News Article: - Deeper Look at the Tim Thomas Trade | Page 4 | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League

News Article: Deeper Look at the Tim Thomas Trade

Status
Not open for further replies.
again, consider the context. also, consider that we could be supporting JT with on ice talent instead of expending the mental nickels and dimes to support a shaved down roster...

Naw, man. You got it all wrong. All of this nonsense, and spending as little cash as possible, and figuring out ways to artificially inflate cap numbers is cool because the Isles now might be able to get an extra draft pick.
 
For arguments sake; we already know via TSN's Bobby Mac, that adding Visnovsky already brought the Isles over the cap. Isles are spending not one penny on Thomas. His cap hit of 5 million costs Wang, ZERO. Now assume the Isles completely fall out of the playoff race, this allows Snow to gain picks while ensuring the team remains over the cap. If he can use Thomas' cap hit and gain extra picks, isn't that a good thing?

again, consider the context. also, consider that we could be supporting JT with on ice talent instead of expending the mental nickels and dimes to support a shaved down roster... 5 years ago, fine. four, three years ago, fine, ok. two years ago, borderline ok. last year, borderline not ok. now, not ok.
you have to reach kansas eventually.

I agree I was just putting it out there. I don't think we should be a floor team. We should be spending legit money to get in the mid 50 million range.
 
still up, couldn't find that damn Ambien. I think beach took my advice and snatched it.


Tell me when Snow makes a trade to make us compete during a season, like he's trying to get us winning. Maybe you can also let me know when he gets a good coach not very familiar with good chowder?

Trade what? You do realize we would have to give up assets as well, right? Which would likely be a prospect, why bother when rebuilding?
A good coach? Roy Sommer comes to mind, especially with a young team. No idea if he'll leave his comfortable AHL job though.


Be patient. The loopy kid walking into the walls and falling over and over again will eventually make it to the other side or whatever he's trying to do. One day we'll get the right Reasoner to get us #5!!!!

Personally can't wait for that scrub to retire and Brock Nelson to take his place, you?


So no more complaining. Our passing game is amazing and there's no shortage of hustle.:yo:

That's Kooky Cappy for ya :cry:


And there are no budget constraints. Snow could get an elite winger for JT and Moulson but chooses not to.....so we can CONFUSE the opponent. They will never see it coming!

If you can't sign or trade, then draft/develop. Which is exactly what we're doing. ;)

And what cracks me up about Ol' Time Thinker...I mean Hockey is that he must be so annoyed with all the huge blockbuster trades happening in this league to wonder why the Isles aren't making any....oh wait, duh there aren't ANY happening. The reason being...teams spent pre new cba time locking up their big players for outrageously high contracts that have caused them to be immovable. The GM's that haven't done that refuse to move their players without a king's ransom. Look, if these trades were popping off left and right I'd buy it...but they aren't. So stop asking for our GM to do something NO GM is doing...it's just absurd. Absolutely absurd.

Bobby Ryan...still playing in Anaheim

What are the other ones that got away?
 
Isn't one of the reasons the isles traded for lubo is because he has a 3 million actual salary, 5.6 million cap hit?

Deduct yashin's BO, thomas's fake cap hit, and 2.6 mil from lubo, and the isles are at a $43 million cash payroll for players on the team. Not sure if there's any other salary vs cap hit differences. I didn't look at every contract.

(BTW, I'm speaking as a neutral 3rd party. I could care less if the isles spend to the cap and are a great team, or if wang trades for 5 tim thomas contracts and they go 0-82. I just find this discussion more interesting then most of the other stuff going on in the league)
 
As you said, remains to be seen. I don't see him reporting here. Look how long Vis resisted, but him I fully expected over, and not just so he can play overseas next year, but here in the NHL.

Thomas? He strikes me as a different sort.


Moulson is pretty forgettable if he isn't paired with MM. You probably never saw him play off his line. I have. He becomes a real nobody fast. Streit is wearing down and due for the glue farm soon. His start to every season minus his first here has been abysmal. Vis won't be here next year, so why even bring him up? Nielsen is the best checking unit center being miss-used in a 2nd scoring center role, and also the best one who can't handle power forwards at all. He is inadequate in a fundamental way because of that. He is also a weakling who Pat Kane could probably beat up. MacDonald has been average to bad for us this year. He is a good 4/5 on a real team. He is a good depth defenseman, but he is not a real shut down guy. He simply lacks the size to be that next step in effective. Okposo is the American Oleg Kvasha. His need for a half a season to show up is maddening. He is also a giant Mary, as is all of the top 6. Grabner has yet to get his whole game on the same page, but he is a weakling I'd keep. Most of the rest need an upgrade physically. Aucoin is not top 6 and never will be. On a real team he is a 4th line nobody, and he is also small.

