Erie Otters 2022 Off-season Thread

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
Status
Not open for further replies.
Can’t help but think that sometimes those in either the top tier destination -or somewhere struggling forgets Erie is prob a top 5-6 destination spot in the OHL

We hear of non report rumors ( bs) every year then have landed the likes of Strome , McDavid, O Reilly , DeBrincat , Drysdale and on and on who still are engaged w the Otters ..and these guys thrive here socially and in the top notch schools / good areas of NWest PA..I think your going to see Spence and Watson and others thrive once we get this thing going next year
I do think their alumni base is strong and its hard to beat, other than London, because they can always point to McDavid - who is the face of hockey right now. Its not so much the development of guys, though Erie can point to DeBrincat and Brown as examples of that, as much as it is that guys like McDavid and OReilly have nothing but great things to say about their time in Erie. If I'm a 16 year old considering my options and I hear McDavid tell me how much he loved his time here, well that's going to be a major selling point.

In terms of the non report rumors - I don't think they are all bs. McDavid was ES and as has been speculated, he might not have had a choice if he wanted to play in the OHL a year early. It helps that he was humble and just wanted to play. But make no mistake that Erie in 2012 is not even close to Erie in 2022. Things were very bleak in 2012 and without McDavid, this franchise would have collapsed here. Strome was an easier sell because of McDavid. DeBrincat same thing. O'Reilly was drafted 1st overall because Taylor Hall said no... so its not like Erie got the consensus top guy that year, they didn't. They had to "settle" for O'Reilly because he would actually report

But again, Erie in 2006 or 2011 ... much different than Erie recruiting players in 2022. They have much more credibility now, and the alumni in the NHL is a big factor with that. Not to mention the fans and the recent title run, which really was magical and showed the passion this fanbase has when a team is worthy of it. It's hard to quantify what that means compared to other teams - especially when every prospect probably wants something different. Erie being a US based team is going to hurt them more than help them. That said, they are at least a middle pack team in terms of being a destination. For some prospects they might be top 5-6 team or even a top 3 spot. For others they might be bottom 5-6 spot, but I would imagine a lot of that is based on them just being US based. If Erie wants to become a true top tier destination, they have to start winning again. If they can build some great teams with this cycle of players (Sova, Terrance, Lalonde, Spence, Kyrou, imports, etc.), and some of those players become NHL players - well then now you are building something. Get yourself another title in the next 5 years while producing a couple other NHL players and you can make the case. First thing first - get back to the playoffs please
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: OttersFan


Basically saying they had Spence as the best player, even over Misa. Both are not eligible for NHL draft until 2025, so it’s not like Saginaw gets a guaranteed extra year of Misa. I really think that Erie would have taken Spence #1 over Misa as well. He’s the best overall prospect and the most ready to impact. Misa is really talented but seems more like projection. From the highlights I’ve seen, it’s Spence driving a lot of the play
 
Last edited:
Another thing to consider is their 2nd round import pick in the last draft Juraj Slafkovsky.
I know he is a long shot to come but is ranked as high as 3rd overall in this years NHL draft. Maybe he reports if whoever drafts him convinces him to come. Aka burakovsky from a few seasons back.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: OffIceMan
Another thing to consider is their 2nd round import pick in the last draft Juraj Slafkovsky.
I know he is a long shot to come but is ranked as high as 3rd overall in this years NHL draft. Maybe he reports if whoever drags him convinces him to come. Aka burakovsky from a few seasons back.

I have been contemplating that as well ever since the war started overseas. Makes me wonder if we have a couple top players report and there is still a ton of instability over around Europe and Asia if it may have him contemplating a move more now.

We can hope he gets additional push from which ever team drafts him in the NHL.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GetOutDaKitchin
I have been contemplating that as well ever since the war started overseas. Makes me wonder if we have a couple top players report and there is still a ton of instability over around Europe and Asia if it may have him contemplating a move more now.

We can hope he gets additional push from which ever team drafts him in the NHL.
How freakin' awesome would it be if Slafkovsky came over..Our forward corps would be downright scary:

1. Slafkovsky
2. Cohen
3. Lockhart
4. Bressette
5. Spence
6. Sedore
7. Saganiuk
8. Terrance
9. Artichuk
10. Ross
11. Lowe
12. Smith
13. Edwards
14. Sawyer (AP)

That top 9 could rival anyone in the league's. A bit on the small side, but the speed and skill would be killer.

