Rumor: Evans asking for $4M x 5 years

[Sorinth]

Plus if we lose Evans, Armia and Savard this summer then that's essentially our entire 1st PK unit gone down the drain. Right now we have the 7th best PK in the league, if we lose all of those guys I could easily see us drop into the bottom 10 in the league on the penalty kill. I think a lot of people are overlooking how much that's going to hurt the team next season.

The whole discussion kind of reminds me of how adding Carrier completely changed the look of the D. Sometimes a guy's impact is felt well beyond his actual play just because it puts everyone else into roles they are better suited for. I get the feeling that Evans is one of those cases.

 

[salbutera]

Habs couldn’t find a 4C during Houle, Savard, Gainey, Gauthier, and MB eras and when we finally have one developed who is on the verge of becoming a high end PK, want to trade him for a low 2nd rounder / essentially a 3rd rounder…

 

[WG]

Plus if we lose Evans, Armia and Savard this summer then that's essentially our entire 1st PK unit gone down the drain. Right now we have the 7th best PK in the league, if we lose all of those guys I could easily see us drop into the bottom 10 in the league on the penalty kill. I think a lot of people are overlooking how much that's going to hurt the team next season.

As noted elsewhere, this was already a bottom 10 PK with all of these guys on the roster.

21-22: 27th (75.6%)
22-23: 29th (72.7%)
23-24: 24th (76.5%)

Maybe they have made some systemic and projectable change that makes them a surefire top 10 PK going forward. I don't think I'd be that surprised, though, if the PK slipped into the bottom half of the league next year even if they brought all three guys back.

 

[ReHabs]

Habs couldn’t find a 4C during Houle, Savard, Gainey, Gauthier, and MB eras and when we finally have one developed who is on the verge of becoming a high end PK, want to trade him for a low 2nd rounder / essentially a 3rd rounder…

Gainey and MB found many, many 4Cs.

And no 4C gets 4m and 5 years and stays with that team to the end of that contract. That's not 4C money.

 

[1909]

4 X 4 at the very most.

 

[Stoneburg]

I was a big fan of Evans, then I had to reconsider when I saw all the criticism of him here. In the last few games, I noticed two goals that were directly attributable to Evans losing his man (I noticed this issue before the last few games too). He might not be the defensive stud that many (including me) thought. Having said that, his ask is less than the average salary for an NHL player ($ 95.6/23 players = $4.2 MM). Five years does seem a little long, too risky. If we can sign him for $3.5 for 4 years, it seems worthwhile. If we can get a good return, yes, I agree with others that he is replaceable, especially at $3.5MM

 

[Rapala]

As noted elsewhere, this was already a bottom 10 PK with all of these guys on the roster.

21-22: 27th (75.6%)
22-23: 29th (72.7%)
23-24: 24th (76.5%)

Maybe they have made some systemic and projectable change that makes them a surefire top 10 PK going forward. I don't think I'd be that surprised, though, if the PK slipped into the bottom half of the league next year even if they brought all three guys back.

Armia rescued 23-24 with his play down the stretch or it would have been similar to 22-23.
Evans is who he has always been and is not worth double his current salary in my books.
This file should be referenced in the GM's guide to Emotional vs Dispassionate decision making.

I'm betting HuGo are the latter these are the same guys who described "Emotional Maturity" as being one of Marty's best traits.

 

[angusyoung]

Thats his asking price?

 

[The Gr8 Dane]

There's nothing complicated about anything.


The only complicated thing is cattering to the fefans and their win now delusions.


If management isn't capable of replacing Evans than we are already completely toast for the next half decade.

If teams are willing to give value for our UFA's you take it and run

 

[SnapVirus]

Trade his ass. We have Beck that will become a 3rd line centerman. We already have Dach in the system that could be our 3rd centerman. We cant pay 4-5M$ for an overpaid 4th liner. We will have a young team and we need to surround those players with big productive players, not with overpaid cast.

 

[Kosseca]

Structure the contract as $15M signing bonus this summer, and $500 000 per season for 5 yrs. Total $17,5M, but cap hit of 3,5/season. He can invest the money and bank the interest to make up for part of for the missing $2,5M

Edit: Crap. minimum contract is higher then 500K... but you get the idea

 

[HuGort]

Habs couldn’t find a 4C during Houle, Savard, Gainey, Gauthier, and MB eras and when we finally have one developed who is on the verge of becoming a high end PK, want to trade him for a low 2nd rounder / essentially a 3rd rounder…

Couldn't find a 4th line center, they found many. Danault, Dvorak, Dominic Moore, Halpern, Smolinski, Metropolit, Juneau. A 4th line center easy to find. Beck will probably play that role next year.