How in the Blue Hell is Jordan Binnington the best Canada goaltender?

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
...no, I admitted he was great in the 2nd half of last nights game; probably a half dozen times today...doesn't take away the fact that he was mediocre for most of the tournament...sorry facts are hard, amigo... :biglaugh:
None of the goals against in the championship game were on him, and most of the so called “soft” goals Canada fans were squawking about all tournament were not really on him either. Blaming the goalie for a perfect bar down/off the post shot or for allowing a goal after already making 2 saves on the play is idiotic.

Binnington gave the team a chance to win every game, he was nails when the chips were down, and even ended up tied with Cale Makar in scoring. You beclown yourself with your takes on Binnington.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mab894 and MAHJ71
None of the goals against in the championship game were on him, and most of the so called “soft” goals Canada fans were squawking about all tournament were not really on him either. Blaming the goalie for a perfect bar down/off the post shot or for allowing a goal after already making 2 saves on the play is idiotic.

Binnington gave the team a chance to win every game, he was nails when the chips were down, and even ended up tied with Cale Makar in scoring. You beclown yourself with your takes on Binnington.

head-sand.gif


:biglaugh:
 
None of the goals against in the championship game were on him, and most of the so called “soft” goals Canada fans were squawking about all tournament were not really on him either. Blaming the goalie for a perfect bar down/off the post shot or for allowing a goal after already making 2 saves on the play is idiotic.

Binnington gave the team a chance to win every game, he was nails when the chips were down, and even ended up tied with Cale Makar in scoring. You beclown yourself with your takes on Binnington.
Hey, cut him some slack. He's watched hockey for 50 years and still doesn't know what a good goalie performance looks like. He's an inspiration for our more challenged fans.
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: mab894 and stl76
Did we watch the same game? Helley was good but Canada didn't significantly out-chance the Americans in regulation. It was a pretty tight game that could've gone either way. Put these two teams in a best-of-seven and it probably goes the distance.

I dunno, were we? In the 3rd I looked up the game on money puck and they had the deserve to win o meter at 72% Canada.
 
He made the saves when it counted. Because of those 3 OT saves, he impressed me a lot more than Luongo did in 2010 (if I remember Luongo only made scoring threat save in OT). Like the coach said, he saved his best for last, or when it counted. Only 3 Canadian goalies may have had that much pressure and that's Dryden 1972, Brodeur 2002 ,Luongo 2010 and him...and this is the internet era. Binner is a winner
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: BigDaddyLurch
He proved me wrong in finals and was amazing. He should be starter for 2026 Olympics no ifs, and or buts.
Binnington was exceptional in the OT, and a major reason Canada won the tournament. Having said that, you simply cannot pencil him as a Starter one year out. He did allow soft goals throughout this tournament (including

in the final yesterday) and if guys like Logan Thompson, Hill, and Blackwood continue their stellar play heading into the early part of next year- the Number 1 Starting Goaltender for Canada for 2026 is yet to be determined.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Avsfan1921
Binnington was exceptional in the OT, and a major reason Canada won the tournament. Having said that, you simply cannot pencil him as a Starter one year out. He did allow soft goals throughout this tournament (including

in the final yesterday) and if guys like Logan Thompson, Hill, and Blackwood continue their stellar play heading into the early part of next year- the Number 1 Starting Goaltender for Canada for 2026 is yet to be determined.
In the final? Canadians have the wildest definitions of "soft goals". Guess you're just spoiled from always having the greatest goalie of the generation and expect the same performance you would expect from Roy or Brodeur (even they may not have saved those).
 
In the final? Canadians have the wildest definitions of "soft goals". Guess you're just spoiled from always having the greatest goalie of the generation and expect the same performance you would expect from Roy or Brodeur.
The second US goal last night was a bad one that an elite goalie should never allow. Having said that, Binnington was exceptional in OT and kept Canada in it. That does not take away the fact that Binnington allowed

soft goals against Finland, Sweden, and the US in Montreal. All I am saying is that he should not be the automatic Starter for 2026 when you have big 6 foot 4 goalies like Adin Hill, Thompson, and Blackwood playing the way they are.
 
The second US goal last night was a bad one that an elite goalie should never allow. Having said that, Binnington was exceptional in OT and kept Canada in it. That does not take away the fact that Binnington allowed

soft goals against Finland, Sweden, and the US in Montreal. All I am saying is that he should not be the automatic Starter for 2026 when you have big 6 foot 4 goalies like Adin Hill, Thompson, and Blackwood playing the way they are.
Those guys hopefully won’t see a minute of ice time

He made the saves when it counted. Because of those 3 OT saves, he impressed me a lot more than Luongo did in 2010 (if I remember Luongo only made scoring threat save in OT). Like the coach said, he saved his best for last, or when it counted. Only 3 Canadian goalies may have had that much pressure and that's Dryden 1972, Brodeur 2002 ,Luongo 2010 and him...and this is the internet era. Binner is a winner
Luongo was scary as heck in 2010
I feel lucky that we won
 
The second US goal last night was a bad one that an elite goalie should never allow. Having said that, Binnington was exceptional in OT and kept Canada in it. That does not take away the fact that Binnington allowed

soft goals against Finland, Sweden, and the US in Montreal. All I am saying is that he should not be the automatic Starter for 2026 when you have big 6 foot 4 goalies like Adin Hill, Thompson, and Blackwood playing the way they are.
If that’s your definition of a soft goal then you’re likely to be disappointed no matter who is in net. Frankly, I think you have completely unreasonable expectations.
 
Binnington is definitely going to Italy. No other goaltender is a lock, so it is an open competition.

The nature of the Olympics requires a tandem so you will see two goalies get time, at least. You can then go with the guy you feel is in the best spot.

Every other team at 4 nations was set to ride one goaltender but poor performances, illness and a meaningless game for the US, led to multiple goaltenders getting time.
 
The Blues have been ass for the past three seasons. But the team has been unable to get a high draft pick because Binnington has earned them points they didn’t deserve (or need, tbh). Guy is a big game goalie. Many fans are convinced that the Avs 2022 championship never would have happened had Nazem Kadri not run Binnington in game 4 of the second round matchup. Binner was dialed in and on top of his game.

It’s funny how nobody actually pays attention to what Blues fans have to say about the guy. Does he let in some save-able goals sometimes? Sure does. But would he be trusted to win a do or die, winner take all game? You bet your ass. At times he appears unfocused and can go through spells where his mechanics are “off”…but the guy battles, and makes big saves he has no business making and plays better as the stakes go up.

It’s not always pretty, but he’s a very good goalie. And it’s why the Blues’ and their fans want to give him a playoff caliber team around him, because once he’s in he can steal a playoff round or more.

Congrats to Binner and Team Canada.
Yep, Binner was well on his way to stealing that series and who knows what else.

Before Kadri injured him, he was on fire. He had a 1.72 GAA and .949 GAA in the 2022 Playoffs against Minnesota and Colorado.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad