nope. try again. is reading comprehension a problem for you?
I said that the results, as in the teams results, would barely be any different with Guentzel on the team, playing with Zibanejad. maybe we would have 2 or 3 more wins or something? Guentzel has 10 even strength goals (playing with better players than he would here) and Smith has 6, there's an objective metric for you. it would do nothing to help any of the major problems this team has.
and then I said that Smith has been fine for what he is, in that he is a player we got off the scrap heap that doesn't have a huge cap hit. he's on a 40 point pace, that seems fine to me? is that an objective enough metric for you?