Is Matthews the worst playoff performer ever? | Page 3 | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League

Is Matthews the worst playoff performer ever?

He’s very clearly injured and has been all season. At some point a decision was made not to shut him down. Maybe due to recovery needing to be quite long. He hasn’t been himself all year. It’s highlighted more now, but this isn’t even normal playoff Matthew’s. it sucks to see a guy with his talent unable to play his game.
It’s funny how every time he’s bad, he’s “injured”. Is he injured every playoffs because his play nosedives every year. He goes from superstar to 2 way, 2nd line centre like clockwork.

He’s done nothing in the playoffs in almost 10 years
 
For what he is paid, what he has done in the regular season, and for the players he is often lumped in with. He needs to up his game in the playoffs.

McDavid 133 pts in 83 PGP
Draisaitl 123 pts in 83 PGP
Mackinnon 124 pts in 95 PGP

Matthews 58 pts in 65 PGP
But who looks better with a purse?
1747018396602.jpeg
 
Who said that?

It’s been well documented all season long. He even flew to Germany to have it addressed.

Deciding to ignore what’s been in front of us all season doesn’t make it illegitimate.

Leafs fans say it every year

for example here's you personally talking about Matthews being injured last year about this time:

I mean the guy was injured clearly. He still came back and set up the only Leafs goal tonight.

The team is just poorly built.

Who knows what they’ll do this off season. Probably something stupid.
 
But 3 goals in the last 19 games?
Not arguing that. He has been disappointing. Hes still found ways to produce despite not being able to score. But I also commented on how hes not even shooting the way he should be able to. You can see it in his game.

Leafs need more from him, and tonight he did not look good at all, but almost nobody on the team did either.
 
He’s very clearly injured and has been all season. At some point a decision was made not to shut him down. Maybe due to recovery needing to be quite long. He hasn’t been himself all year. It’s highlighted more now, but this isn’t even normal playoff Matthew’s. it sucks to see a guy with his talent unable to play his game.
Agreed nobody understands he's been injured the last 8 years in the playoffs. Very misunderstood player.
 
Yeah injuries as an excuse is tired but I haven’t seen him take a single good shot on net since that puck hit his hand in the Ottawa series. Even the goal he scored in Game 6 looked like he fanned on it and it snuck in.

Panthers know what and where to target and hit right now.
 
This is why I could never get behind Erik Karlsson. Seemed to care more about his styling than winning
Karlsson drug a team that was lucky to be in the playoffs to the conference finals and was the best player on the ice every time he was on it.

Not once in his career has Matthews done anything like that. To be fair, not many can though. He was incredible
 
He's apparently been injured every season except for when he scored 60 goals.

It's old.
injury doesn't prevent the very best from performing, look at McDavid last year, he was setting records while hurt, still contributing to the team. When you are paid like these guys are, you have to contribute and be a major part of the team success. A goal scoring not scoring goals isn't good enough.
 
I cant think of a worse example of a skater whose play so consistently drops off every playoffs and I’ve been watching hockey for 30 years.

This guy is supposed to be a superstar and has a C on his jersey now and it’s the same old. 60 goal man in the regular season, 30 goal pace in the playoffs at best. He wasn’t good at 4 nations either.

It’s time to stop making excuses for this guy IMO.

Yashin
 
Karlsson drug a team that was lucky to be in the playoffs to the conference finals and was the best player on the ice every time he was on it.

Not once in his career has Matthews done anything like that. To be fair, not many can though. He was incredible
He had his moments but I just never sensed a consistent,burning desire to win
 
he was going balls out trying to hit a meaningless personal milestone in games 81 and 82 and had nothing left in the tank for the playoffs. Not captain material.
I mean if thats a stretch you want to make thats fine. Players do push for milestones and 70 goals would’ve been a special one. Maybe Shanahan should’ve marched to the dressing room after 82 and ripped the C right off his chest
 
  • Haha
Reactions: thaman8765678
It’s a European-style male handbag. Not a purse.
Whatever. If a guy is going to show up to the rink with that look he sure as hell better back it up. Play hard and tough and lead your club to the Cup. If that’s not on your dna, then don’t dress like a Fop.
Matthews dresses like he wants the spotlight. Earn that presence.
 
Whatever. If a guy is going to show up to the rink with that look he sure as hell better back it up. Play hard and tough and lead your club to the Cup. If that’s not on your dna, then don’t dress like a Fop.
Matthews dresses like he wants the spotlight. Earn that presence.
To me, it only proves that Matthews has good taste and flair.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Ad

Ad