Did you just compare this club to Chicago? Toews, Kane, Sharp, Hossa, Seabrook, Kieth, Leddy... Compare that to Tavares & Hamonic. You can't do that with a straight face.

Al Arbour disagrees completely. It takes both, to get goals, and then to close out.

The bottom line is this club under Wang's direction goes into the season with one goal in mind: save money. The roster is built for that. 29 Other teams go into the season with the goal of winning games. That's why our club is a laughingstock.

Moulson must be forgettable if you have him playing with himself :naughty:
 
In the Toronto game, Butch and Howie talked about how the Islanders are dead last in the league in 5-on-5 play.

They're dead last in 5v5 goals against, but 5th in 5v5 goals for. That means their problem is almost exclusively goaltending.

As for the rest of this thread:

 
Isn't one of the reasons the isles traded for lubo is because he has a 3 million actual salary, 5.6 million cap hit?

Deduct yashin's BO, thomas's fake cap hit, and 2.6 mil from lubo, and the isles are at a $43 million cash payroll for players on the team. Not sure if there's any other salary vs cap hit differences. I didn't look at every contract.

(BTW, I'm speaking as a neutral 3rd party. I could care less if the isles spend to the cap and are a great team, or if wang trades for 5 tim thomas contracts and they go 0-82. I just find this discussion more interesting then most of the other stuff going on in the league)

:nod:

It is also the reason they haven't declared Rick medically unfit and retired him against his own will. There isn't a fan in Islander country who doesn't know Rick's done, and now we have the admission he has had a chronic condition the past three years that was kept hidden... Garth knew. Chuck knew. The Docs knew. All in the name of saving Wang money.

It's a pretty nice deal Wang has. Force the club to use an injured idealist as a backup, collect insurance money when he's injured which is most of the time, yet have his entire salary count against the cap.

I can't wait to see how he spends the league revenue sharing check - maybe gold plated mud flaps for his golf cart.
 
They're dead last in 5v5 goals against, but 5th in 5v5 goals for. That means their problem is almost exclusively goaltending.

The Islanders are tied for 11th in 5 on 5 Goals For.
They are 29th in 5 on 5 goals against. That means their defense sucks. Your reference to goaltending is funny though, because it would imply you haven't actually watched the games. Nabby hasn't been lights out, but he has been good enough. The problem has been the other 5 guys for the most part. Our top line has two floaters who seem offended by the concept of back checking, and we have mostly softies, small fries, or both on the blueline with Carkner and Strait out. Your attempt to disguise our goals against as owing to anything else but team defense is sad.

But hey, those couple of extra draft picks should help this club next week... 7 years from now. Great plan there.

Interns, gotta love them.

Reference: http://www.nhl.com/ice/teamstats.htm?fetchKey=20132ALLSAAAll&sort=avgGoalsPerGame&viewName=goalsFor
 
Last edited:
Wang this summer admitted there were, so you are wrong. You should update your material if you are going to defend this laughingstock of an owner/organization.

I was quoting someone else, and they were being satirical. Try again.


We are drafting, yes, and sometimes poorly. Getting caught dumping a bunch of assets into Calvin the Fra-gil-le' and trying to make up for it with a ridiculous defensemen-mostly draft was and still is embarrasing. That it leaked that we offered all of our draft picks for Larsson is even more embarrassing but at least they realized, finally, that you can't go mostly offense with your drafting like the previous years. I guess that is something. Maybe Reinhart will be a top 4 player by 2020. I hope I am still alive to see it.


Wouldn't take the deal either. Has anyone considered that Snow/Wang is spending money on scouting instead signing slightly better role players? Our front office isn't very forthcoming.
It's also worth noting Snow offered all his picks for the second overall pick. i.e. Ryan Murray. He/scouting obviously saw something in him. Though he's injured now, so we may of avoided another de Haan.

Considering we drafted all defence last draft is a good example. Snow put precedence on what (was) our weakest position. It's still at the NHL level, but not for prospects.
I wouldn't knock Snow's drafting, especially not this early. I am impressed by his drafting in the later rounds. De Haan was a flub, but his career isn't done yet.

I would bet Snow will look into drafting a bluechip defenseman. Seth Jones would look awfully nice in our colours.
If none are available, it's safe to say he'll go for a winger. Or just BPA if there's a substantial gap.


Development... now that is an interesting issue with this club, because they aren't very good at it. The club is so bereft of veteran leadership with a few skills that it hurts to see them blow games like kids vs. adults sometimes. They should be adding decent vets to help provide stability on the ice, but instead we get ahl scrubs, waiver garbage, and projects like Boyes. Some work out, many don't like Pock, Hillen, Reasoner, Schremp, etc. The club is too kid heavy, with most of the kids being average. Yes, if we had a club like Chicago that quickly scores 4 franchise players in a short time span maybe you can do it, but we didn't do that. Our draft picks that have made it to the club so far outside of Hamonic and JT are pretty middling. They aren't leaders. Martin will grow into one, but he is currently in improvement mode and shouldn't be saddled with that kind of responsibility, not yet anyway. They instead give us Mark ****ing Streit who is about as good a leader as Yashin. Bad idea.

Touche. And we need better coaching at all levels.
I feel we should look into getting an ECHL affliate. (All teams should have both AA, AAA imo) Doing this may help Bridgeport as well.

It's not like there's very many skilled players going into free agency. PA was offered 4mil for 4 years, which was risque at the time no doubt. He's scoring now, but there was no guarantee he'd continue to do so.


We need a few better parts and you would see the club's development improve more. This? This roster is just a cheap owner not giving a crap about the Islanders and Garf putting lipstick on a pig.

Of course I want to see us improve, but I know rebuilding can take up to a decade before the results play off. Chicago took eight years to rebuild, look at them now, they're unstoppable.

I'd say this rebuild started in 2008. We tried the playoffs in 2007, didn't work.


Moulson is pretty forgettable if he isn't paired with MM.

Moulson is forgettable in general, I don't think I've ever seen a more boring 30 goal scorer.
I'm not complaining, as long as he scores I don't care if he isn't flashy.


It is also the reason they haven't declared Rick medically unfit and retired him against his own will. There isn't a fan in Islander country who doesn't know Rick's done, and now we have the admission he has had a chronic condition the past three years that was kept hidden... Garth knew. Chuck knew. The Docs knew. All in the name of saving Wang money.

How is that saving money for Wang? That would mean insurance would have to pay him, (from being medically unfit to play.) If anything they're holding onto him hoping he'll retire from injury, so he won't count towards the cap and the Isles don't have to pay him for the next decade. He isn't retiring and they're getting impatient (rightfully so.)
Now they can buy him out without his cap hit sticking, it might seem like a blessing for Wang now, the next ten years? Not so much. But it's the better of the two evils.
 
They're dead last in 5v5 goals against, but 5th in 5v5 goals for. That means their problem is almost exclusively goaltending.

As for the rest of this thread:




Oh god this is bloody brilliant. How you managed to narrow that down to goaltending is beyond me. The fact that the defense is littered with Hamonic, two aging and offensive-minded d-men, and a bunch of waiver wire scrubs surely has no impact on goals against. Neither does the fact that the top line consists of two wingers who don't even know what defense is. Nope, the only player who has any impact on goals against is the goaltender.
 
They're dead last in 5v5 goals against, but 5th in 5v5 goals for. That means their problem is almost exclusively goaltending.

As for the rest of this thread:


Cute video, but I have a more appropriate one for those who seem to be in a bizarre state of denial when it comes to this team's management and ownership:



This thread is a textbook example of why one cannot rely on numbers and statistics alone when it comes to sports. No matter how hard you try to whitewash the Islanders using stats, at the end of the day they're still doing everything they can to avoid spending real dollars while Garth insults our intelligence by insisting he has no financial limitations ( :laugh: ) and it shows in their performance. Three points out of the East basement, a familiar position for them in case you haven't been paying attention.

I've seen a couple of amusingly bad arguments floated in this thread, such as "the Islanders were over the floor before the Thomas deal!!1" and "standings don't matter, look at the LA Kings!!1" Regarding the former, a team that's already loaded with useless salary and inflated cap hits adding a bogus five million dollar hit - one which will never see a penny of actual money spent - not only reinforces what most of us have noticed about Wang and his spending, but also sends a message to the team that they're expecting to unload even more actual salary at some point instead of taking some on in an attempt to - wait for it - improve the team and COMPETE. And as for the Kings argument, please don't embarrass yourself - anyone who fancies themselves a statistician should know the exception is not the rule. Name one team since the lockout other than LA that hoisted the Cup without finishing in the top four of their conference... I'll wait.

Lastly, if one wants to make the argument that Garth Snow is a shrewd GM because he seems to know the CBA inside and out and uses that knowledge to satisfy his owner, I agree 100%. IMO Garth has no integrity and seems to believe the fans don't realize what the organization is doing (which is probably true for the casual fan), but he's no idiot. I have no doubt he would be able to assemble a more competitive team if Wang was not leaning on him to spend as little as possible, and he showed as much by surprising everyone with the Smyth deal back in '07 (before Wang's Lighthouse project failure and subsequent wallet-closing). That said, I don't care how much Garth has done to work the CBA and save Wang money - as a fan, my interest lies in seeing the team win, not cut costs in new and creative ways. So as far as putting a winning product on ice goes, Garth has been a failure - I just don't consider him primarily accountable because no GM can or will succeed with someone like Wang calling the shots.
 
This thread is a textbook example of why one cannot rely on numbers and statistics alone when it comes to sports. No matter how hard you try to whitewash the Islanders using stats, at the end of the day they're still doing everything they can to avoid spending real dollars while Garth insults our intelligence by insisting he has no financial limitations ( :laugh: ) and it shows in their performance. Three points out of the East basement, a familiar position for them in case you haven't been paying attention.

I've seen a couple of amusingly bad arguments floated in this thread, such as "the Islanders were over the floor before the Thomas deal!!1" and "standings don't matter, look at the LA Kings!!1" Regarding the former, a team that's already loaded with useless salary and inflated cap hits adding a bogus five million dollar hit - one which will never see a penny of actual money spent - not only reinforces what most of us have noticed about Wang and his spending, but also sends a message to the team that they're expecting to unload even more actual salary at some point instead of taking some on in an attempt to - wait for it - improve the team and COMPETE. And as for the Kings argument, please don't embarrass yourself - anyone who fancies themselves a statistician should know the exception is not the rule. Name one team since the lockout other than LA that hoisted the Cup without finishing in the top four of their conference... I'll wait.

Lastly, if one wants to make the argument that Garth Snow is a shrewd GM because he seems to know the CBA inside and out and uses that knowledge to satisfy his owner, I agree 100%. IMO Garth has no integrity and seems to believe the fans don't realize what the organization is doing (which is probably true for the casual fan), but he's no idiot. I have no doubt he would be able to assemble a more competitive team if Wang was not leaning on him to spend as little as possible, and he showed as much by surprising everyone with the Smyth deal back in '07 (before Wang's Lighthouse project failure and subsequent wallet-closing). That said, I don't care how much Garth has done to work the CBA and save Wang money - as a fan, my interest lies in seeing the team win, not cut costs in new and creative ways. So as far as putting a winning product on ice goes, Garth has been a failure - I just don't consider him primarily accountable because no GM can or will succeed with someone like Wang calling the shots.

brilliant post.

better than any article from thehockeywriters.com and a lot of the junk in mainstream media.

post more.
 
This thread is a textbook example of why one cannot rely on numbers and statistics alone when it comes to sports. No matter how hard you try to whitewash the Islanders using stats, at the end of the day they're still doing everything they can to avoid spending real dollars while Garth insults our intelligence by insisting he has no financial limitations ( :laugh: ) and it shows in their performance. Three points out of the East basement, a familiar position for them in case you haven't been paying attention.

I've seen a couple of amusingly bad arguments floated in this thread, such as "the Islanders were over the floor before the Thomas deal!!1" and "standings don't matter, look at the LA Kings!!1" Regarding the former, a team that's already loaded with useless salary and inflated cap hits adding a bogus five million dollar hit - one which will never see a penny of actual money spent - not only reinforces what most of us have noticed about Wang and his spending, but also sends a message to the team that they're expecting to unload even more actual salary at some point instead of taking some on in an attempt to - wait for it - improve the team and COMPETE. And as for the Kings argument, please don't embarrass yourself - anyone who fancies themselves a statistician should know the exception is not the rule. Name one team since the lockout other than LA that hoisted the Cup without finishing in the top four of their conference... I'll wait.

Lastly, if one wants to make the argument that Garth Snow is a shrewd GM because he seems to know the CBA inside and out and uses that knowledge to satisfy his owner, I agree 100%. IMO Garth has no integrity and seems to believe the fans don't realize what the organization is doing (which is probably true for the casual fan), but he's no idiot. I have no doubt he would be able to assemble a more competitive team if Wang was not leaning on him to spend as little as possible, and he showed as much by surprising everyone with the Smyth deal back in '07 (before Wang's Lighthouse project failure and subsequent wallet-closing). That said, I don't care how much Garth has done to work the CBA and save Wang money - as a fan, my interest lies in seeing the team win, not cut costs in new and creative ways. So as far as putting a winning product on ice goes, Garth has been a failure - I just don't consider him primarily accountable because no GM can or will succeed with someone like Wang calling the shots.

