Is Peter Forsberg underrated?

Has Forsberg become underrated?

  • Yes indeed

  • Maybe slightly

  • Not at all

  • He’s actually overrated


Results are only viewable after voting.

authentic

Registered User
Jan 28, 2015
26,446
11,422
Hello, new here and this thread caught my eye!

I’ve seen a lot of credible, ex-players, call Forsberg “the best there was”, “most talented ever” etc.

I’ve also heard stars of today have him as one of their idols (Crosby for example).

But here I see a bunch of posters calling him “overrated”? I see people are mentioning injuries and stuff, but that’s another discussion…? Are people here just very very young, or is there a lot of bias against Forsberg here? Maybe fans of teams he played or…?

Well it’s not exactly a hard call to make. All one has to do is watch the player in his prime and he looks far closer to what actual NHL players past and present describe than what half of HF will tell you.
 

Pablo El Perro

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Oct 10, 2007
26,108
14,003
Hello, new here and this thread caught my eye!

I’ve seen a lot of credible, ex-players, call Forsberg “the best there was”, “most talented ever” etc.

I’ve also heard stars of today have him as one of their idols (Crosby for example).

But here I see a bunch of posters calling him “overrated”? I see people are mentioning injuries and stuff, but that’s another discussion…? Are people here just very very young, or is there a lot of bias against Forsberg here? Maybe fans of teams he played or…?
Overrated doesn't mean he wasn't a great HOF player.
 

Hallonbroder

Registered User
Nov 29, 2024
2
1
Overrated doesn't mean he wasn't a great HOF player.
Sure, sure, but what about him is overrated?

His playmaking skills are in the top 10 ever (4th in APG all time, playing in the DPE speaks for itself, including the eye test).

His shot - sure he preferred assists to goals, according to himself, but he’s got a higher GPG in the playoffs than Crosby and other greats.

His physicality- played a hard, sometimes ugly game that hockey fans loved.

Selkie-level defense.

Skated eights around other teams in their d-zone long before the Karlssons, Crosbys and Makar’s did. But he did it when other players used him as a sleigh.

Big-game player, stepped up when it mattered for both club and country.

Amazing playoff stats.

What does people tend to overrate?
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad