mrmovies779
The Greatest Teacher,Failure is.
- Feb 5, 2013
- 7,553
- 7,594
I'm also giving him a big extension and not giving a f*** about it either
Player Discussion Igor Shesterkin
- Thread starter Brooklyn Rangers Fan
- Start date
I know I'm known as the local Shesterkin hater here but why did people get on him for allowing that second goal? Pretty clearly went off Trouba. I know we didn't play well (at least according to the people here) but they had more lucky goals.
Crease
Chief Justice of the HFNYR Court
- Jul 12, 2004
- 24,551
- 27,007
Main board consensus is that he is the leading Conn Smythe candidate.
mrmovies779
The Greatest Teacher,Failure is.
- Feb 5, 2013
- 7,553
- 7,594
As well he should be...he's been phenomenal so far
The fact Igor is doing what he's doing behind this defense is amazing.Same shit Hank did year after year
I didn't like goals 1 or 4. Those are both shots he should have stopped.
He didn't let up anything after that and there were many opportunities for him to do so. All that matters.
He didn't let up anything after that and there were many opportunities for him to do so. All that matters.
McRanger92
Registered User
- Jun 7, 2017
- 11,660
- 21,761
He’s let up some goals he himself would call soft in this series, but the grade A saves have far outweighed them.
2Leetch_94
Kreid Me A River
Goalies are going to allow goals. Can't be bothered to dissect every GA unless it's happening late in games or OT and directly leading to tough losses. Igor will have a goal here and there that he should probably save, no question about it, but the goals he should probably allow but doesn't so far out weight them it's stupid to try and harp on it all the time.
Just be blessed about the sort of goaltending the Rangers have had for basically forever, I can name quite a few fan bases in this league that would love to have our less than perfect goalies in net over the last couple decades.
Just be blessed about the sort of goaltending the Rangers have had for basically forever, I can name quite a few fan bases in this league that would love to have our less than perfect goalies in net over the last couple decades.
He half heartedly went for the poke check right as Reinhardt shot.
The Forsling goal was a walk in snipe from the lady’s tee.
Did y'all see his quote about whether Tkachuk's chirps are getting to him? "I'm lucky I don't speak English". 
The Crypto Guy
Registered User
- Jun 26, 2017
- 28,359
- 37,018
I noticed the "DONT GIVE IGOR AN EXTENTION" crowd has been very silent during the playoffs.
Almost like they are realizing how important a good goalie can be...and how an average one can cost you the playoffs.
Almost like they are realizing how important a good goalie can be...and how an average one can cost you the playoffs.
EdJovanovski
#RempeForCalder
I remember when we signed him to that contract I’d say the majority of fans here were saying it’s a bad deal and giving him too much for too long. I was saying it’s a bad deal because we should’ve locked him up longer.
Igor certainly held the fort and then some after he gave up the 4th goal on Sunday but since the beginning of game 4 vs Carolina he's really been painfully average.
Hes given up 7 goals in this series, 4 of them were ones he should have had and 2 of those were just flat out bad.
Is he wearing down or is this just a small "blip" in the radar (and I'll call it a blip because he hasn't been that bad)? If its a blip, we're in amazing shape because he's more than capable of stealing a bunch of games.
I think most people were on your side of the fence who wanted a longer deal with more UFA years eaten.
Hes given up 7 goals in this series, 4 of them were ones he should have had and 2 of those were just flat out bad.
Is he wearing down or is this just a small "blip" in the radar (and I'll call it a blip because he hasn't been that bad)? If its a blip, we're in amazing shape because he's more than capable of stealing a bunch of games.
I think most people were on your side of the fence who wanted a longer deal with more UFA years eaten.
EdJovanovski
#RempeForCalder
I just went back and read the thread, most were saying it's a huge overpayment and huge gamble on a goalie with 40-something NHL games
I feel like sometimes fans forget about the softies when he makes big saves but I guess you it could argue that works both ways. We might have still lost that game but he was a big part of the loss in game 1 and game 3 he was a wall after it went 4-4 but he also gave up 4 goals. I don't know if he's been average but people do tend to ignore when he gives up bad goals.
Our fans or rival fans?
Because we could have signed him for 8 years at league minimum and opposing fans would have said it was a bad deal.
In my memory I remember in his sophore season our fans said we should draft another goalie. I'm not getting on anyone as everyone knows I've killed him enough (just like Hank), just clarifying.
tlk
hARry kane comeS homE
Truth hurts I guess.
G4 vs Carolina and G1 of the current series were objectively bad games.
I think he deserves a ton of credit for holding the line in G3 of the current series, but 2 of those 4 GA's against weren't good. Same applies to G6 of the Carolina series though that wasn't a necessity due to his own making, his team let him down until they didn't.
Compare that to every game that proceeded it where he gave up maybe 1 bad or even iffy goal in the first 7 games. He's had 7 in the last 6.
tlk
hARry kane comeS homE
I'm happy that I'm not taking crazy pills and @GoAwayPanarin sees what I see. Largely excellent but completely uneven performances. He gave up a goal that was not any better than Anderson's game 6 goal and Skinner's goal last game in the third period that people have said you can't win with goaltending like that. Yet we're supposed to pretend like it didn't happen. He's been largely top 3 best players in this series, maybe top 4 since I think Goodrow was more opportunistic. But let's not pretend that a huge percentage of the goals he has allowed this series were anything but complete stinkers. If I were to look at the playoff on the whole these goals would be up there with the goal in game 3 against Washington.
And he largely was amazing don't get me wrong but he doesn't get absolved for ECHL level nonsense goals. There exists a world where "he gives up too many stinkers" and "he's been saving our asses for the most part" are both true.
And he largely was amazing don't get me wrong but he doesn't get absolved for ECHL level nonsense goals. There exists a world where "he gives up too many stinkers" and "he's been saving our asses for the most part" are both true.
aufheben
#Norris4Fox
Igor had saved 45 goals above expected in his last I think 42 playoff games. That’s like the other team starting -1 against us every game.
If he should have been better, if he should deliver a cup on his own, then he should also make 20% on his next contract.
mrmovies779
The Greatest Teacher,Failure is.
- Feb 5, 2013
- 7,553
- 7,594
Not good enough.He gives up a softie every few games.He isn't perfect therefore he's a bum