Other than the fact that I think 'integrity' in this case can only be as obvious as the dollar amount allotted to write players' checks, this post NAILS IT PERFECTLY.
 
I feel we should look into getting an ECHL affliate. (All teams should have both AA, AAA imo) Doing this may help Bridgeport as well.

Lemme know when we get a double A or triple A team. Bridgeport sucks!:laugh:

Wait, the Isles ARE the triple A team. Gotcha.:cry:
 
And what cracks me up about Ol' Time Thinker...I mean Hockey is that he must be so annoyed with all the huge blockbuster trades happening in this league to wonder why the Isles aren't making any....oh wait, duh there aren't ANY happening. The reason being...teams spent pre new cba time locking up their big players for outrageously high contracts that have caused them to be immovable. The GM's that haven't done that refuse to move their players without a king's ransom. Look, if these trades were popping off left and right I'd buy it...but they aren't. So stop asking for our GM to do something NO GM is doing...it's just absurd. Absolutely absurd.

Bobby Ryan...still playing in Anaheim

What are the other ones that got away?

Absurd? No teams are getting players signed? They're all using the waiver wire to fill needs? And where did I say blockbuster trades? Big contracts?

We're the epitome of well managed hockey teams. Got it.:help:
 
This thread is a textbook example of why one cannot rely on numbers and statistics alone when it comes to sports. No matter how hard you try to whitewash the Islanders using stats, at the end of the day they're still doing everything they can to avoid spending real dollars while Garth insults our intelligence by insisting he has no financial limitations ( :laugh: ) and it shows in their performance. Three points out of the East basement, a familiar position for them in case you haven't been paying attention.

I've seen a couple of amusingly bad arguments floated in this thread, such as "the Islanders were over the floor before the Thomas deal!!1" and "standings don't matter, look at the LA Kings!!1" Regarding the former, a team that's already loaded with useless salary and inflated cap hits adding a bogus five million dollar hit - one which will never see a penny of actual money spent - not only reinforces what most of us have noticed about Wang and his spending, but also sends a message to the team that they're expecting to unload even more actual salary at some point instead of taking some on in an attempt to - wait for it - improve the team and COMPETE. And as for the Kings argument, please don't embarrass yourself - anyone who fancies themselves a statistician should know the exception is not the rule. Name one team since the lockout other than LA that hoisted the Cup without finishing in the top four of their conference... I'll wait.

Lastly, if one wants to make the argument that Garth Snow is a shrewd GM because he seems to know the CBA inside and out and uses that knowledge to satisfy his owner, I agree 100%. IMO Garth has no integrity and seems to believe the fans don't realize what the organization is doing (which is probably true for the casual fan), but he's no idiot. I have no doubt he would be able to assemble a more competitive team if Wang was not leaning on him to spend as little as possible, and he showed as much by surprising everyone with the Smyth deal back in '07 (before Wang's Lighthouse project failure and subsequent wallet-closing). That said, I don't care how much Garth has done to work the CBA and save Wang money - as a fan, my interest lies in seeing the team win, not cut costs in new and creative ways. So as far as putting a winning product on ice goes, Garth has been a failure - I just don't consider him primarily accountable because no GM can or will succeed with someone like Wang calling the shots.


We all need to make this our signature so that we don't forget.
 
How is that saving money for Wang? That would mean insurance would have to pay him, (from being medically unfit to play.) If anything they're holding onto him hoping he'll retire from injury, so he won't count towards the cap and the Isles don't have to pay him for the next decade. He isn't retiring and they're getting impatient (rightfully so.)
Now they can buy him out without his cap hit sticking, it might seem like a blessing for Wang now, the next ten years? Not so much. But it's the better of the two evils.

Who insured the tail end of DP's stupid contract?

I'll give you a hint....the insurer only covered the first six years of the deal.

So who pays the insurance in a self insured contract? Yeah, Wang won't spend a dime self insuring the guy.
 
And can we change "News Article" to "Blaaaaahhhhhhhhger Piece"? This, news wise, is less of an article than it is a self serving pro Islander propaganda device.

Uh, right...

That's a blog, but not an Islanders blog. They do advanced stats and contract analysis there. He's a neutral fan laying out a detailed argument.

Read other articles there if you want a better picture of what they do.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

Ad

Ad