You are using players who played in an era where the gap between top and bottom end talent was huge. Even Gretzky has said openly that had he played in today's game with the level of talent that exists he would never have put up the same kind of numbers. Nobody is saying there weren't great players back in the day. What is being said is the gap between top and bottom talent has shrunk so much so that today's teams are deeper, faster, stronger and more talented all the way through the lineup. I have seen the past teams and there is no question about it. Today's teams are far better.
What NONSENSE....We're not talking about the disparity btwn average and top NHLers here ...we're talking about the creme de la creme in both cases...We're comparing all time best Team Canada's here
1976 Canada Cup Roster was Overall ( TOP TO BOTTOM ) better than this TC roster..sans doubt. ...Gretzky and Mario in their prime were better than Crosby...sans doubt. Seriously try to tell Jagr that Crosby today is better than Mario in his prime, he probably laugh in ur face...
Would Gretzky score 212 pts today? No but that's NOT the same argument
We dont have time machines , but if we could take all time greats in their prime and give them modern equipment, those greats from the seventies and eighties would do fine against todays greats...Our 1987 Canada Cup team had Mario and Gretzky on it, + guys like Dale Hawerchuk, Paul Coffey and Ray Bourque..
Heck Selanne, this years ( cough, cough ) MVP was playing pro in Finland first Div in 1988-9
***
Here let me find the 1976 Canada Cup roster and post it for you
Forwards and Defense: Bill Barber, Bobby Clarke, Marcel Dionne, Phil Esposito, Bob Gainey, Danny Gare, Bobby Hull, Guy Lafleur, Rick Matthews, Guy Lapointe, Reggie Leach, Richard Martin, Peter Mahovlich, Lanny McDonald, Bobby Orr, Gilbert Perreault, Denis Potvin, Larry Robinson, Serge Savard, Steve Shutt, Darryl Sittler, Carol Vadnais, Jimmy Watson;
Goaltenders: Gerry Cheevers, Glenn Resch, Rogatien Vachon; ( gotta give edge to todays goalies for sure, but not the D or the forwards, 1976 was better iMO )