Regardless of Slafkovsky's decision, I think we obviously have to dump Kulakov (could he even return?) and get a legit top 4 defenseman to complement Kyrou, Sova and Morton.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OttersFan
How freakin' awesome would it be if Slafkovsky came over..Our forward corps would be downright scary:

1. Slafkovsky
2. Cohen
3. Lockhart
4. Bressette
5. Spence
6. Sedore
7. Saganiuk
8. Terrance
9. Artichuk
10. Ross
11. Lowe
12. Smith
13. Edwards
14. Sawyer (AP)

That top 9 could rival anyone in the league's. A bit on the small side, but the speed and skill would be killer.

Regardless of Slafkovsky's decision, I think we obviously have to dump Kulakov (could he even return?) and get a legit top 4 defenseman to complement Kyrou, Sova and Morton.
Slafkovsky is unlikely coming. We can dream but it’s a long shot and I believe Erie would have to release his rights in order to draft another import (unless they release Kulakov)

Kulakov is eligible to return. Erie can’t afford to “dump” him and get a “legit” top 4 D.. they don’t have the assets to waste on a fun little run. No. They need to just keep getting better, let their youth develop, and focus on gaining assets if anything. Whether that be a Sedore trade, or even a Lockhart trade later in the year. Even if this team is amazing out the gate, there is no reason to trade for anyone and totally deplete the future assets. With Spence, they have a chance for a special player in 2-3 years. Build around that..
I would rather keep Kulakov than create a hole that’s not there. The D is fine. They will all be 1 year older next season. How about we coach them up better and actually have goalies that make up for any mistakes? No trades needed.
 
Slafkovsky is unlikely coming. We can dream but it’s a long shot and I believe Erie would have to release his rights in order to draft another import (unless they release Kulakov)

I might be wrong but if he is taken in the first round (which he will) I think Erie can retain his rights?
I know this was the rule a few seasons ago but I don’t know if it’s changed.
 
Slafkovsky is unlikely coming. We can dream but it’s a long shot and I believe Erie would have to release his rights in order to draft another import (unless they release Kulakov)

Kulakov is eligible to return. Erie can’t afford to “dump” him and get a “legit” top 4 D.. they don’t have the assets to waste on a fun little run. No. They need to just keep getting better, let their youth develop, and focus on gaining assets if anything. Whether that be a Sedore trade, or even a Lockhart trade later in the year. Even if this team is amazing out the gate, there is no reason to trade for anyone and totally deplete the future assets. With Spence, they have a chance for a special player in 2-3 years. Build around that..
I would rather keep Kulakov than create a hole that’s not there. The D is fine. They will all be 1 year older next season. How about we coach them up better and actually have goalies that make up for any mistakes? No trades needed.

I'd say they already have a legit top 4 D. If you take Kyrou & Morton and Sova & Kulakov, that's some pretty decent defense right there. Add Johnston to the mix and they're not that far off being one of the better defenses in the league. Erie could have used better defensively responsible forwards last year. I saw way way way too many times where the D had their guys covered but another opposing forward came out from the half boards to walk right in front of the Erie net for easy scoring chances.
 
Slafkovsky is unlikely coming. We can dream but it’s a long shot and I believe Erie would have to release his rights in order to draft another import (unless they release Kulakov)

Kulakov is eligible to return. Erie can’t afford to “dump” him and get a “legit” top 4 D.. they don’t have the assets to waste on a fun little run. No. They need to just keep getting better, let their youth develop, and focus on gaining assets if anything. Whether that be a Sedore trade, or even a Lockhart trade later in the year. Even if this team is amazing out the gate, there is no reason to trade for anyone and totally deplete the future assets. With Spence, they have a chance for a special player in 2-3 years. Build around that..
I would rather keep Kulakov than create a hole that’s not there. The D is fine. They will all be 1 year older next season. How about we coach them up better and actually have goalies that make up for any mistakes? No trades needed.
Unfortunately there was something that came up with Arty.

Last I knew (last week) Kulakov was heading home this week and there is no guarantee he would be allowed to come back to the US. If that's true, it hurts. I hope he is able to return.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OttersFan and NOA
Interesting timing...

Wes Wolfe stepped down as GM and HC of the Cobourg Cougars...
Interesting indeed. At some point Erie has to add a 3rd coach, just a question of whether it will be a new head coach or another assistant. Wes won’t be up back here unless he’s the head coach.

Everyone should know my stance at this point - I would hire someone other than BJ as the new head coach. I like BJ and his personality but I don’t necessarily think he’s the right guy going forward and that’s not a knock on him, I just think they need a new direction. I’m not sure how I would feel about Wes either, given that he was yet another coach that was here during the recent issues and I would prefer to clean house a bit or bring in a fresh new voice. But Wes also has a good personality and is young. Maybe he’s a darkhorse to be a really good up and coming head coach.

Certainly interesting timing with Wes. But it could be personal reasons or another team that is about to sign him as a coach
 
Interesting indeed. At some point Erie has to add a 3rd coach, just a question of whether it will be a new head coach or another assistant. Wes won’t be up back here unless he’s the head coach.

Everyone should know my stance at this point - I would hire someone other than BJ as the new head coach. I like BJ and his personality but I don’t necessarily think he’s the right guy going forward and that’s not a knock on him, I just think they need a new direction. I’m not sure how I would feel about Wes either, given that he was yet another coach that was here during the recent issues and I would prefer to clean house a bit or bring in a fresh new voice. But Wes also has a good personality and is young. Maybe he’s a darkhorse to be a really good up and coming head coach.

Certainly interesting timing with Wes. But it could be personal reasons or another team that is about to sign him as a coach

I'm undecided on BJ. Hell, I'd be undecided on Wes being the man too for that matter, but hey everyone has to start somewhere and BJ could surprise us.

That being said BJ was dealt a really crappy hand and we actually saw for the first time in a while, progression. For that reason alone I will say BJ earned himself 2 years from Jim and DB to work these kids and develop the program. Is it the right decision, I'm unsure, but unless Knoblaugh said he was coming back tomorrow it is likely the route we go.

With regards to Wes...I agree he'd probably want HC, but I don't see BJ stepping down and I don't see Jim/DB blowing up the coaching staff especially with what could be the most talented kid since the McDavid/DeBrincat/Strome era coming to Erie hopefully for the next 3 years. Unless there is some coach that is of the highest caliber, they are going to leave it alone for 2 years.

I would have to agree with you in that it might just be time to cut the cord from the McDavid era and start fresh...Fresh coaches, fresh GM, fresh ideas. DB is definitely entering this season on thin ice in my eyes. If we can't put together a playoff run he needs to go.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OttersFan
I'm undecided on BJ. Hell, I'd be undecided on Wes being the man too for that matter, but hey everyone has to start somewhere and BJ could surprise us.

That being said BJ was dealt a really crappy hand and we actually saw for the first time in a while, progression. For that reason alone I will say BJ earned himself 2 years from Jim and DB to work these kids and develop the program. Is it the right decision, I'm unsure, but unless Knoblaugh said he was coming back tomorrow it is likely the route we go.

With regards to Wes...I agree he'd probably want HC, but I don't see BJ stepping down and I don't see Jim/DB blowing up the coaching staff especially with what could be the most talented kid since the McDavid/DeBrincat/Strome era coming to Erie hopefully for the next 3 years. Unless there is some coach that is of the highest caliber, they are going to leave it alone for 2 years.

I would have to agree with you in that it might just be time to cut the cord from the McDavid era and start fresh...Fresh coaches, fresh GM, fresh ideas. DB is definitely entering this season on thin ice in my eyes. If we can't put together a playoff run he needs to go.
You are right, they are likely not moving on from the current staff. Doesn’t mean I agree with it but it’s the cheap, easy thing to do and the historic pattern of this team to do so. I expect it. But that said it’s not really BJs choice on whether to “step down” or not. He was hired as the “interim” coach. As of now, they haven’t officially announced any real contract with him as the head coach. So like any other job, if Erie wants to hire a new head coach to take over the still vacant permanent role, they can. They aren’t obligated to keep BJ here, financially or otherwise.

I’m not necessarily excited to just give BJ two years if thats the direction they want to go. The reason is simple: They don’t have that amount time. If BJ is just Hartsburg with a better attitude and personality, that’s not close to good enough. They need to see progress, and major progress at that. Yes, BJ had some progress this year with players but they finished like 3-13 and overall BJ went 24-30-1-2. He might be a better guy or person, players might like him more, but does that mean he can consistently coach up guys and win? Literally BJ had the same quality production that Hartsburg gave us the prior 4 years. I agree that BJ wasn’t dealt the best situation but still, it’s not like they improved so much that anyone has to be locked on the idea that he’s the only option or it would be stupid to move on from him. Again, they need new voices. If BJ was an outside hire as an interim guy, I might feel differently. But he’s been with the team through the entire Hartsburg era and that era wasn’t good… I don’t think it’s wrong to just say “we need a new direction.”

I fully admit that It’s hard to know what BJ will or won’t be as a full time coach. I might be totally wrong on him. But imo he’s not going to be anything other than another guy - average coach. We are comparing him to Hartsburg who was horrible, so anyone is going to look better. But I don’t see BJ making a significant difference and I think Erie needs to invest or find a guy that actually will make that difference. Easier said than done but that’s why they get paid to do what they do and I’m just a fan who can only have opinions. Given the current state of the team (no playoff games since May 2017), it’s safe to say that anything less than a 6/7 seed finish this upcoming year would be unacceptable. You return every single player minus the OAs (which is really just DAmato) and you drafted Spence who should give you some impact this year. Plus you have a top 12 import pick. If this team doesn’t take some bigger strides forward, it’s not a good look to the stability of the franchise. Getting 30-32 wins and 8th seed isn’t going to cut it. That’s what they should have been this year. They need to be 35+ wins. No excuses. If they aren’t that, then the development of their players is broken and that’s a bad sign for not only DB but also the coaching staff.
 
Draft Review

Had a chance to read some stuff on the 2022 draft prospects so here is a little overview from me:

Spence - immediate impact type player. Expectations should be high and I think he can compete for rookie of the year

Gibbons - really big frame and a candidate to be the #2 goalie this year behind Lalonde. Either way, his skills and size will certainly have him getting some action this year even if 4-5 games

Sawyer - seems like he projects more like a Pettit or Betz type of big forward. Needs to work on his first few strides and skating to really put it all together. That said, Erie needs size and there is room for him to crack the lineup right away. I would expect him to do so. He projects more like a middle lineup player or complimentary piece.

Holomego, Henry, Watson - all big bodied defensemen who will have time to develop given the current roster on the backend. No need to rush any prospect but I think the idea for Erie here was to have at least 1 pan out and hopefully 2. Ty seems like the better skater of the bunch but Holomego and Watson have huge size for their age and I would imagine that as they learn to play with their size more, they will have a solid chance at a good OHL career.

Good - my favorite sleeper of the draft. Was ranked 43rd by Prospect Pipeline in December. Clearly undersized but led the entire ETA in scoring at nearly 1 GPG and 2 PPG. Given the roster, he is unlikely to make the team but a really good candidate to sign after camp with the intention of seeing him here in 2023-24.

The others that stand out in the later half of the draft are Kuipers (a lot of production for Quinte Red Devils), Morello (bigger forward with a PPG production in the GTHL) and Curd (defender who is already 6’6 205lbs).

Early look at the 2022-23 depth chart:

Bressette - Terrance - Lockhart
Import (?) - Saganiuk - Cohen
Smith/Lowe - Spence - Ross/Artichuk
Edwards - Smith/Lowe - Ross/Artichuk
Sawyer

Morton - Kyrou
Sova - Thompson
Johnston - Sauder
Alboim

Lalonde
Import

I don’t know whether Kulakov will be back or not but everything I will have is based on him NOT returning so keep that in mind. Hopefully Erie figures that out prior to the import draft next month. Please don’t allow for another Cajka situation... I’m full on projecting and guessing on the goalie spot but makes sense to go the import route if Kulakov isn’t back and actually might be a better solution for them. I’m not wasting an OA spot on Campbell. He has never played like a starting caliber goalie and I don’t see why that would change now. They can do better on a backup that isn’t using the OA spot. Instead, keep Thompson over Kulakov and get a backup import goalie with your 2nd round pick.

