Proposal: Edmonton - Toronto

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
No.

The message you have entered is too short. Please lengthen your message to at least 4 characters.
 
I figured it would be something along the lines of either Matthews to edm or McDavid to Toronto

Neither will happen
 
Never going to happen.

You want Matthews...would cost you McDavid.




Didnt think so.



And that's the end of that.
 
Watching McDavid and Matthews do their magic in the WCH wondering if there is a way to unite these two for good.

Toronto receives

RNH/Draisaitl +Nurse + 2nd (2017)

Edmonton receives

Matthews

The only player they would trade Mathews for at least on this board, is Mcjeesus, I know that's ridiculous, but this is a team that hasn't had a player like Mathews since Sundin, and that was a long time ago.
 
The only player that I see Matthews being traded for is McDavid and that's obviously not happening. So no.
 
Lol. As if Edmonton is the one team in the NHL that needs yet another top center.

Talk about being greedy.
 
Never going to happen.

You want Matthews...would cost you McDavid.




Didnt think so.



And that's the end of that.

This response sums it up. The OP and everyone on here knows exactly how this thread would play out so what's the point in even creating it? Lock it up.
 
Never happening. EDM doesn't need anymore young C's anyways, remember they just drafted Pulju who is very likely going to be McDavids future winger.
 
Watching McDavid and Matthews do their magic in the WCH wondering if there is a way to unite these two for good.

Toronto receives

RNH/Draisaitl +Nurse + 2nd (2017)

Edmonton receives

Matthews

Matthews is awesome but Mcdavid had Yakapov looking like an allstar. Makes no sense for the oilers..and likely makes no sense for TOR
 
This would be kind of like a Patrick Laine + Trouba + 1st round pick trade for McDavid - the value is there, but just wouldn't be done for optics.

Also, I would think Draisaitl has more value than RNH now, and I love RNH.
 
Toronto passes. No idea what Nurse becomes, a 2nd isn't that enticing and downgrading from Matthews to Drai is illogical. The Leaf have their Franchise centreman, they are loath to deal him beyond a ridiculous overpayment.
 
Toronto says no since they need a #1 C

but lets be real. Every single winger who has played with McDavid has looked like an all-star. Patrick Maroon and friggen Yakupov were near point per game players when they played with McDavid.

Eberle's point totals went from very sub par to over a ppg with McDavid.

He doesn't need a superstar winger. he needs a guy who can either finish or win board battles
 
Lol. As if Edmonton is the one team in the NHL that needs yet another top center.

Talk about being greedy.

This response sums it up. The OP and everyone on here knows exactly how this thread would play out so what's the point in even creating it? Lock it up.

well the funny part is that OP is a Leafs fan so NO the Oilers fans are not being greedy here..
 
So the leafs get their first franchise center since sundown and just trade him away for scraps? Not going to happen.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad