Guentzel is a good player and he would return quite a bit. But Dallas needs a RHD to partner with Heiskanen not another winger. I also can’t see them moving Bourque for a soon to be UFA.
Value of: Jake Guentzel as a rental
- Thread starter Gurglesons
- Start date
Ledge And Dairy
Registered User
No he doesn't, MacKinnon has 23 5v5 points, Guentzel has 21. Empty net points don't count as 5v5 points.
Lets not pretend that riding passenger to Crosby doesn't play a major factor. Yes Jake is a very good player but he is no where near the level of dominance that Hossa brought, especially with his 2-way game.
Not even right handed because Miro has played RD for years now. What they need is a top pairing dman. Someone who isn't turning 39 in January and being completely carried at this point
66-30-33
Registered User
Ledge And Dairy
Registered User
66-30-33
Registered User
I only follow NHL.com which does general stats, not cherry picked stats.
hamzarocks
Registered User
I wouldn't do Bourque straight for Guentzel/Nylander/Reinhart type player if I were Stars management/fans
Bourque will be a 60-80 pt guy for 10 years soon. He is an elite prospect.
Him, Stankoven, Wyatt Johnson will be an insane group of secondary core pieces to Hintz, Robertson, Oettinger, and Heiskanen
The stars should not make any trade for a buy now UFA.
This year try to win with the deep team you have. The team is as good if not better than the WCF 2023 stars team.
Next year add two elite young players to the roster that is very deep.
You avoid overpaying for an elite current player who has risk of steep decline due to change in system/environment/or simply injuries & natural age regression 2-3 years into his deal
Bourque will be a 60-80 pt guy for 10 years soon. He is an elite prospect.
Him, Stankoven, Wyatt Johnson will be an insane group of secondary core pieces to Hintz, Robertson, Oettinger, and Heiskanen
The stars should not make any trade for a buy now UFA.
This year try to win with the deep team you have. The team is as good if not better than the WCF 2023 stars team.
Next year add two elite young players to the roster that is very deep.
You avoid overpaying for an elite current player who has risk of steep decline due to change in system/environment/or simply injuries & natural age regression 2-3 years into his deal
M88K
irreverent
- May 24, 2014
- 9,798
- 7,969
66-30-33
Registered User
That's fine, we don't make good trading partners. Stars need D, not more scoring wingers.
M88K
irreverent
- May 24, 2014
- 9,798
- 7,969
You’re assuming some rather negative value to Marchment in this proposal.
take out Bourque and value seems more like it.
KrisLeturnover
Registered User
- Jan 17, 2021
- 267
- 267
It seems that extension talks aren't coming together as hoped.
Via The Athletic:
Also, given the stagnant play of the Penguins and where they are in the standings, it looks like Jake could be reaching for greener pastures.
I think a 1st + solid prospect make sense. After all, he is a multiple 40g scorer. Anyone have ideas as to where he might fit? Potential speculative in-depth trade ideas are welcome. His contract carries a 6M tag for the remainder of this season and he has a modified NTC.
Via The Athletic:
Also, given the stagnant play of the Penguins and where they are in the standings, it looks like Jake could be reaching for greener pastures.
I think a 1st + solid prospect make sense. After all, he is a multiple 40g scorer. Anyone have ideas as to where he might fit? Potential speculative in-depth trade ideas are welcome. His contract carries a 6M tag for the remainder of this season and he has a modified NTC.
OgeeOgelthorpe
Riccis per 60 record holder
- Feb 29, 2020
- 18,235
- 19,907
Pick two of...
Daniel Sprong, Jonatan Berggren, Rob Fabbri, Andrew Copp, and a 1st
We'll give you a 4th if you take Jeff Petry back.
Wallet Inspector
Registered User
- Jan 19, 2013
- 6,273
- 5,809
Vancouver should nab him, get a proper winger for Pettersson.
Heavily discussed on our boards. Pettersson needs a top line winger he can feed off of rather than having to play with Mikheyev, Lafferty, Suter and whatever else depth guy we have.
Guentzel would be ideal + the Pittsburgh connection he has with Tocc/Rutherford
AintLifeGrand
Burnin Jet-A
To Pitt: Egor Afansyev, Dante Fabbro, 2024 2nd
To Nash: Guentzel
Forsberg- ROR-Nyquist
Guentzel-Novak- Tomasino
Parsinnen-Sissons- Evangelista
Smith-Mccaron-Trenin
To Nash: Guentzel
Forsberg- ROR-Nyquist
Guentzel-Novak- Tomasino
Parsinnen-Sissons- Evangelista
Smith-Mccaron-Trenin
He'll resign I think. Carter comes off the books this summer so Guentzel can take most (or all) of that. Whilst the Pens are still in the hunt for a Playoff spot, they'll not want to get rid of one of their main goal scorers.
The only way he gets traded is if they are so far off the playoffs that the season is done and he has no intention of staying, which would be surprising considering he gets to play alongside Crosby and will get paid a good amount.
I suppose there could be a scenario where they are out of the hunt and he wants to return next year, so they trade him for assets, he gets a cup run and then the assets can be used to improve next year's team.
The only way he gets traded is if they are so far off the playoffs that the season is done and he has no intention of staying, which would be surprising considering he gets to play alongside Crosby and will get paid a good amount.
I suppose there could be a scenario where they are out of the hunt and he wants to return next year, so they trade him for assets, he gets a cup run and then the assets can be used to improve next year's team.
He’s also young enough to realize Pens cup contending window has closed years ago and is likely closed for the foreseeable future and if he wants to win another cup, he’s going to have to leave to get it.
A 1st + a very good prospect feels like it'd be too much, although I wonder if something can be done for Kuzmenko+ for Guentzel.
After getting Karlsson and whilst Crosby and Malkin are still playing, I don't think that they think their window is closed. They can offer him a big contract, and if he wants to move after the next couple of years (likely the absolute final hurrah for the window), he can move on, and the team rebuilds.
I don't think their window is closed, they just need to find a way to close out games. Karlsson has been better than advertised/playing at a Norris level again, Crosby is still playing at an elite level, Malkin has also been very good - the production appears to be down on the surface but when you really look into it their power play hasn't been clicking. They've been getting good goaltending as well, just the two issues which should be fixable with the veterans they have on their team to close out games and the talent they have at their disposal to score on the PP - I think in terms of talent they can ice a PP unit that should be top-5 in the league pretty easily.
Gurglesons
Registered User
Why is that exactly?
When was a player of Jake's ability and playoff reputation making 3 million (50% retained if traded) moved?
KrisLeturnover
Registered User
- Jan 17, 2021
- 267
- 267
Interesting point. I could very well see Rutherford going in hard to get a deal done.
Maninthebox87
Registered User
molon labe
Registered User
Quite a few teams with young C's might be considering some major spending this Summer and I'm thinking that, as much as Jake has enjoyed it here - his 'camp' (family/friends) might be reminding him before any sentimentality.
Chicago and Vancouver stand out.
Not sure what we can even move him for now with trade protection and whatever other player involved with trade protection. But if there's not headway on anything that makes sense they shouldn't be stupid about it. Frankly of all the years this year it's not even like we would feel like we're missing much - the team so far has felt like a one man show.
Chicago and Vancouver stand out.
Not sure what we can even move him for now with trade protection and whatever other player involved with trade protection. But if there's not headway on anything that makes sense they shouldn't be stupid about it. Frankly of all the years this year it's not even like we would feel like we're missing much - the team so far has felt like a one man show.
