I'll concede Carlo's another good candidate for Seventh Player. I think his baseline expectations might have been a little bit higher than Moore's, but he's done amazingly well with Chara, and isn't half-bad with the mishmash we currently have.
Pasta's the "people's choice"...I mean, if you took his expectations when he was drafted and told where he was today...then ABSOLUTELY, he exceeds expectations. But he did with the award in his rookie year, when, IMHO, it was most warranted. My expectations with him are high, and he exceeds them...but not as much as Moore exceeds his expectations. That said, people who vote will vote for the "big names".