Given that Erie emphasized size this draft class and Brown knows they need to upgrade it, I will say that Sedore is a likely trade candidate. He also might actually get a decent return so more incentive to put him on the market. Though I like his game and could see a jump next year, his small size is sooo redundant in their lineup and they need to reverse the trend. If they do move on from him (plus Sellan) and add an import with some size (plus Spence/Sawyer with size) they will already be bigger than last year at forward. So that’s a step in the right direction. I think Spence could be a top 6 forward at some point but I won’t put that expectation on him and if they draft an import forward at 12th overall, there is a logjam of options. He’s likely going to start on the 3rd line, but I just hope the guys around him will compliment his game
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mata
Another thing to consider is their 2nd round import pick in the last draft Juraj Slafkovsky.
I know he is a long shot to come but is ranked as high as 3rd overall in this years NHL draft. Maybe he reports if whoever drafts him convinces him to come. Aka burakovsky from a few seasons back.
Another one that comes to mind is Erik Cernak
 
Draft Review

Had a chance to read some stuff on the 2022 draft prospects so here is a little overview from me:

Spence - immediate impact type player. Expectations should be high and I think he can compete for rookie of the year

Gibbons - really big frame and a candidate to be the #2 goalie this year behind Lalonde. Either way, his skills and size will certainly have him getting some action this year even if 4-5 games

Sawyer - seems like he projects more like a Pettit or Betz type of big forward. Needs to work on his first few strides and skating to really put it all together. That said, Erie needs size and there is room for him to crack the lineup right away. I would expect him to do so. He projects more like a middle lineup player or complimentary piece.

Holomego, Henry, Watson - all big bodied defensemen who will have time to develop given the current roster on the backend. No need to rush any prospect but I think the idea for Erie here was to have at least 1 pan out and hopefully 2. Ty seems like the better skater of the bunch but Holomego and Watson have huge size for their age and I would imagine that as they learn to play with their size more, they will have a solid chance at a good OHL career.

Good - my favorite sleeper of the draft. Was ranked 43rd by Prospect Pipeline in December. Clearly undersized but led the entire ETA in scoring at nearly 1 GPG and 2 PPG. Given the roster, he is unlikely to make the team but a really good candidate to sign after camp with the intention of seeing him here in 2023-24.

The others that stand out in the later half of the draft are Kuipers (a lot of production for Quinte Red Devils), Morello (bigger forward with a PPG production in the GTHL) and Curd (defender who is already 6’6 205lbs).

Early look at the 2022-23 depth chart:

Bressette - Terrance - Lockhart
Import (?) - Saganiuk - Cohen
Smith/Lowe - Spence - Ross/Artichuk
Edwards - Smith/Lowe - Ross/Artichuk
Sawyer

Morton - Kyrou
Sova - Thompson
Johnston - Sauder
Alboim

Lalonde
Import

I don’t know whether Kulakov will be back or not but everything I will have is based on him NOT returning so keep that in mind. Hopefully Erie figures that out prior to the import draft next month. Please don’t allow for another Cajka situation... I’m full on projecting and guessing on the goalie spot but makes sense to go the import route if Kulakov isn’t back and actually might be a better solution for them. I’m not wasting an OA spot on Campbell. He has never played like a starting caliber goalie and I don’t see why that would change now. They can do better on a backup that isn’t using the OA spot. Instead, keep Thompson over Kulakov and get a backup import goalie with your 2nd round pick.

Given that Erie emphasized size this draft class and Brown knows they need to upgrade it, I will say that Sedore is a likely trade candidate. He also might actually get a decent return so more incentive to put him on the market. Though I like his game and could see a jump next year, his small size is sooo redundant in their lineup and they need to reverse the trend. If they do move on from him (plus Sellan) and add an import with some size (plus Spence/Sawyer with size) they will already be bigger than last year at forward. So that’s a step in the right direction. I think Spence could be a top 6 forward at some point but I won’t put that expectation on him and if they draft an import forward at 12th overall, there is a logjam of options. He’s likely going to start on the 3rd line, but I just hope the guys around him will compliment his game
I think it is great to have this many options going into preseason!

Bresette, Cohen, Sedore, Lockhart, Terrance, and Saganiuk have to be the early top 6 for forwards.

Spence may have some time in the top 6 throughout the season as he adjusts, but I fully expect him on the 3rd line starting the season out. I think part of our success up front hinges on how well Smith, Lowe, Artichuk, and Ross develop. They should be game ready day 1 given they all saw a decent amount of playing time.

Sawyer to me will likely be 4th line to lose player. They wouldn't have opted for a 2nd second round pick if they didn't need to which means to me if they land an import there is going to be a battle for roster spots on lines 3 and 4 in the sense that Artichuk, Ross, Edwards, Sawyer, and possibly either Smith or Lowe are fighting for.

That leaves us trade value in Sedore, or even another forward for that matter. Right now we have two options regarding OA that are obvious to me...

Cohen, Sedore, Thomspon, Morton

Run 2 forward OA and 1 Defensive OA or run 1 Forward OA and 2 Defensive OA. I think they will shop around a few of the OA and get the best return they can so really no one is technically off the table.

With regards to goalie, unless they change the OA rules one would think Campbell is either traded asap or released. There is no other plausible way forward for him IMO. That leaves us with Nicholls or Gibbons as the backup currently. Perhaps they give Gibbons 1 year in juniors to develop and keep Nicholls up if he has grown at all and his confidence isn't totally shot, but I think the draft moves indicate otherwise.

Whatever is going on behind the scenes will help shape our direction with regards to the import draft and give us our next clues as to how the pieces will look going into camp.

Unless someone has really improved/impressed I think most of the faces will be back but this will be our first camp removed from Hartsburg so it wouldn't be totally surprising to see a shake-up.

Lastly, coaching...I still believe they give BJ a chance...1 year, though likely 2. I have to believe if BJ falters next season both him and DB are gone and even possibly Vince. I hope Jim has some scouting going on because I'm not totally opposed to getting rid of the entire coaching staff/GM at this point for a fresh start.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: NOA
The team finished poorly under BJ, but I think the honest question we have to ask ourselves is, was a 24-30-1-2 record the true talent level of the team? I think it probably was given the backup goalie situation. If they had sorted the backup goalie situation out and had BJ running things from the beginning, they could have been a .500 team and been in the 6-8 range. It's probably better long term they finished where they did though, Spence is a potentially game-breaking talent.

As for next season's team and how the depth chart will sort out, obviously it's a bit tough to say right now. How players develop over the summer will be extremely important. Guys like Artichuk and Ross have top 9, maybe even top 6 potential, but need to take a big step forward and it's impossible to say who will until we see them in the fall. Given the information we have now, here is what I would do next season:

Import - Bressette - Cohen
Spence - Saganiuk - Lockhart
Ross - Terrance - Artichuk
Edwards/Sawyer - Lowe - Smith

Traded: Sedore

Morton - Kyrou
Sova - Johnston
Kulakov - Sauder
Alboim

Traded: Thompson

Lalonde
Campbell

Nicholls released, Gibbons signed and sent to Jr. A/Jr. B for a season, can be called up in case of injury.

I am going to put my faith in the young guys to develop and give them playing time right away, trading Sedore to make room for them and recoup a draft pick or two. I think it's their best chance at being a contending team in 23/24 & 24/25. I'm also okay with using an OA spot on Campbell, as I think having 68 games of reliable goaltending and not burning Lalonde out will be crucial next season. I also think Gibbons will likely need a season of development. It's tough for rookie goalies in this league, especially one who will be 15 when the season starts (he's a November birthday).

There are a lot of variables here, especially the import and OA situation. Can they land a top 6 import forward with size? Will Kulakov return? How will they handle the backup goalie situation? What are they going to do about the coaching staff? A very interesting off-season is ahead of us. I'm certain this team will at least make the playoffs this season. How good their off-season is and how well players develop over the summer will determine if they will possibly settle into the 4-6 range and possibly win a round, or if they squeak in as a 7-8 seed and lose first round.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mata
The team finished poorly under BJ, but I think the honest question we have to ask ourselves is, was a 24-30-1-2 record the true talent level of the team? I think it probably was given the backup goalie situation. If they had sorted the backup goalie situation out and had BJ running things from the beginning, they could have been a .500 team and been in the 6-8 range. It's probably better long term they finished where they did though, Spence is a potentially game-breaking talent.

As for next season's team and how the depth chart will sort out, obviously it's a bit tough to say right now. How players develop over the summer will be extremely important. Guys like Artichuk and Ross have top 9, maybe even top 6 potential, but need to take a big step forward and it's impossible to say who will until we see them in the fall. Given the information we have now, here is what I would do next season:

Import - Bressette - Cohen
Spence - Saganiuk - Lockhart
Ross - Terrance - Artichuk
Edwards/Sawyer - Lowe - Smith

Traded: Sedore

Morton - Kyrou
Sova - Johnston
Kulakov - Sauder
Alboim

Traded: Thompson

Lalonde
Campbell

Nicholls released, Gibbons signed and sent to Jr. A/Jr. B for a season, can be called up in case of injury.

I am going to put my faith in the young guys to develop and give them playing time right away, trading Sedore to make room for them and recoup a draft pick or two. I think it's their best chance at being a contending team in 23/24 & 24/25. I'm also okay with using an OA spot on Campbell, as I think having 68 games of reliable goaltending and not burning Lalonde out will be crucial next season. I also think Gibbons will likely need a season of development. It's tough for rookie goalies in this league, especially one who will be 15 when the season starts (he's a November birthday).

There are a lot of variables here, especially the import and OA situation. Can they land a top 6 import forward with size? Will Kulakov return? How will they handle the backup goalie situation? What are they going to do about the coaching staff? A very interesting off-season is ahead of us. I'm certain this team will at least make the playoffs this season. How good their off-season is and how well players develop over the summer will determine if they will possibly settle into the 4-6 range and possibly win a round, or if they squeak in as a 7-8 seed and lose first round.

I guess it is an interesting perspective to look at possibly 2 OA players being traded and one scenario I kind of didn't give much thought to. With how young our defense is, getting draft picks and/or decent value out of Sedore and Thompson does allow Campbell to stay to shore up the goalie situation AND restock the cupboards or bring in another support player if we need to.

I agree though with most in that depending on our import situation a 6th seed or higher should be the goal. If by chance we miss the playoffs entirely it would be a huge let down and the coaching staff as well as DB should be let go immediately.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NOA
Great thoughts, EON and Mata

I agree that there is some room for optimism. Players need to develop but it helps that they have a lot of youth and options for doing so. They need Lockhart, Bressette, Saganiuk to take another step forward. Terrance probably needs to make the biggest jump. Then I think they just need 2 of Lowe, Smith, Ross, and Artichuk to take a jump. Lots of development needs to happen but the good news is that many of these guys showed promise or were higher draft picks to give you hope they can do so. They also need an import forward that can impact the game.

Not worried with the backend as they have plenty of bodies there and a good blend of size and offensive ability. Having everyone return means more experience and hopefully more structure. They can’t be any worse.

My only issue with keeping Campbell is I don’t think he’s ever played like a starter, let alone a good backup. Again, his career SV% is .872. He wasn’t great in the preseason or summer showcase either (prior to injury). He just has never been that good. If he’s going to be a .900 backup that can play 25-30 games, sure I’ll keep him. But I don’t think he’s that. I could be wrong and he has a huge offseason but I’m super skeptical. We would be better off relying on a 2021 prospect or finding someone via trade. All they have to be is better than .872 to make it worth it versus using an OA spot on a backup. Nicholls at .849 is not the answer. They have to find someone else and I just think Campbell isn’t the guy, especially using an OA tag. Now all that said - If Kulakov returns, they sign a top forward import, and the forwards develop - then that makes Sedore/Thompson expendable. In which case, you can at least give Campbell a shot. At least there are some options here because of the depth on the backend and the import draft.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mata
While there's no debating the Import Draft's importance, I think this upcoming U18 Draft is going to be another good opportunity for us to potentially get a better backup goalie or important depth piece. The players available for this U18 Draft weren't scouted their U16 year due to COVID, so there's an increased likelihood that legit prospects weren't drafted in the 2021 Priority Selection - particularly goalies, who are more difficult to project as it is.

Our pick at #2 overall might also show us what direction Brown intends to go in. If we go goalie at #2, got to think that decreases the likelihood Campbell returns. If we go D, it's more likely that one or more of Kulakov and/or Thompson don't return. A defensively responsible, bottom-six forward with size would also make sense, and make Sedore all the more expendable.

Like NOA said, lots of OPTIONS here for Brown and co. His ability to select the right ones will determine whether we can really contend in the next couple/few seasons.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad