Random thought, unrelated to prospects, that jumped into my head.
You mentioned +/- and most of us operate under the impression that it has limited value as a statistic of meaning. But is that true of defensemen?
When I think about +/- I think about the forward making a line change that is on the ice or one that just comes on the ice when the other team scores. They're not in the play but they are given a -1 for being on the ice. That's where some of the limit of the value of the measure is in my mind.
But is that true of a D? They don't tend to change when the puck is coming into our zone so never really have that opportunity to not be involved in the play when scoring occurs. Obviously it can happen in odd ways and so it's not impossible, just less likely than a forward.
I guess my question is has anyone looked closely at the measure and separated it out for D vs. F?
Statistical measures are rarely ever as straightforward as we like so I wonder if there's some nuance there that someone may be able to be more informative about
@garret9