Rumor: Evans asking for $4M x 5 years

  • Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.

Do you sign or Trade?

  • Sign?

    Votes: 61 30.2%
  • Trade

    Votes: 141 69.8%

  • Total voters
    202
My argument from the get go. We already have two players ready to replace Evans in Beck and Kapanen.
People are freaked out we won't be able to replace his PK when in reality it's one of the easiest roles to replace. I don't get the fear mongering crowd who think we will fall apart. I've also ascertained that our good PK coincided with Armia's uptick in play not Jake Evans.

Why in the hell would we want to tie up 20M on a role player?
I seen this argument falsely made about internal replacements so many times. We do not have any internal options for replacing Evans at the moment. This ask is pretty reasonable from Evans camp. I’d sign him tbh.
 
If I were Hughes I'd take one last shot at re-signing Evans before the deadline with the best offer and term he'd be comfortable with offering Evans to stay.

If Evans holds firm on his 5x4m ask Hughes needs to shop him around to see if a team will offer up a 2nd for him, if not and teams only offer up a 3rd or 4th just keep him and let him play out the season and maybe take another shot at re-signing him before or after July 1st.

I'd also tell Evans before trading him (if it comes to that) that if he doesn't get an offer better than that final offer from Hughes after July 1st to let him know and they'll see if they can work something out then.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rickthegoon
I seen this argument falsely made about internal replacements so many times. We do not have any internal options for replacing Evans at the moment. This ask is pretty reasonable from Evans camp. I’d sign him tbh.
What makes you so sure there is anything even remotely FALSE about what I posted?
The legendary irreplaceable Jake Evans.
Holy Crap Jake great snow job.
 
I don't like 4x5. Trade at deadline or let him test the market.

Montreal is an interesting team for UFA Centers looking to sign. There's talented players to play with. Montreal should also test the market.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scriptor
My argument from the get go. We already have two players ready to replace Evans in Beck and Kapanen.
People are freaked out we won't be able to replace his PK when in reality it's one of the easiest roles to replace. I don't get the fear mongering crowd who think we will fall apart. I've also ascertained that our good PK coincided with Armia's uptick in play not Jake Evans.

Why in the hell would we want to tie up 20M on a role player?
They may be ready for NHL roles but they aren't ready to replace Evans. The simple truth is that the best thing for Beck's development is to have a guy like Evans around who can carry that defensive load so that Beck can be put in situations where he will succeed and develop.
 
They may be ready for NHL roles but they aren't ready to replace Evans. The simple truth is that the best thing for Beck's development is to have a guy like Evans around who can carry that defensive load so that Beck can be put in situations where he will succeed and develop.
Right Beck needs Evans for his development.
Beck is developing just fine on his own. In case you haven't noticed Owen Beck already knows how to play Hockey and he's doing a damn fine job at being a professional. He needs to work on getting stronger and execution is Evans going to hold his hand for that? Nice fabrication.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Grate n Colorful Oz
Right Beck needs Evans for his development.
Beck is developing just fine on his own. In case you haven't noticed Owen Beck already knows how to play Hockey and he's doing a damn fine job at being a professional. He needs to work on getting stronger and execution is Evans going to hold his hand for that? Nice fabrication.
Beck developing just fine right now is actually proof that Evans is actually a big help. He's developing well right now WITH Evans, we can't say for sure how he would be developing without Evans, but without question he has an easier time with Evans taking the hardest minutes.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Rapala
Beck developing just fine right now is actually proof that Evans is actually a big help. He's developing well right now WITH Evans, we can't say for sure how he would be developing without Evans, but without question he has an easier time with Evans taking the hardest minutes.
Hasn't spent one second of ice time on with Evans. Nice Fabrication.
 
Right Beck needs Evans for his development.
Beck is developing just fine on his own. In case you haven't noticed Owen Beck already knows how to play Hockey and he's doing a damn fine job at being a professional. He needs to work on getting stronger and execution is Evans going to hold his hand for that? Nice fabrication.
Doing good in the AHL, and then didn't look out of place in his 9 games sampler. All that by developing on his own !
As KK, as Galchenyuk who didn't need players, or coaches to help them
:facepalm:
 
Exactly my point, Beck hasn't been thrown to the wolves because we have Evans to take that responsibility.
You are talking crap. If you told me Evans has played are part in helping develop Heineman I would automatically have to agree with you. As far as throwing Beck to the wolves I don't see it. His line has been far more responsible and is not losing us games like it has been for most of this season. Don't confuse what is happening out there. Evans is playing a 2C role with 2C icetime. Beck is playing a 4C role with 4C icetime and his only job is to graduate up the ladder based on his own play exactly like Nick Suzuki had to do. We need a 2C not a 4C it's completely obvious or at least should be. Evans has exactly zero influence on what happens with Owen Beck.
 
You are talking crap. If you told me Evans has played are part in helping develop Heineman I would automatically have to agree with you. As far as throwing Beck to the wolves I don't see it. His line has been far more responsible and is not losing us games like it has been for most of this season. Don't confuse what is happening out there. Evans is playing a 2C role with 2C icetime. Beck is playing a 4C role with 4C icetime and his only job is to graduate up the ladder based on his own play exactly like Nick Suzuki had to do. We need a 2C not a 4C it's completely obvious or at least should be. Evans has exactly zero influence on what happens with Owen Beck.
You don't see Beck being thrown to the wolves because Evans is on the team taking those minutes. You seem to have a very simplistic/childish view of things. If we were to go out and get Crosby the biggest beneficiary would probably be Suzuki even though they would have limited ice time together.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BehindTheTimes
You don't see Beck being thrown to the wolves because Evans is on the team taking those minutes. You seem to have a very simplistic/childish view of things. If we were to go out and get Crosby the biggest beneficiary would probably be Suzuki even though they would have limited ice time together.
I'm talking about the need of re-signing Evans for 5 years I'm not talking about what happens in the immediate. If HuGo decide to hold then they'd better damn well add or I'll be completely pissed. If they don't add a true 2C this off season I'll also be completely pissed. The most important thing we need to do is ADD not simply tread water by over paying a role player.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tyson
What makes you so sure there is anything even remotely FALSE about what I posted?
The legendary irreplaceable Jake Evans.
Holy Crap Jake great snow job.
Ridiculous response like this is all the evidence one needs to see how weak their argument is. Everything you said is demonstrably false. Beck and Kapanen can not match Evans production or his PK ability.

Right Beck needs Evans for his development.
Beck is developing just fine on his own. In case you haven't noticed Owen Beck already knows how to play Hockey and he's doing a damn fine job at being a professional. He needs to work on getting stronger and execution is Evans going to hold his hand for that? Nice fabrication.
You don’t know what you are talking about and your posts are cringeworthy.

You don’t understand the market and the value someone like Evans is worth, that is clear as day, but this is not even a big ask from Evan’s camp. It is perfectly reasonable.
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: Rapala

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad