This is my 3rd time trying to play Witcher 3 over the years. I bought the remastered version for $30 and have been mostly enjoying it so far. I'm a level 13 now and about to examine the site with Yennifer and then go meet Triss.
I'm enjoying myself for the most part but the game is lacking a little bit of tempo and theme personally so far. It's A LOT of: talk to this person, go to location, to use witcher sense to examine for clues, follow trails/tracks, find out what happened, have short fight with monster, go back talk to that person again, finish mission, start new mission, talk to this person, go to location, etc...
With BOTW, Elden Ring, and Red Dead 1 i felt like i was a part of huge living world and there is a theme to my experience. BOTW focuses on exploration, curiosity, and conquering evil. Elden Ring is about chaos, destruction, and overcoming difficulties. RDR 1 focused on the end of the Wild West and redemption. I'm not sure yet what CDPR is trying to tell me with Geralt so far. The expansive world they've built seems to be much of the same wherever i go and the action is usually so short lived that it's hard to get momentum building in the game so far. I track down the monster or quest, have 30-60 seconds of fighting, and then immediately get sucked back into that loop again i mentioned above.
Not a bad game at all, i'm enjoying the quality of Witcher 3 and its experience, but it's lacking some spice IMO. I'll happily finish it.
Then i just have to play RDR 2, another game i tried to play twice now and couldn't get into. Maybe these complaints just mean Open World RPG's aren't for me?