Is Leon Draisaitl on pace to be the best non-“big six” nation hockey player ever?

[McPoyle]

Oilers fans getting in a Jimmy over a different opinion. Shocking.

You think Chara is a 55 goal scorer on the Oilers?

 

[McFlash97]

Doubtful, nothing more than a wild assumption that that Draisaitl would make that big of an impact on another team.


It’s a Draisaitl thread and not a McDavid thread.

Doesn't matter though, you seem to be all over every single Oiler thread.

 

[McFlash97]

Oilers fans getting in a Jimmy over a different opinion. Shocking.

The opinion would have to be something that makes logical sense....If I believe unicorns are real, I would expect people who try to correct me. Just human nature

 

[Three On Zero]

Doesn't matter though, you seem to be all over every single Oiler thread.

Hockey fans use a hockey forum to comment on hockey related topics, what a shocking revelation. I could always just post in threads to discuss the forum users and not the actual topic

 

[Skolman]

Doesn't matter though, you seem to be all over every single Oiler thread.

Dude spends more time talking about the Oilers than any other team on here, it's weird.

 

[PuckG]

Dude spends more time talking about the Oilers than any other team on here, it's weird.

It’s shit analysis too.

“I can assume Draisaitl is worse on another team, but you can’t assume Draisaitl is the same or better.”

Makes no sense whatsoever and has no wherewithal to apply his own arguments consistently.

 

[McFlash97]

 

[Nemesis Prime]

Maybe, if you started watching hockey in 2021. Kopitar will not be passed anytime soon

Draisaitl has passed Kopitar, he can't even see Kopitar. Kopitar is a dot to him.

 

[Duke74]

It’s shit analysis too.

“I can assume Draisaitl is worse on another team, but you can’t assume Draisaitl is the same or better.”

Makes no sense whatsoever and has no wherewithal to apply his own arguments consistently.

 

[McAsuno]

Oilers fans getting in a Jimmy over a different opinion. Shocking.

You're referring to Zdeno Chara, right? AKA a defenseman who career high in goals was 19 and points was 52. How the f*** would Chara put up the 'same' numbers, exactly? Nobody has to be an Oiler fan to clown that ridiculous post of yours.

 

[FinlandPanther]

You're referring to Zdeno Chara, right? AKA a defenseman who career high in goals was 19 and points was 52. How the f*** would Chara put up the 'same' numbers, exactly? Nobody has to be an Oiler fan to clown that ridiculous post of yours.

Obviously that means Zdeno Chara would put up NUMBERS. He would put up better numbers than Bouchard who has become grossly overrated riding Mcdavid’s coattails just like Leon.

 

[PuckG]

Obviously that means Zdeno Chara would put up NUMBERS. He would put up better numbers than Bouchard who has become grossly overrated riding Mcdavid’s coattails just like Leon.

Great…another goofy poster that makes assumptions and just pretends it’s a fact.

So who should we deduct on the Panthers?

Reinhart plays with Barkov correct? Who’s riding who’s coattails and is overrated?

I’m going to assume Barkov is overrated and is really only a 70 point player because apparently that’s what every moronic poster on here can do now.

Or do your assumptions only apply to the Oilers?

 

[Three On Zero]

Obviously that means Zdeno Chara would put up NUMBERS. He would put up better numbers than Bouchard who has become grossly overrated riding Mcdavid’s coattails just like Leon.

Eh, Chara is a weird one because he wasn’t exactly an offensive defenceman. I don’t see him benefiting much from a new team. Draisaitl could move up this list if he proves he can be the type of player he is without McDavid

Mikita (depending how you define him)
P. Statsny (depending how you define him)
Kopitar
Hossa
Draisaitl
Chara
A. Statsny
Bondra
Gaborik
Josi

 

[Duke74]

Obviously that means Zdeno Chara would put up NUMBERS. He would put up better numbers than Bouchard who has become grossly overrated riding Mcdavid’s coattails just like Leon.

