McDavid left in 2015. They won it all in 2017. They had success without him but they sold everything off for 4 straight years. Do fans on other teams not realize the drastic nature of that?? Rarely do teams go for it 2 years in a row, let alone 3. 4 in a row? That’s unheard of. So it was naturally going to take 2-3 years minimum. The pandemic killed them more than most because they lost out on the cashing in of Drysdale/Golod/Yetman that they needed much, much more than most teams. Instead they all graduated to the NHL/AHL
Their assets depleted from 2013-2017 and little youth was left in the system by the time the rebuild started (McShane, Neumann, etc. traded away). Their drafting has been average. They have hit on late round picks like Golod, Yetman, Cohen, and DAmato in the u18. They missed on early picks in Sproule (but late 1st round pick so hard to hit on that) and Lockhart (so far a bust given the position drafted). With the rest of the guys it’s too early to tell or they were 4-15th round picks. Not a lot of 2/3rd rounders from 2016-2019. COVID didn’t help because they lost out on trading Drysdale for a ransom
Their bigger issue has been coaching and asset management. Asset management being the trades and the waste of import picks on guys like Molnar (potentially). It’s not that they can’t evaluate talent or draft. Rather, they seem to not be able to sign some important pieces which has impacted their high end talent. Not to mention the horrible coaching that hasn’t been able to develop players which might be leading to trouble with signing guys. Of all the issues though, drafting for talent isn’t one. Drafting guys that sign? That’s the bigger issue. Coaching that develops players? That’s the main issue