The Top 10 from Last August's HFJets forum poll:what does your top 10 prospects list look like right now?
Salomonssonwhat does your top 10 prospects list look like right now?
Scout's Analysis: An updated look at how 2024 NHL Draft prospects are faring
With the world juniors in the rearview, Jason Bukala provides an update on how players selected at the 2024 NHL Draft are faring so far this season.www.sportsnet.ca
He and Walton highlighted.
He and Walton both have solid NHL potential. They also provide a classic prospect assessment issue. Walton appears to have a higher ceiling but He seems more likely to hit his ceiling.Thanks for this -- interesting read.
Struck by these notes about Walton: "Walton’s skating has gone to another level this season and the results speak for themselves [he] has fantastic touch, pucks are on and off his stick in a hurry."
Improved skating and mobility seem crucial for NHL success, but the comment on just how good his first touch is pointed to another reason for his elevated totals this season -- Walton plays fast, which seems exactly suited to the Jets playstyle this year and hopefully going forward.
Nice writeup on He also -- hard to believe that He's only 5'11'' ad 185, given his skating and forechecking power. Two or more impact players out of a thin draft (for the Jets, given their number or picks) would be a serious jolt for the pipeline.
For me:what does your top 10 prospects list look like right now?
His shot is for real,the truth is in the numbers,his release is top shelf.I was always worried about the Barlow pick as he looked like a men playing with boys and that it would catch up to him. Obviously hoped to be wrong. I hope you guys are right about his shot and release, that will be exciting to watch .
And remember when we re-signed Helle and Scheifele and everyone laughed at us because we should be rebuilding. Love or hate Chevy in some of his decisions, but this team is built for long term success.I'm still leery of Lucius' injury history. I need to see him survive a lot longer than he has so far.
I'm not that down on Barlow, but for now, others have passed him.
Freij is only that low because he hasn't come to NA and succeeded here yet. I expect him to climb fairly quickly but time will tell.
I still have high hopes for DD but his sv% in the ECHL is nothing special. He still has 2-3 years to develop.
Lambert still has quite a way to go. Its a little hard to judge with the Moose being so bad this year but he is one of the players who should be leading them to better results if he is truly a top 6 prospect.
Chibrikov showed well in his few NHL games but he hasn't been as good as hoped in the AHL this year either.
Salomonsson and Yager are my untouchables right now.
Salomonsson
Yager
Chibrikov
Walton
Lambert
He
Freij
Barlow
Divincentiis
Lucius
It appears I'm in the minority here but also pretty comfortable letting this one stand the test of time.I appreciate Walton's progress this year but to put him ahead of Team Canada's U20 captain after half a season is premature IMHO
Salomonsson
Yager
Lambert
Chibs
Walton
He
DD
Friej
Lucius
Barlow
Hopefully Friej makes his way to the moose next season. I have a feeling we're sleeping on him a bit
And remember when we re-signed Helle and Scheifele and everyone laughed at us because we should be rebuilding. Love or hate Chevy in some of his decisions, but this team is built for long term success.
I still think Yager's #1 because it's likely IMO he becomes a 2C before Salomonsson becomes a top 4 NHL D. That would be the way I saw TC.I appreciate Walton's progress this year but to put him ahead of Team Canada's U20 captain after half a season is premature IMHO
Salomonsson
Yager
Lambert
Chibs
Walton
He
DD
Friej
Lucius
Barlow
Hopefully Friej makes his way to the moose next season. I have a feeling we're sleeping on him a bit
I guess if you're basing it on potential ceilings, then maybeIt appears I'm in the minority here but also pretty comfortable letting this one stand the test of time.
Everyone's criteria ranking these guys is different so I don't want to get too scientific about it.
I am ranking them on their likely impact one day and it just seems like Walton ceiling is so much higher than Yager right now from my POV
I appreciate Walton's progress this year but to put him ahead of Team Canada's U20 captain after half a season is premature IMHO
Salomonsson
Yager
Lambert
Chibs
Walton
He
DD
Friej
Lucius
Barlow
Hopefully Friej makes his way to the moose next season. I have a feeling we're sleeping on him a bit
There is always a tendency to focus on recent trends with prospects, and Walton and He are on a heater this season. But all top prospects have had their moments and it's a bit hard to rank.I guess if you're basing it on potential ceilings, then maybe
Not sure how much you know about Yager...
For a long time he was projected as a top 5 pick until his production dipped during his draft year
He won CHL rookie of the year (same year as Bedard was a rookie)
In his D+1 season, he put up 1.67 points per game while playing a solid 2-way pro style
I'm not sure why you'd have Walton ahead of him other than he's the shinier, newer toy. Or maybe it's the underdog effect of him being a late round pick
This is pretty close to how I’d rank the top ten as well. I’d swap Yags and Salmon but that’s about it.I appreciate Walton's progress this year but to put him ahead of Team Canada's U20 captain after half a season is premature IMHO
Salomonsson
Yager
Lambert
Chibs
Walton
He
DD
Friej
Lucius
Barlow
Hopefully Friej makes his way to the moose next season. I have a feeling we're sleeping on him a bit
I'll take a guy with high end tools that makes a huge leap over a guy who is showing steadier, more leveled off progress. Just prefer that as a better indicator of upside than consistency from age D-1 to D+2. A sharp upwards trajectory is pretty much the best green flag there is in prospects. Especially after their draft year.I guess if you're basing it on potential ceilings, then maybe
Not sure how much you know about Yager...
For a long time he was projected as a top 5 pick until his production dipped during his draft year
He won CHL rookie of the year (same year as Bedard was a rookie)
In his D+1 season, he put up 1.67 points per game while playing a solid 2-way pro style
I'm not sure why you'd have Walton ahead of him other than he's the shinier, newer toy. Or maybe it's the underdog effect of him being a late round pick