Don’t think this is true at all. Look at the depth on the Penguins the years they competed for a cup compared to Edmonton’s. It’s not even in the same universe.
I watched a game a couple of years ago that I’ll never forget. Playoff game against the Kings. When McDavid wasn’t on the ice it was all Los Angeles. But when he stepped on the ice he took over.
He only had two points but he could’ve had 15. It was the most dominant performance I’ve seen since Jagr in the 90s. It was a whole other level.
Last year, he and Drai actually had stats that were comparable to Gretz/Lemieux. And that was in a crappy team.
It is the total flipside to Carey Price. They played as well as they possibly could but couldn’t win because their goalie would let in some stupid goal.
Crosby may not have had the best goalies but at least it was “good enough”. No way he wins a cup with Edmonton’s team either. Pittsburgh had Letang and Kessel at different points and I actually think Kessel should’ve taken a Smythe in one of those years that Crosby won.
Both are elite players but I think when it’s all said and done, McD will probably claim the 5th best player of all time slot.