Toggle sidebar

D Cale Makar - UMass (Amherst), NCAA (2017, 4th, COL)

  • Work is still on-going to rebuild the site styling and features. Please report any issues you may experience so we can look into it. Click Here for Updates
Status
Not open for further replies.
rt said:
Who owns his CHL rights? Any chance his new NHL club can talk him out of going to UMASS?
Click to expand...

If there was a time for Makar to change his plans, it would have been this season cause Med Hat is a great team and could win the league title. Chances are the team wont be as good next year.

I dont see him changing his plans next year... But u never know i guess
 
Every scout I've talked to about him thinks he could be an offensive superstar...those do not last long in the draft. No one wants to pass up on a player who could be the "next Karlsson"...so he's a great bet to go top three I think...which is where Karlsson should have gone in hindsight. This article should open a few eyes....and no... I didn't rank him second overall just for attention..ranked him second because IMO he will end up being one of the top-two players from this draft.

https://recrutes.ca/meet-your-makar-king-patrick/
 
Grant McCagg said:
Every scout I've talked to about him thinks he could be an offensive superstar...those do not last long in the draft. No one wants to pass up on a player who could be the "next Karlsson"...so he's a great bet to go top three I think...which is where Karlsson should have gone in hindsight. This article should open a few eyes....and no... I didn't rank him second overall just for attention..ranked him second because IMO he will end up being one of the top-two players from this draft.

https://recrutes.ca/meet-your-makar-king-patrick/
Click to expand...

You think he projects to be more like an Erik Karlsson then say Tyson Barrie or a Kevin Shattenkirk?

I'm guessing you don't expect him to be around when Buffalo picks...
 
1972 said:
You think he projects to be more like an Erik Karlsson then say Tyson Barrie or a Kevin Shattenkirk?
Click to expand...

For sure. His skating/puck skills are far superior to those two at the same age...only d prospect who has possibly had better in the past decade is Karlsson.
 
1972 said:
Whose seen this kid play live?
Click to expand...

I watched him last season without knowing who he was or anything about it. Lets just say I was googling his name shortly into the game. Kid was so far above everyone else on the ice it wasn't funny....and he was just 16. You could just tell he got it and had skill to burn. He had 1 goal and 2 assists in that game if my memory serves and the goal was the gwg.
I've been keeping tabs on him ever since. I haven't seen a playing in junior A play like him since I used to see Kariya in Penticton. I'm obviously not saying he is a Kariya but man this kid has unlimited potential.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaKarter
1972 said:
Whose seen this kid play live?
Click to expand...

I was at a few games in Bonnyville for the World Junior A Championship.

Makar is no Svechnikov but he was more talented than anyone else there. The thing that really strikes me about him is how he plays with so much swagger. He does whatever he wants (in a good way) and he has the skill to pull it off. He's not the biggest guy but he plays way bigger than he is, so I'm not very concerned about his size. All of his abilities could be described as plus, imo, even the defensive ones.

Of course, you wish he was in a higher league so you knew how well he stacked up with a little more certainty. I heard some chatter on HF that he might be selected for the men's world championship team, but I don't know how likely that is. It would be very interesting to see how he would do there.
 
Scouts are going to have to determine whether he is a Torey Krug or an Erik Karlsson. Not bad either way just a thinking point.
 
Grant McCagg said:
For sure. His skating/puck skills are far superior to those two at the same age...only d prospect who has possibly had better in the past decade is Karlsson.
Click to expand...

Better than Werenski, Provorov, DeAngelo in that regard? I have a hard time seeing that.

Even Girard in this last draft was pretty gifted there, specifically his puck skills.

IceManCat said:
Scouts are going to have to determine whether he is a Torey Krug or an Erik Karlsson. Not bad either way just a thinking point.
Click to expand...

My biggest fear is that he is Ryan Murph V2. Also I just feel like from a value standpoint, similar players to Makar go in the 15-30 range in most draft classes. Because of the risks associated with them.
 
Frk It said:
Better than Werenski, Provorov, DeAngelo in that regard? I have a hard time seeing that.

Even Girard in this last draft was pretty gifted there, specifically his puck skills.



My biggest fear is that he is Ryan Murph V2. Also I just feel like from a value standpoint, similar players to Makar go in the 15-30 range in most draft classes. Because of the risks associated with them.
Click to expand...


I have seen him play a number of times, and if he is available when the wings pick, and holland doesnt pick him, i will be pissed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: covfefe
His team won the AJHL Championship and he was named Playoff MVP. Im really interested to see where he ends up, could be 4th, 8th or 13th who knows...
 
Last edited:
I was able to speak to a college coach recently and his name came up. The coach had said that Cale Makar was the best junior(A) he has ever seen. This came as a bit of a suprise but he was very open about it although he did admit he himself hasn't watched much of the USHL as it isnt his job.
 
  • Love
Reactions: covfefe
RedWingsAllTheWay said:
I was able to speak to a college coach recently and his name came up. The coach had said that Cale Makar was the best junior(A) he has ever seen. This came as a bit of a suprise but he was very open about it although he did admit he himself hasn't watched much of the USHL as it isnt his job.
Click to expand...

It's a good thing he doesn't watch the USHL for Makar as he plays in the AJHL. :)
 
Skinnyjimmy08 said:
If there was a time for Makar to change his plans, it would have been this season cause Med Hat is a great team and could win the league title. Chances are the team wont be as good next year.

I dont see him changing his plans next year... But u never know i guess
Click to expand...

Hypothetical question here but if he goes to Medicine Hat Next year, can he play in the AHL when he is 19? I thought I heard something about a rule that if a player signs when they are 18 they not subject to the same rules as players drafted out of the CHL. That might only be for non Canadians though
 
boredmale said:
Hypothetical question here but if he goes to Medicine Hat Next year, can he play in the AHL when he is 19? I thought I heard something about a rule that if a player signs when they are 18 they not subject to the same rules as players drafted out of the CHL. That might only be for non Canadians though
Click to expand...

Yeah he'd be drafted out of the AJHL instead of the CHL so he could be sent there for a season or to the AHL.
 
So he's committed to UMASS, but aren't they a terrible team or am I mistaken?
 
Love said:
So he's committed to UMASS, but aren't they a terrible team or am I mistaken?
Click to expand...

UMASS isn't very good especially for their conference. On the bright side though he will be the teams #1 defensman and should get a lot of playing time.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom