I remember that season. I felt uneasy going into that series because of the team's recent play coupled with the Flyers going on a hot streak into the playoffs. And it ended as expected. Just a total disappointment.
That was the beginning of Marty's decline.
When someone asks me ''When did Brodeur really start declining?'' my answer is usually the start of the 2010 calendar year. Right after he had that 50 save shutout at MSG in January of 2010. His play in the 2010 calendar of the 2009-2010 season was drastically different from his 2009 play. And of course, I believe we were on pace for the best record in the history of the franchise through the 2009 part of the year or even up to the halfway point of that year.
Soft decline I would say maybe around the injury in 2008, but hard decline was 2010. Not the 2010-2011 season, but before that. And then the complete cratering came around when he came back from the pinched nerve in February of 2013.
His play from after that 50 save shutout through the playoffs and from then on was drastically different from his pre-2010's decade play. And you can even include the 2010 Olympics as a part of that.
I don't think it was all downhill for him from there, as he did have a 60-ish (I forgot what the number was) game stretch of .920%-ish goaltending from February of 2012 through February of 2013, which also included the entirety of the 2012 playoffs in that stretch.
But yeah, that second half of that season was heavy foreshadowing with what was to come the next season. We also played Marty 77 games that season at 37 years old. He really started looking absolutely exhausted from January onward.
I predicted us to lose that series to the Flyers that year in exactly 5 games. I felt like we had such a death spiral in the second half of that year that I can't even believe we somehow still got out of that year with the division win. That's how good we were in the first half.