He made sure that serious contention was nullified with his personnel decisions though. Yes, he should be blamed for not getting the best out of his players, but let's not pretend that he turned Kreider, Panarin or Zib into what they are - they were already those players. Now, however, with the exception of Panarin, they are all regressing. This team responds the way it does because he allows them to.
You keep saying "multiple teams on extended playoffs runs." It's two teams and two runs and that's it - his first year with Vegas and his first year with us. Everything else is one and done and the teams got worse after the first year. Never made the playoffs with CBJ. One playoff make with Florida and lost in round 1. Lost round 1 his second year with Vegas and then was fired the next season. That is his track record. That is not a track record of success, that is barely a record of mediocrity. Right now, this team is already on a worse start than last year, and not recognizing that the major factor here is Igor's play would be incredibly disingenuous. This team seems to be following his past track record to a T.
This is not emotions. This is facts. He is a loser. The faster he is fired the better for this franchise.
I'm sure Gorton and JD thought they were safe too. Is Dolan going to be happy with a step back this season?