- Jul 21, 2022
- 2,330
- 2,379
McDavid signed $12.5m x 8y in 2017, it was 16.6% of the cap
Eichel signed $10m x 8y in 2017, it was 13.3% of the cap
Hughes signed $8m x 8y in 2021, it was 9.8% of the cap
Stutzle signed $8.35m x 8y in 2022, it was 10.1% of the cap
McDavid was already a Top 5 center in the league when that contract was signed, so there's no comparison.
Hughes was seriously struggling to be an effective Top 6 Center in the NHL when he signed that contract. Bedard has his issues, but his first two years has clearly been better than Hughes' first two years, so that's not a good comparison either.
Stutzle didn't have the same hype as Bedard, and his production didn't pop off until after he signed.
Interestingly, both Ottawa and New Jersey had history of giving out early, risky contracts to young players, and (consequently) they had internal precedents and also provided more offensive support for Hughes/Stutzle than Bedard has had.
Eichel hadn't even established himself as first line center when Buffalo irresponsibly turned the franchise over to him. He had similar production to Bedard and was similarly one-dimmensional, so if Chicago wants to go the fake-it-til-you-hopefully-make-it route and pay for Bedard's draft hype, Eichel might actually be a decent comparable.
13.3% of $92.5m is $12.3m. Voted for $12.5m because after arbitrary math and a cursory look at history, I won't be surprised if this is the number--even if it's undeserved.
Slaf got an 8mil contract for 1 half a season. Bedard is obviously better, it wont surprise me they use him as bench mark and give Bedard the moon.