I don’t know what the origin of the ‘crying girl’ reaction option is—but I do know that it should probably be replaced with Tom Wilson’s cry face.
A while back there was essentially a "Photoshop battle" where people kept combining the face of a surprised looking little girl looking at a turkey with Olli Jokinen. I wasn't around for it, but it kind of went down in HF lore. Other piece of HF lore I can name off hand:
"THIS IS OUT HOUSE"
"Ryder, Halak, and a 2nd"