Pending departures were the theme as the Stanley Cup champion Penguins cleared out their lockers Thursday, but I was more interested in an arrival.
Mike Sullivan’s.
The question of how, precisely, Sullivan found his way into this organization had been a subject of great curiosity (mine, anyway) since he started winning a lot of games midway through the 2015-16 season.
I knew he’d worked with Rick Tocchet and crossed paths with fellow Bostonian Bill Guerin. He knew people in the Penguins organization. But who suggested Sullivan as a replacement for John Hynes in Wilkes-Barre? Who made the first phone call? How did the process play out?
Neither Sullivan nor general manager Jim Rutherford would give me straight answers to those questions last season. It all seemed very mysterious. And it all seems fairly pertinent at the moment, given the fact that Sullivan arguably has become the best coach in the NHL.
He is the first coach since Toe Blake, for goodness' sake, to win Stanley Cups in his first two seasons with a team.
So how did he get here?
The first name you need to know is a name you know already for reasons good and bad. Tom Fitzgerald. His unlikely goal ended the Penguins’ playoff run in 1996. But he helped the Penguins win a Cup as an assistant coach in 2009. He is now an assistant general manager with the New Jersey Devils.
“Sully” and “Fitzy” go waaaay back. They played in the same youth leagues around Boston, then against each other in high school. They took recruiting trips together. Sullivan wound up at Boston University, Fitzgerald at Providence.
The two nearly played together in the NHL when Fitzgerald was named captain of the first-year Nashville Predators, who picked Sullivan in the expansion draft before trading him four days later.
Fitzgerald later played for Sullivan in Boston, during Sully’s brief stint as Bruins coach (so if you’re comparing him to Bill Belichick, which is perfectly appropriate, that was his Cleveland Browns run).
Now fast forward 10 years, to June 2, 2015, the day former Penguins general manager Ray Shero hired Hynes away from Wilkes-Barre to coach the Devils. Rutherford told assistant general manager Jason Botterill he wanted a replacement with NHL experience because he knew he might be firing Mike Johnston early in the season.
Rutherford’s braintrust, including Botterill, Fitzgerald and Guerin, compiled a list of names.
Guerin, when I spoke with him a year ago, said Fitzgerald mentioned Sullivan.
“Tom lives in Boston and has a good relationship with Sully,” Guerin said. “He was the first one to bring the name up.”
Fitzgerald was the first one to call Sullivan, as well. I confirmed as much with Sullivan Thursday.
“It meant a lot to me,” Sullivan said. “We go way back, and I have so much respect for [Fitzgerald]. He’s such a quality person. So, yeah, when he called to gauge my interest, it meant a lot.”
Sullivan had just finished a year as a development coach with the Chicago Blackhawks. He wanted to be a head coach in the NHL again, and the best route was to go back to the AHL.
The Penguins weren’t the only team calling. Some wanted Sullivan as an NHL assistant, others as a minor-league head coach.
“We knew we were in competition,” Fitzgerald recalled earlier this week. “I’d like to think his relationship with me helped, but it was a team effort.”
Fitzgerald added: “I think he’s a way better coach the second time around. He learned from Boston. He matured as a coach. I think he understood players better, the young guys, and he was open to everything. Like, we were really high on Jay Leach as an assistant coach, and Sully didn’t come in saying, ‘No, I want my guy.’ He wasn’t reluctant at all.
“We were lucky to get him, to be honest.”
Fitzgerald and Botterill interviewed Sullivan together and were sufficiently blown away. But they had one other candidate in mind (identity remains a mystery), so Botterill went to Rutherford. Here’s what might have clinched it: Rutherford had met Sullivan exactly one time, by chance, nine years earlier, and he, too, had been sufficiently blown away.
That was June 2006. The Bruins were in the midst of a drawn-out firing of Sullivan, who remembers bumping into Rutherford (then Carolina’s general manager) at an airport.
“We had a good chat,” Sullivan recalled. “But I think Jim probably has a clearer memory of it.”
As usual, Sullivan was right.
“I remember it very well,” Rutherford said. “I told him I thought he’d done a great job in Boston, and I was sorry with the way he was being treated. Something about him stood out.”
Which is why Rutherford’s ears perked nine years later when Botterill mentioned Sullivan as one of the two final candidates to coach Wilkes-Barre (and thus have a real chance to coach the Pittsburgh Penguins sooner rather than later). Rutherford looked at Botterill and said, “I always liked that Mike Sullivan.”
The rest, as they say, is history. And it goes to show that, while the current organization obviously deserves the credit, a championship team always has hidden helpers.
Could be a guy like Fitzgerald (who signed Conor Sheary in his final act as a Penguins executive). Could be a scout like Scott Bell, who fought for drafting Jake Guentzel, or a scout like Brian Fitzgerald (no relation to Tom) who made the case for Bryan Rust.
All kinds of folks have their fingerprints on that Cup, and it wasn’t long after Sullivan took his turn with it Sunday night that his old buddy Tom Fitzgerald checked in with a text message.
“I just said, ‘Mike, you’re cementing your legacy. Congrats again. I’m just so happy for you,’ ” Fitzgerald said.
Sully’s response?
“He was very thankful.”
A lot of other people are, too.