GDT: HFBoards GDT | 11/18/2023 | 12 Games

Status
Not open for further replies.

Some Other Flame

Registered User
Dec 4, 2010
8,053
10,395
7a3.jpg
 

RoyalDuder

Registered User
Dec 26, 2011
2,010
852
NY
How is that a goal in NJ when the whistle blew well before it went into the net??? I'm so unbelievably confused.
 

Crease

Chief Justice of the HFNYR Court
Jul 12, 2004
24,520
26,911
Last game they waive off a Ranger goal because they said they intended to blow the play dead. Tonight they blow the play dead but still award the goal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kane One

5cotland

NFR
Jan 23, 2015
4,004
4,786
Scotland
WTF!!

Shocking by Igor but the ref blew the whistle before it cross the line.

How can they call that a goal if the play was called dead?
 

Irishguy42

Mr. Preachy
Sep 11, 2015
27,057
19,545
NJ
Nah in a league where "intent to blow the whistle" exists, this goal shouldn't have happened tbh

I know a rule about continuous play exists, but the refs abuse the "intent to blow the whistle" too much for "oh yeah the puck would have gone in without an issue" to be a legitimate argument.
 

Blender

Registered User
Dec 2, 2009
52,653
46,414
Nah in a league where "intent to blow the whistle" exists, this goal shouldn't have happened tbh
They changed the rules explicitly to permit that since it's a continuation of the shot.
Continuous Play rule (Rule 37), which states that a goal may be awarded, even after a whistle is blown, "if the puck entered the net as the culmination of a continuous play, where the result of the original shot was unaffected by any whistle blown[...]"
 

LOFIN

Registered User
Sep 16, 2011
16,860
23,896
I can't bother to check, but if someone can find out the rule where the refs can reverse a call and project a goal after they had already blown the whistle, that would be nice. Clearly something like that exists because I don't believe they just made it up.
 

5cotland

NFR
Jan 23, 2015
4,004
4,786
Scotland
Continuous Play rule (Rule 37), which states that a goal may be awarded, even after a whistle is blown, "if the puck entered the net as the culmination of a continuous play, where the result of the original shot was unaffected by any whistle blown[...]"
So what about all those goals that have been ruled out because ' the ref was intending to blow the whistle'
 

Irishguy42

Mr. Preachy
Sep 11, 2015
27,057
19,545
NJ
They changed the rules explicitly to permit that since it's a continuation of the shot.
Show me the alternatives when they disallow a goal due to "intent to blow the whistle" when it's a clear ass goal due to this "continuous play" rule.

Oh wait, that's most of the overturned goals from "intent to whistle"

Literally most among the last few league-wide "intent to blow whistle," sorry.
 

WaitingForThatCab

#1 Nick Cousins Fan Account
Mar 11, 2017
16,640
27,822
There's a very obvious difference between guys jamming at a puck in a scrum when the whistle has been blown or should have been blown, and a puck trickling in through the pads when somebody stupidly blew the whistle way too quickly.

In fact, the rulebook makes that very distinction.
 

Blender

Registered User
Dec 2, 2009
52,653
46,414
Show me the alternatives when they disallow a goal due to "intent to blow the whistle" when it's a clear ass goal due to this "continuous play" rule.

Oh wait, that's most of the overturned goals from "intent to whistle"
By "continuous play" they mean like what happened here, a shot is taken and the puck keeps going and into the net. They don't mean someone digging at the goalie for a loose puck, those still factor in "intent to blow the whistle". The rule was specifically amended to fix situations exactly like today.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrLouniverse

RedRocking

Registered User
Jan 8, 2022
7,324
8,752
NoCal
So what about all those goals that have been ruled out because ' the ref was intending to blow the whistle'
The difference is the “continuous play”, and shot unaffected by the whistle part.

Intent to blow the whistle (as annoying as it is), typically happens when a puck should be frozen dead, but players keep whacking at it and it goes in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrLouniverse
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad