Do you think Dustin Brown is dirty? (MOD Warning in post #4)

  • Thread starter Thread starter KingKopitar11*
  • Start date Start date
  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
Nah, he's never been dirty, just a clutz and he is reckless. He is not strong on his skates and was taught to skate hard through everything and keep his feet moving. He fearlessly and foolhardily runs around the ice into any situation. Just about all of the time when he goes down he is legitimately tripped or thrown off balance. He's just a winger that skates a little too hard if that is possible.
Pretty well put... add in the fact that he hits a ton and something is bound to happen.
I'll bet he does go down a little easy at times, but I dont expect a player to nessisarily give 110% to avoid drawing a penalty..
 
I suggest anyone who thinks he's dirty watch a Kings game and focus on 23 solely all game. You'll see what reckless means. He is constantly tripping and falling.
 
2500+ career hits.

If the guy was out there trying to hurt people he's not doing a very good job.

I especially love that people continue to include the Rousell hit when compiling their list of 7 youtube clips. The guy hits himself in the face with his own stick, flops, and does his best starfish impression and yet it keeps getting posted.
 
Brownie plays on the edge and really doesn't give a **** who he hits. I can see why other fans think he's dirty, but I think he's just a throwback who walks the line.
 
Dirty ?

Watch Brad Marchand play just once.....

Brown is not even close to Dirty, Diver ? Yes, Stupid sometimes ? Yes.

Bad Skater ? In spades...

You could play a killer drinking game watching Brownie...Take a Drink every time he falls with no one around him.
 
More than a fair take, thanks for being diplomatic :)

Agreed on the intentions part, and as others have said, it might be more semantics than anything, but 'dirty' to me implies intent.

Dirty:

Keep in mind that even before that play Hanzal was running around like a total dick trying to take off everyone's heads--was surprised he didn't take a 2 before this.

I'd say very little of what Brown does is premeditated outside of tying his skates.


That's the definition of dirty right there.

Brown is reckless but not in a class of dirty.
 
Just don't feed it and it stops.

Problem is people want to talk in circles.

Not going to change anyone's mind at this point, and there's nothing new to talk about--it's the same old bickering about incidents people have already made up their minds about. I remember we were on a 3-day layoff doing absolutely nothing and a Brown thread popped up. It's insanity. I'm not engaging in any Brown discussion until something stupid happens (which I'm willing to bet happens to him again before it happens by his hand).
 
Welp looks like the cup thread is about Brown again. Oh man, fans are obsessed with him.
It's the usual suspects with the same old agenda. I'm not going to even post in that thread if that's all they're going to talk about. It would be smart if a mod just made a Brown "discussion" (lol) thread on the SC board to keep that cancer from spreading to everything else. This way people can enjoy a discussion about the series without putting their brain cells at risk.
 
Just don't feed it and it stops.

Problem is people want to talk in circles.

Not going to change anyone's mind at this point, and there's nothing new to talk about--it's the same old bickering about incidents people have already made up their minds about. I remember we were on a 3-day layoff doing absolutely nothing and a Brown thread popped up. It's insanity. I'm not engaging in any Brown discussion until something stupid happens (which I'm willing to bet happens to him again before it happens by his hand).

Nope, not gonna get in to that. You just can't get through some fans, they simply loath him.

Have fun moding the thread! :D
 
A mod just needs too shut down the Brown talk, it will stop.

The Thread should be focused on the series.
 
Yeah my bad guys, I should have made the voters be visible. I honestly think he's reckless, he doesn't seem like a player that intentionally target players.
 
Brown is not reckless, he is just Stupid. The guy doesn't think sometimes.

That's stupid.

Reckless people still know what they are doing, Brown doesn't think that far ahead.

Brad Marchand is reckless, cause he knows exactly what he is doing.
He just doesn't give a shi$%t, that is reckless.
 
2500+ career hits.

If the guy was out there trying to hurt people he's not doing a very good job.

I especially love that people continue to include the Rousell hit when compiling their list of 7 youtube clips. The guy hits himself in the face with his own stick, flops, and does his best starfish impression and yet it keeps getting posted.

