If MTL/TOR/OTT had a redraft, what would your top 10 look like?

[SNES]

Matthews
Stu
Marner/Brady
Nylander
Suzuki
Sanderson
Batherson
Caufield
Laine
Knies

 

[Golden_Jet]

Matthews
Stu
Marner/Brady
Nylander
Suzuki
Sanderson
Batherson
Caufield
Laine
Knies

Nice, you snuck in an honourable mention at 11

 

[34]

Wooooooof! No wonder no one takes you seriously…yeesh

He is not wrong.

i'd be pretty disappointed if stutzle potential was only mitch marner tbh.

which isn't bad but stutzle looking special special so far, so marner would be a let down.

Be prepared to disappointed as he not half the player Marner is.

 

[DackellDuck]

Matthews
Stützle
Marner
Tkachuk
Nylander
Sanderson
Suzuki
Caufield
Batherson
Reilly

 

[CanadienShark]

As a Habs fan, Caufield is too high and Guhle ≠ Sanderson. And Matthews is clearly #1.

 

[CanadienShark]

Why is Toronto being compared with teams who can't sniff the playoffs? And why are you ranking guys who have proven less than Toronto's players ahead of them?

It's just sad when fans try and pretend because they haven't been in the final 4 they are basically the same as teams who can't escape the bottom 10.

Edit: Just noticed Hutson ranked ahead of Marner and Nylander LMFAO

What about the Habs players that made the SCF? So not only final 4, but final 2.

 

[LPHabsFan]

This thread should make a Top 10 List of "Ways to start an Internet fight". It'll be low, like between 8 and 10, but it's definitely there.

 

[Atomos2]

i'd be pretty disappointed if stutzle potential was only mitch marner tbh.

which isn't bad but stutzle looking special special so far, so marner would be a let down.

Potential*

What would the Sens be without that term?

 

[Phion Keneuf]

Good God. I expected OP to be bad, but Stutzle first and Hutson 3rd is epically bad.

 

[Commander Clueless]

So if I'm playing this game correctly, you would presumably be drafting say 1st and 4th, or 2nd and 5th, etc. etc. rather than all at once.

I think that likely pushes the Leaf players higher up the list than might otherwise be true when factoring in contracts. You have more space if you can get a cheaper contract later in the draft.

Am I cooking?

 

[Nogatco Rd]

Thread needs more nick Jensen

 

[The90]

Yes we aware leafs record is less than 3 rounds ever, we’ve discussed that already.

Yes. Same amount of cups as both Montreal and Ottawa. That’s correct. A mighty fine looking participation ribbon though.

 

[DackellDuck]

Potential*

What would the Sens be without that term?

Considering current production, position, age, and contract status, I think most teams would take Stützle over Marner if we’re talking about “starting a franchise”.

 

[Random Comment]

Considering current production, position, age, and contract status, I think most teams would take Stützle over Marner if we’re talking about “starting a franchise”.

Every franchise would. Look at their contracts.

Matthews
Stutzle
Marner
Tkachuk
Nylander
Suzuki
Sanderson
Caufield
Slafkovsky
Hutson

 

[Mackiaveli]

As a Habs fan, Caufield is too high and Guhle ≠ Sanderson. And Matthews is clearly #1.

Fair - I think Sanderson has a higher ceiling than Guhle and I don't watch the Sens enough to know how much of him being caved in this season defensively is because his partner is Hamonic - I also think in today's league two-way guys like Sanderson are slightly less valuable than first-pass DFDs

Caufield to me is a future MSL - I don't know if I see him being a 50/30 player as much as I see him being a 40/50 player in the future.

I put a lot of stock in contract in my list - both $ and term - as well as age - whereas some people here seem to only value the quality of the player as they are today. For example, I know Matthews and Marner are both considerably better players than Stutzle today, but I think Stutzle's contract is incredible value-wise vs an expiring Marner and a 13m, oft injured Matthews when building a franchise around a single player.

 

[Rob Brown]

And never won 3 rounds ever.

Where is your list

He literally never said that. He correctly corrected the guy that said the Leafs haven't sniffed the second round.

And if playoff success was the most important criteria in the context of this thread, then Tkachuk, Stutzle, Hutson wouldn't be in the list at all.

If people were being honest here the top 5 would be Matthews, Marner, Nylander, Tkachuk, and Stutzle in whichever order. Matthews is clearly the best of the three teams, though.