Golden_Jet
Registered User
- Sep 21, 2005
- 27,239
- 14,325
I think he needs a 2-3 games on a lower line, when comes back, then tried with Stu and G.I would put Perron with Stü and Giroux.
I think he needs a 2-3 games on a lower line, when comes back, then tried with Stu and G.I would put Perron with Stü and Giroux.
My concern is that they can't keep up with him.I think he needs a 2-3 games on a lower line, when comes back, then tried with Stu and G.
Yep definitely a possibility , but it won’t surprise me if they try it.My concern is that they can't keep up with him.
In some ways it is OK as Stu burns into the zone, pushes the D back and they can be trailers, but in general I think he needs faster players, not slower. At least 1 anyway.
Me neither. We need Perron to provide some scoring, and we know he can do it, so why not see if Stu can generate some opportunities for him.Yep definitely a possibility , but it won’t surprise me if they try it.
Or put him lower in the lineup and see how he does against weaker competition.Me neither. We need Perron to provide some scoring, and we know he can do it, so why not see if Stu can generate some opportunities for him.
I was dumbfounded when the 2nd went to Arizona rather than coming to OttawaThe Stepan trade - in a vacuum - was ok, but paying a 2nd and retaining nothing was beyond stupid.
I think we all were. I legit thought it was a typoI was dumbfounded when the 2nd went to Arizona rather than coming to Ottawa
That isn't my concern. My concern is that Stü needs players to dish to. Gaudette has been pretty good, but he isn't defensive minded enough to be trusted on the top two lines for extended minutes. I think Perron could help in multiple facets. I am not saying he's a long term fix. I am simply saying, I'd put him with Stü when he returns. I'd also do it right away, so Perron can start scoring and get off the shneid.My concern is that they can't keep up with him.
In some ways it is OK as Stu burns into the zone, pushes the D back and they can be trailers, but in general I think he needs faster players, not slower. At least 1 anyway.
Gaudette deserves it atm I think. Agree that Perron and Amadio aren't ideal, but both have scored close to or above a 20 goal pace the last few years, so not totally insane to try it. Joseph could get there quicker, but he doesn't score enough to be a top line player either. Only 2 goals, 4 points & -5 in 20 games so far. Pacing at only 11 per 82 the last 3 years. Either way, we'd have someone miscast on that line and I don't think the solution was or is in house atm.I agree that a fast winger who can shoot and play with Stutzle is needed; I don't think Perron is that winger as he is too slow. Amadio is also slow.
Gaudette has proven to be a shooter in the AHL and done well so far in the nHL, so he can play there now and I hope he thrives at it.
Trading Jospeh and a 3rd round pick for "nothing" but open cap space has not been a very good decision.
This team definitely needs that '06 Heatley to put the puck home.Gaudette deserves it atm I think. Agree that Perron and Amadio aren't ideal, but both have scored close to or above a 20 goal pace the last few years, so not totally insane to try it. Joseph could get there quicker, but he doesn't score enough to be a top line player either. Only 2 goals, 4 points & -5 in 20 games so far. Pacing at only 11 per 82 the last 3 years. Either way, we'd have someone miscast on that line and I don't think the solution was or is in house atm.
Green has been praising that 3rd line the past few games. They get a lot of minutes, spend most of their time in the O zone, have some of the more difficult match-ups and are relied on during key moments in the game (end of period, end of game). I don't see Green changing anyone on that line unless they start to falter.I was surprised to see Cousins be adequate on the 3rd line but hey if it works keep it going. I do think Perron would push him down to the 4th just to get him going but no harm in having Perron ease his way back starting on the 4th. He can't be worse than Greig at this point but also wouldn't be opposed to seeing Amadio pushed out of the top 9.
I agree. I think it'll be a toss-up between Gaudette and Ostapchuk going down to the minors once Perron returns.That isn't my concern. My concern is that Stü needs players to dish to. Gaudette has been pretty good, but he isn't defensive minded enough to be trusted on the top two lines for extended minutes. I think Perron could help in multiple facets. I am not saying he's a long term fix. I am simply saying, I'd put him with Stü when he returns. I'd also do it right away, so Perron can start scoring and get off the shneid.
My question to you is: When Zub returns do you put him with Sanderson of play him down the lineup? I don't think anyone plays Zub on a lower line. I don't think Perron should be shoved down to the fourth line either. We need to get him going and get the entire team clicking. I don't see Gaudette being a major factor in the playoffs. Perron on the other hand will play a lot of minutes if we make the playoffs.
I see what you mean, and I hadn't thought of the 3rd line being so effective, it shouldn't be broken up.That isn't my concern. My concern is that Stü needs players to dish to. Gaudette has been pretty good, but he isn't defensive minded enough to be trusted on the top two lines for extended minutes. I think Perron could help in multiple facets. I am not saying he's a long term fix. I am simply saying, I'd put him with Stü when he returns. I'd also do it right away, so Perron can start scoring and get off the shneid.
My question to you is: When Zub returns do you put him with Sanderson or play him down the lineup? I don't think anyone plays Zub on a lower line. I don't think Perron should be shoved down to the fourth line either. We need to get him going and get the entire team clicking. I don't see Gaudette being a major factor in the playoffs. Perron on the other hand will play a lot of minutes if we make the playoffs.
I agree that a fast winger who can shoot and play with Stutzle is needed; I don't think Perron is that winger as he is too slow. Amadio is also slow.
Gaudette has proven to be a shooter in the AHL and done well so far in the nHL, so he can play there now and I hope he thrives at it.
Trading Jospeh and a 3rd round pick for "nothing" but open cap space has not been a very good decision.