. Babcock is all over this, BTW. There's a reason they have what, 37 defensemen on the roster right now? Babcock is trying to find a combination that has any kind of balance because you have to have that balanced, stifling defense to win the Cup.
In the meantime, Jimmy is covering up a lot of sloppy play by Q, Kronwall, CC, Lashoff, and the rest of the boys. Until they get the D in order, they're going to need Jimmy.