Blue Suede Shoes
hound dog
- May 5, 2012
- 1,791
- 0
Outside of Ehrhoff, Gillis has done a great job of keeping our core players here at great prices.
The thing is, ATT I'm pretty sure the main thing Ehrhoff wanted was security ie. NTC. And he got a NTC & NMC in his next contract, with Buffalo.
So if that is what he wanted, could we have Hamhuis Bieksa Edler Garrison Ehrhoff all locked up for ~5 million - all with NTCs? That's too many NTCs imo. It constrains our roster.
Giving Ehrhoff a NTC probably meant we couldn't add Garrison, because Garrison would definitely want a NTC as well. And Garrison is the better dman for our team.
The other issue is that Ehrhoff is reported to have wanted 5.5 million per.
Now this is just a rumour, but if true, that would mean Garrison probably wouldn't sign for less than 5.5. Which would be another reason we couldn't add Garrison to our roster. And once again, Garrison seems like the much better choice for our team.
And then, if Ehrhoff gets 5.5, Edler is going to want more than him for sure. So maybe we're looking at 6+ million, and our cap structure start to fall apart.
So what's better: Garrison at 4.6 and Edler at 5.0? Or Ehrhoff at 5.5, Edler at 6.0, no Garrison, and subsequent contracts costing more?