I didn't grow up as a hockey fan - I did go to some of the Bulldogs school day games when they were still in the AHL (and Bruiser actually came to my school at one point, I remember one of my friends being scared the living hell out of by Bruiser, very sweet memories of that LOL), but I was more into monster trucks at the time, and didn't really like "traditional" sports. When the Leafs made the playoffs in 2013, my grandmother went and watched all the games in the first round. I remember specifically coming out of my room and seeing Game 3 being played, and I asked her what was on the TV. She said it was hockey, and for some reason, at this point I was finally interested in watching hockey. I was 9 at the time and Monster Jam moved to FOX Sports starting the next year, a channel we didn't have, so I finally became a hockey fan since that timeslot was freed up. I mention all of this because I feel like I'm probably the youngest person in this thread, and that I grew up as a Leafs fan, so I would be thrilled at the idea of having the Marlies come to Hamilton.
But then I thought about it some more, looked at
@Hammer9001's messages here, and I realized that there isn't really a point in that. While I am a Leafs "fan", I don't necessarily pay attention to them anymore ever since the Bulldogs moved to the OHL. I'd always support local sports over major-league sports, even if my local team is in a lower level of play. This is what I was talking about a few pages ago, that if the Bulldogs relocated, I'll start paying attention to the Leafs (and the NHL as a whole) again. The other thing is that I don't like MLSE whatsoever, and I'd rather they not own a team in Hamilton again. Originally I didn't like MLSE just because they've made it so that it's borderline impossible to go to a Leafs game if you're not rich, but now I've grown to dislike them for their nearly-complete monopolization of Toronto sports, shady business practices, the fact that they don't intervene when their teams are doing poorly as long as they're making them money (Leafs), and now with the information Hammer explained, some of which I didn't even know about.
I thought about the arena situation some more, and now I don't think too much of it makes sense. While I do think the Honey Badgers relocating is the fault of the CEBL being too impatient for the arena to become ready again in a few years (also the fact Morreale said something about that Hamilton has no other professional venues in place for that team to stay in, yet Scarborough literally plays on a university campus... okay? That doesn't seem very "professional" to me, but whatever!), who's to say that Andlauer is going to also keep his patience, given how the city has treated him over the past several years? Why exactly is the capacity staying at around 17,000 when none of the tenants even crack more than 10,000 on average? Like Hammer said, there is absolutely no way an NHL team is coming to the city, so who is HUPEG expecting to fill up the seats on a consistent basis?
I feel like the only reason why the capacity is remaining the same is because they see that FirstOntario Centre is a decent alternative to Toronto for concerts, and they want to preserve that. But there once was 3 local teams playing in the arena, and only the Rock got "fair" attendance numbers, so wouldn't it make more sense to cater the seating capacity to them? I am absolutely confused as to who is going to be in the arena that will draw near-capacity crowds on a consistent basis. The Rock had an average attendance of 9,700, which is about the size of the lower bowl. Concerts are nice, but they aren't consistent. The priority here should be the teams, but that doesn't seem to be what's happening here, especially since they only found out recently that they can't play in the arena during renovations, when they were originally led to believe otherwise.
Anyway, I'm sorry for being pessimistic here. I just don't understand how this whole renovation plan is going to work out that benefits everybody, but maybe I'm confused because I'm young and I don't understand how things like this work.