Highly doubt he beats out Gagner, Toninato sure.
Yeah, I'd bet that unless Gagner completely lost his legs in the offseason he's more than capable of beating out one of Toninato or Eyssimont. I wouldn't be surprised at all if it ends up with Eyssimont beating out both though, with Gagner essentially being the 12th forward on the depth chart.
Toninato and Eyssimont could be a wash though, they both bring similar elements. If Toninato or Eyssimont aren't scoring I'd hope that the new staff makes a switch rather than just continually running the same shit and hoping something changes.