I didn't think this was rocket science, but players that win multiple major awards don't ride coattails of other players. Either do players with 3 50-goal seasons and 5 100-point seasons. Putting up these types of numbers one year is a fluke, but doing it most years is a pattern of a player that's obviously elite with or without the help of others.

 

[McPoyle]

I didn't think this was rocket science, but players that win multiple major awards don't ride coattails of other players. Either do players with 3 50-goal seasons and 5 100-point seasons. Putting up these types of numbers one year is a fluke, but doing it most years is a pattern of a player that's obviously elite with or without the help of others.

Yep exactly. 50-50 seasons are a rare elite thing showing a player can be both a top level scorer and playmaker. In the last 15 years there have been 11 50-50 seasons.

Crosby x 1
MacKinnon x 1
Malkin x 1
Pastrnak x 1
Rantanen x 1
McDavid x 1
Ovechkin x 2

and Draisaitl x 3

He is one of the best players in the league the last decade and I can't help but laugh at people still saying he is a product of another player.

 

[FinlandPanther]

Great…another goofy poster that makes assumptions and just pretends it’s a fact.

So who should we deduct on the Panthers?

Reinhart plays with Barkov correct? Who’s riding who’s coattails and is overrated?

I’m going to assume Barkov is overrated and is really only a 70 point player because apparently that’s what every moronic poster on here can do now.

Or do your assumptions only apply to the Oilers?

Barkov is a better player than Reinhart. Mcdavid is a better player than Draisaitl. Hope this helps.

 

[PuckG]

Barkov is a better player than Reinhart. Mcdavid is a better player than Draisaitl. Hope this helps.

Great, so how much does Reinhart ride the coattails of Barkov and how overrated is he? How many pegs should we knock him down or how many points should we deduct?

I’m sure you have some way of consistently applying this across players and teams, right?

 

[McAsuno]

Obviously that means Zdeno Chara would put up NUMBERS. He would put up better numbers than Bouchard who has become grossly overrated riding Mcdavid’s coattails just like Leon.

Yeah sure he would! Nothing but hyperbole nonsense from you. Best players make others better, what a fricken concept. By your logic, Reinhart should get viewed upon as inferior because he plays with the likes of Barkov. Keep moving your goal post. You're just making yourself look more ridiculous.

 

[McFlash97]

Eh, Chara is a weird one because he wasn’t exactly an offensive defenceman. I don’t see him benefiting much from a new team. Draisaitl could move up this list if he proves he can be the type of player he is without McDavid

Mikita (depending how you define him)
P. Statsny (depending how you define him)
Kopitar
Hossa
Draisaitl
Chara
A. Statsny
Bondra
Gaborik
Josi

Solid list there guy. Draisaitl will have to put up 10 100 plus point seasons just to get on this vaunted list

 

[wetcoast]

Eh, Chara is a weird one because he wasn’t exactly an offensive defenceman. I don’t see him benefiting much from a new team. Draisaitl could move up this list if he proves he can be the type of player he is without McDavid

Mikita (depending how you define him)
P. Statsny (depending how you define him)
Kopitar
Hossa
Draisaitl
Chara
A. Statsny
Bondra
Gaborik
Josi

Sure I can get into this list if it's a right now question and one really, really values career over prime by a large degree but there are a couple of problems here.

Firstly, for all practical purposes Mikita was a Canadian hockey player and people trying to state otherwise are being too cute by half.

Stastny was a great player but Draisaitl has by quite a bit the better prime and playoff resume already.

Same thing with Srai to Kopitar, drai's prime and playoff resume are just that much better.

The comparison comes down to this in a nutshell.

Kopitar has 17 seasons of 60-94 points adjusted with some really good defensive play in there.

Drai has 8 seasons at 72-128 points with 6 seasons at 100+ and a more prolific playoff resume.

right now sure someone could take Kopitar but really the poll question is about pace and barring a catastrophic career ending injury how much does Drai really need here to be top on this list?

Stastny BTW has 10 seasons with 61-102 points adjusted so not really sure why you have him ahead of Kopitar.