You nailed it.

For the bulk of his career Brown had a reputation of hitting hard but clean. The only thing that's shifted is the Kings winning most of their playoff series the last two years. Well that, and other teams/fanbases melting down about it. Rozsival turned out to have a thigh bruise and they can't let it go, for the love of god. Was that what he was supposed to be suspended for? Or what, the slow mo gif of him hitting Jaden Schwartz in shoulder with his elbow?

The collision with Hertl is a good example of this. The textbook definition of kneeing is to extend the leg while going for a hit, and Brown doesn't even have weight on that leg (Hertl does). But Hertl goes down and suddenly Brown's the new Marchment, lol. Watch some actual Marchment clips and get back to us. If there had been any hallmarks of kneeing Brown would have been nailed to the wall for it, and their GM who loves gamesmanship would have howled to the moon over more than a lack of "manners." There is no magic no-suspension halo.

You know once someone posts "we know it has to be intentionally dirty, because it's Brown" that they have lost all ability to evaluate the clips front of their eyes. And they aren't going to post clips of Brown's other 2,000+ hits that are fine, because that's not the evidence they seek. HFBoards confirmation bias at its finest.

Want an actual dirty player? Torres has a rap sheet as long as my arm, and knocked out other players with a concussion three playoffs in a row. In each incident, he had plenty of time to make a better hit through the body and didn't. As much as Sharks fans would love to make him Brown's moral equal to feel better about Torres on their team, it is not even close.
 
You nailed it.

For the bulk of his career Brown had a reputation of hitting hard but clean. The only thing that's shifted is the Kings winning most of their playoff series the last two years. Well that, and other teams/fanbases melting down about it. Rozsival turned out to have a thigh bruise and they can't let it go, for the love of god. Was that what he was supposed to be suspended for? Or what, the slow mo gif of him hitting Jaden Schwartz in shoulder with his elbow?

The collision with Hertl is a good example of this. The textbook definition of kneeing is to extend the leg while going for a hit, and Brown doesn't even have weight on that leg (Hertl does). But Hertl goes down and suddenly Brown's the new Marchment, lol. Watch some actual Marchment clips and get back to us. If there had been any hallmarks of kneeing Brown would have been nailed to the wall for it, and their GM who loves gamesmanship would have howled to the moon over more than a lack of "manners." There is no magic no-suspension halo.

You know once someone posts "we know it has to be intentionally dirty, because it's Brown" that they have lost all ability to evaluate the clips front of their eyes. And they aren't going to post clips of Brown's other 2,000+ hits that are fine, because that's not the evidence they seek. HFBoards confirmation bias at its finest.

Want an actual dirty player? Torres has a rap sheet as long as my arm, and knocked out other players with a concussion three playoffs in a row. In each incident, he had plenty of time to make a better hit through the body and didn't. As much as Sharks fans would love to make him Brown's moral equal to feel better about Torres on their team, it is not even close.

I will say it again, Brad Marchand actually swung his stick at someone's head with force(with full intent too injure).

Shawn Thornton beat a defenseless player on the ice while the guy was down...

When has Brown ever done anything like that ?
 
I will say it again, Brad Marchand actually swung his stick at someone's head with force(with full intent too injure).

Shawn Thornton beat a defenseless player on the ice while the guy was down...

When has Brown ever done anything like that ?

Never. And all the dumb****s that troll about Brown call him a whiner. He isn't a whiner either.
 
And *******, 28 pages of a Dustin Brown stroke-fest. Don't these people have a life? All they do is obsess over him. They probably have a sculpture in their closet of him like Helga in Hey Arnold.
 
And *******, 28 pages of a Dustin Brown stroke-fest. Don't these people have a life? All they do is obsess over him. They probably have a sculpture in their closet of him like Helga in Hey Arnold.
It will never stop unless Brown is traded to the Sharks, then they will kiss his feet like they do to Torres.
 
It will never stop unless Brown is traded to the Sharks, then they will kiss his feet like they do to Torres.

This was me going through that thread...

Seinfeld-Laughing-with-Cigar.gif


So many rustled jimmies.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad