Does Trocheck put the Rangers over the top?

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates

Does the Trocheck signing put NYR over the top?

  • Yes, we will win the Cup in 22-23

    Votes: 31 20.4%
  • No, but we will be in the Cup Final

    Votes: 27 17.8%
  • No, we are still behind other Eastern Conference teams (Pitt, Toronto, etc)

    Votes: 27 17.8%
  • Too early to tell - let FA finish

    Votes: 67 44.1%

  • Total voters
    152

HANK30

Tom Brady 4-3 in SBs without Patriot cheating
Just curious where everyone thinks we stand after the Trocheck signing. As of today, I think the Rangers and Pens are the best teams in the Eastern Conference. Tampa IMO takes a step back because of the losses of Palat and Rutta. Toronto lost Jack Campbell but adds Samsonov, who is a big downgrade...
 
No. He's an improvement over Strome in theory, but we'll need to see how he meshes with Panarin. It may end up a downgrade offensively.

What would put us over the top is a major leap from Lafreniere or Kakko (or even Kravtsov), combined with the continued development of Miller, Schneider, and possibly Jones or Lundkvist.

Even then, it probably takes a TDL acquisition to help mask whatever our biggest weakness is, to truly put us over the top.

We should be in good position for at least the next few years, though.
 
No. He's an improvement over Strome in theory, but we'll need to see how he meshes with Panarin. It may end up a downgrade offensively.

What would put us over the top is a major leap from Lafreniere or Kakko (or even Kravtsov), combined with the continued development of Miller, Schneider, and possibly Jones or Lundkvist.

Even then, it probably takes a TDL acquisition to help mask whatever our biggest weakness is, to truly put us over the top.

We should be in good position for at least the next few years, though.

Yeah this, need growth from the young top picks and in general every cup team fills some holes or needs at the TDL to help out

Also need Panarin to show up in the playoffs

E: I think Trocheck puts them in a better spot than they were with Strome though
 
If a person watched the playoffs this year, then comes to the conclusion Kane will put the Rangers over the top, I am questioning several things. First and foremost, I am questioning their sanity, then were they really watching the 2013 playoffs.

Trocheck is a good signing. This team needs speeds and ability to get and keep the puck in the offensive zone. VT gives the Rangers more ability in that respect than Copp and much more than Strome. Looking at the contracts doled out, the Rangers did it at a fair market price
 
If everything stays the same as it was last year, performance wise for everyone else still here, but now we have Trocheck, I can't see the needle being moved TOO much. Have to see how he fits with Panarin, if that is even where he eventually ends up.

Everything matters on the what K'Filaapo Laftsov does in terms of putting us *over the top*.

I would think the most realistic scenario is we go into the playoffs in a similar position as last year. Not a bad thing!

*Edit* looks like others above me already covered this.
 
I am not sure there is such a thing as realistically putting a team "over the top"

Being 50/50, or slightly better, to win any playoff series against any opponent they may run into is probably about as close as teams get to being considered over the top. And even then the probability of winning 2, 3, 4 coin flips straight is still not all that high. Injuries, performances, officiating, variance, and match-ups come into play.

I think they'll be pretty good though.
 
No. He's an improvement over Strome in theory, but we'll need to see how he meshes with Panarin. It may end up a downgrade offensively.

What would put us over the top is a major leap from Lafreniere or Kakko (or even Kravtsov), combined with the continued development of Miller, Schneider, and possibly Jones or Lundkvist.

Even then, it probably takes a TDL acquisition to help mask whatever our biggest weakness is, to truly put us over the top.

We should be in good position for at least the next few years, though.
This is perfectly put.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nyr2k2
This team is better than the team that started last year and with more defined expectations under Gallant. 2C upgrade, Kravs back, no Nemeth, more depth, another year of experience for Kakko, Laf, Chytil, Miller, Schneider, Shesty etc., a possibility of other top prospects to push for a roster spot. There is not 1 team in the east that is clearly better.
 
I think they are in a spot that isn't really reflected on the poll. I don't know if they will make the conference finals or cup finals, but I think they are as good as any team in the East.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gump116

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad