GDT: Game 23. 2:30pm jersey retirement. 5pm vs Buffalo.

[LilLeeroy]

He kills plays in the offensive zone by making ill timed low-percentage passes that he is not yet equipped to capitalize on, he drags Macklin down

These two players are not at the same stage of development, Celebrini is a bonafide NHL player right now, today, at this moment, while Will Smith is a developmental project who the organization is trying to mold into an NHL player, Macklin needs to play with actual NHL caliber linemates to allow him to continue growing, Smith's developmental minutes should be segregated from that process at 5-on-5

I don't know, I guess I just saw it differently, and it just seems weird that he was having good results last night (besides missing wide open nets) at 5v5 with Smith last night and seriously struggling on the PP when Smith wasn't even on the ice.

 

[weastern bias]

I don't know, I guess I just saw it differently, and it just seems weird that he was having good results last night (besides missing wide open nets) at 5v5 with Smith last night and seriously struggling on the PP when Smith wasn't even on the ice.

The power play is massive problem, but I don't know if it's a personnel problem as much as a system problem, they've alternated which unit starts and they are both similarly ineffective

Someone pointed out that they struggle mightily against pressure up high at the point of possession, I think part of the problem is the utter lack of off puck movement, but it isn't helped by the fact that we don't have anyone who can handle the responsibility of playing with possession in the middle of the slot on the PP, the middle of the ice is used strictly as a last pass for a shot on goal, no one can create space by handling the puck in the slot so they just spend 2 minutes passing the puck around the perimeter waiting for the "perfect" shot to open up and more often than not it just becomes a low-percentage look or a turnover

 

[TheBeard]

The power play is massive problem, but I don't know if it's a personnel problem as much as a system problem, they've alternated which unit starts and they are both similarly ineffective

Someone pointed out that they struggle mightily against pressure up high at the point of possession, I think part of the problem is the utter lack of off puck movement, but it isn't helped by the fact that we don't have anyone who can handle the responsibility of playing with possession in the middle of the slot on the PP, the middle of the ice is used strictly as a last pass for a shot on goal, no one can create space by handling the puck in the slot so they just spend 2 minutes passing the puck around the perimeter waiting for the "perfect" shot to open up and more often than not it just becomes a low-percentage look or a turnover

You know who would look good on the PP? Brady Tkachuk.

 

[weastern bias]

You know who would look good on the PP? Brady Tkachuk.

I don't think he would because it's a systems problem

 

[LilLeeroy]

You know who would look good on the PP? Brady Tkachuk.

Would you can it already?

 

[TheBeard]

I don't think he would because it's a systems problem

It's a "let's make the highlight reel" power play instead of a blue collar work ethic one. Probably why they use Barclay on it. To instill some sort of ugliness, but he too tries too hard to make things too fancy.

Would you can it already?

What would you give up for Brady?

 

[Cas]

What would you give up for Brady?

Our 2nd, Musty, and a grab bag of lesser prospects, which won't even come close to the necessary package.

It is straight-up not worth expending our 1st plus multiple good prospects.

 

[weastern bias]

That play wouldn't work here, he capitalizes on a shot from the point that hit to the net, on the Sharks that hits a shinpad and bounces out to the neutral zone for a shorthanded breakaway

Also, scored on the Habs defense, not impressive

 

[karltonian]

The Goodrow-Celebrini-Smith line had an 82.1 xGF% last night. It's ok to admit Celebrini didn't have his best game without blaming it on Smith.

oh it was largely smith's fault that it was xgf and not gf. it's okay to watch the games too.

 

[hohosaregood]

I dunno I thought Smith had a good game. Kinda surprised by the shade getting thrown at him after this game. Feel like he's been making good passes (especially to and from Celebrini) and working harder on the boards. Also thought he was using his skating off the puck and staying in motion a lot more.

I wouldn't mind trying to swap Wennberg and Goodrow for a game or two though. But I also wouldn't mind breaking up the Lund line in general. They're a good 2nd line but not that consistent so they get feasted on when playing against bigger and stronger 1st lines. We do know they work so it's a nice fallback option.

 

[TheBeard]

That play wouldn't work here, he capitalizes on a shot from the point that hit to the net, on the Sharks that hits a shinpad and bounces out to the neutral zone for a shorthanded breakaway

Also, scored on the Habs defense, not impressive

Problem is the team only wants to make cross ice passes. Very few one-timers. Just always looking for the pretty play. Get back to nuts and bolts of grinding down, taking shots from the point and standing in front of the net, and take a beating. Everyone on the PP is playing too “pretty” right now.

 

[LilLeeroy]

oh it was largely smith's fault that it was xgf and not gf. it's okay to watch the games too.

It was Smith's fault Macklin missed 3 point blank opportunities? The guy is a real loser then.

What would you give up for Brady?

Askarov for Brady+Sogaard?

 

[Hodge]

Still laughing at the fact Jumbo thanked everyone from randos on the PR staff to Mason Marchment but not Doug Wilson. Legendary status cemented.

 

[Levie]

Still laughing at the fact Jumbo thanked everyone from randos on the PR staff to Mason Marchment but not Doug Wilson. Legendary status cemented.

Tmac too. I can't believe we wasted so many years with him as head coach.

 

[TheBeard]

Still laughing at the fact Jumbo thanked everyone from randos on the PR staff to Mason Marchment but not Doug Wilson. Legendary status cemented.

He never got over being stripped of the C

 

[timorous me]

I dunno I thought Smith had a good game. Kinda surprised by the shade getting thrown at him after this game. Feel like he's been making good passes (especially to and from Celebrini) and working harder on the boards. Also thought he was using his skating off the puck and staying in motion a lot more.

I wouldn't mind trying to swap Wennberg and Goodrow for a game or two though. But I also wouldn't mind breaking up the Lund line in general. They're a good 2nd line but not that consistent so they get feasted on when playing against bigger and stronger 1st lines. We do know they work so it's a nice fallback option.

Yeah, I'm not feeling as bothered by things as some others are right now. The fact is, that line has created some serious chances and if some of them had gone in, I feel like the conversation would be quite different right now.

We've got a couple games against weaker opposition this week, so I wouldn't mind seeing them get the next few games (before the presumed developmental day on Saturday for Smith) to see if some of those shots start to find the back of the net.

 

[one2gamble]

The only issue with Mack and Smith together is they play such a different game. I don't think Smith was or is dragging Macklin down at all but I don't necessarily think they work together.

 

[wickedwitch]

The only issue with Mack and Smith together is they play such a different game. I don't think Smith was or is dragging Macklin down at all but I don't necessarily think they work together.

In what sense? More specifically, what about their differences means they don't they work well together?

 

[Jargon]

In what sense? More specifically, what about their differences means they don't they work well together?

Celebrini is all attack and high pace, attack attack attack and Smith has a more Thornton-esque slow down to his game. Somebody give him a Cheechoo.

 

[wickedwitch]

Celebrini is all attack and high pace, attack attack attack and Smith has a more Thornton-esque slow down to his game. Somebody give him a Cheechoo.

I think they could and would make it work well long-term (think Ovechkin and Backstrom or MacKinnon and Drouin), but it's possible that right now they need to focus on developing their own games first.

 

[Star Platinum]

Celebrini is all attack and high pace, attack attack attack and Smith has a more Thornton-esque slow down to his game. Somebody give him a Cheechoo.

Or at the very least, a Toffoli. If Wennberg can have a Toffoli, certainly Secondary Smith deserves one just as much and it would benefit both of them.

 

[one2gamble]

In what sense? More specifically, what about their differences means they don't they work well together?

Macklin wants to speed everything up, he's much more direct in his effort and skill awareness and use. He attacks head on.

Smith wants to slow it down, control play, control the pace of play, create chances.

It's just different and it was more apparent in person.

 

[StrawHatEklund]

Despite the loss, still had good time celebrating Jumbo. Had a solid 1.5 periods but the skates just fell off the rest of the game and Buffalo capitalized on our mistakes. Celebrini breaking his stick at the end kind of summed up the game.

 

[hohosaregood]

Macklin wants to speed everything up, he's much more direct in his effort and skill awareness and use. He attacks head on.

Smith wants to slow it down, control play, control the pace of play, create chances.

It's just different and it was more apparent in person.

my feeling is that it's fine as is since they could learn to feed off of each other's pace. like Celebrini could gain a lot adding more patience to his game and Smith could stand to add some pace to his.

 

[Shark Finn]

Since he's so similar to Mackinnon, I would take the Avs approach:

Landeskog C, Mackinnon A
Goodrow/Toffoli C, Celebrini A

I'm sure you forgot the "". Right? RIGHT?