If you’re not paying attention to matchups AND not constructing lines properly, you end up with Hughes and Bratt out there vs Mathews nursing a one goal lead with 5 to play. There’s a time and place to play the matchup game. First minute of a period, last 3 minutes of a period. Protecting a one goal lead late.
It’s malpractice to ignore that, just as it’s malpractice to run Madden, Pandolfo, and Shanny out there vs Staal in 09 every single time. Let balance and logic dictate when to matchup.
Again, you cannot fully control this - a line can get caught in the defensive zone and then matched up against, either as a result of an icing or a too-long shift, but also, what are you talking about? The Leafs line on the ice that scored the game tying goal against Hughes-Bratt was Bunting-Acciari-Kampf. So your anecdotal point about Ruff being bad at matchups isn't even making sense, unless you're talking about the Hughes shift before, which I don't see why you would be, because there weren't anywhere near 5 minutes left when that happened, or you're just hypothesizing about not paying attention to matchups at all.
I don't agree about the start of the period or the end of the period either. In an away game, I just start my best line and whatever the opposition counters with, fine.
Moreover, Hughes is 21 and one of the best players in the league, and Bratt isn't a veteran either - these guys need to figure how to be on the ice to protect leads. They did a pretty good job last night.
Doing a little forward casting, in a couple of seasons the Devils may be getting the most goal contributions of anyone in the league from their defense.
Hamilton will still be scoring goals, Nemec has last years playoffs and this AHL year to suggest he will score goals, and Hughes has 2 seasons where he has been a good scorer.
I'm not sold on Nemec as a goal scorer, at least watching the highlights a lot of these are just random shots from distance that don't seem to have much special about them. If he's getting closer to the home plate area on plays where he's not scoring, I'd be more convinced, but I don't have evidence of that.