That is a fair point.
And sometimes I am not even sure that many plays even should be labeled as mistakes. If you make a low margin play, it’s per definition a play that will be broken up at times. You count on a player not being able to get their stick on a hard pass besides them, you count on a player not being able too strip you, well sometimes they do. It’s in the definition. You take a calculated risk. When that risk materialize, is it a mistake?
I have no problems with Gilmours give aways. I’ve never been a big mistakes-hang-up guy, not when it comes to give aways.
From my POV, what Gilmour does really well is get the puck up ice fast, so fast that it disturbs the other team. Defensively he plays with a lot of speed and is aggressive. That is where I see the real mistakes happen. He skates hard into a forward and ‘ops’ the defender was a bit more steady than he thought and just turns DG away, stuff like that.
But like the conclusion I draw when I watch the NHL right now is that speed really kills. And it’s just so much better to have flawed, inconsistent speed with whatever warts there is rather than the opposite. And Gilmour isn’t just fast, he really plays the game with speed. Havoc creates goals. And when someone like Gilmour just flies out of the zone with the speed he has — it just creates a bit havoc every time. And he isn’t taking big curves around guys either, partying with himself if he gets open ice, he is consistently making those speedy break out plays under pretty heavy pressure.
I wouldn’t mind at all to see Gilmour in the NHL again.