Proposal: Colorado - Toronto

[TheRarestDangles]

This New Lander guy isn't that good. I'll keep the midget.

 

[Flyer lurker]

Wow a legit offer on here. Nylander better player but d-men do have premium over wingers. COL would win trade but not crazy win.

 

[thusk]

I really like girard but hes absolutly not what leafs need. They already get rielly and sandin in the same type of dman.

Nylander is the best leafs player with jack campbell by far this season

 

[Guitpik]

Not a fan of either team, but Colorado will need to sweeten up that deal from their side quite a bit.

 

[Raymond foley]

Colorado

William Nylander

Toronto

Samuel Girard

1 for 1. Avs get their top 6 F, Leafs get their D. Who says no?

No

 

[The90]

You said if one of the 4 big forwards are moved..it's for more forwards.

Yes. If.

Only one other could be traded though says you. Teams aren’t in the market for ppg forwards forwards these days huh? The leafs have 3. Eichel just got a big haul on a 10 million dollar contract. Makes sense.

 

[TheImpatientPanther]

Yes. If.

Only one other could be traded though says you. Teams aren’t in the market for ppg forwards forwards these days huh? The leafs have 3. Eichel just got a big haul on a 10 million dollar contract. Makes sense.

Well you don't want to trade Matthews (for obvious reasons) or Nylander.
Tavares isn't going anywhere, so who's left out of the 4?

Will Dubas actually pull it off?
What package would you move Marner for?

 

[AvsGuy]

Girard was actually really good last season, hasn't been as great this season but is starting to pick it up. He's an underrated defenseman league wide, but top 20 would be a stretch. Lots of his value lies in his insane contract - he's a top pairing guy making $5 million long term, that is insanely valuable

 

[The90]

Well you don't want to trade Matthews (for obvious reasons) or Nylander.
Tavares isn't going anywhere, so who's left out of the 4?

Will Dubas actually pull it off?
What package would you move Marner for?

Well an injured eichel just pulled in 2 picks krebs tuch. So there’s your standard. Similar salary too

 

[TheImpatientPanther]

Well an injured eichel just pulled in 2 picks krebs tuch. So there’s your standard. Similar salary too

For sure, not saying Marner can't pull that type of return but BUF is in full rebuild, feels like TOR would prefer roster players who are in early 20s and ready to make an impact right away.

Still unsure if Dubas would do it though.

 

[The90]

For sure, not saying Marner can't pull that type of return but BUF is in full rebuild, feels like TOR would prefer roster players who are in early 20s and ready to make an impact right away.

Still unsure if Dubas would do it though.

They could use all the picks as ammo. Tuch is a nice player. Anyway I doubt it happens and genuinely don’t think it’s a good idea.

 

[unicornpig]

terrible for toronto. if thats the return that colorado is expecting for girard prepare to be disappointed

 

[Dr Amazing]

Toronto adds

 

[Sidney the Kidney]

Counter: liljegren for Rantanen

You can disagree with the OP without making a ridiculous comparison.

The OP is swapping a top line winger for a top 4 defenseman. Your response is swapping a top line winger for a bottom pairing defender with less than 30 NHL games under his belt.

 

[93gilmour93]

Absolutely not from the Leafs. Nylander has gone to another level and the contract at 6.9 is great

 

[GirardSpinorama]

4 point night from Girard. He's not going anywhere.

 

[unitedstars87]

Counter: Mackinnon for Kerfoot

Am I doing this right?

No..Cap issues

 

[Pierce Hawthorne]

I think the Girard to Toronto ship sailed when Rielly was re-signed.


But ya, value wise its pretty close.

 

[Spilot23]

No..Cap issues

Damn it so we have to retain like 50%

 

[Shane Diesel]

Colorado

William Nylander

Toronto

Samuel Girard

1 for 1. Avs get their top 6 F, Leafs get their D. Who says no?

No

 

[Phion Keneuf]

People don’t realize how good Nylander is, most Leafs fans included. This is an easy no & I like Girard

 

[Edgelord]

I think the Girard to Toronto ship sailed when Rielly was re-signed.


But ya, value wise its pretty close.

I don't see it as close at all.
You really don't want to hear what I would ask from Col for Nylander

 

[Linds]

All the leafs fans saying this is an easy no is the exact reason why the leafs have not accomplished anything in the last 10 years. Failing to properly address their blueline. It doesn't matter if you have MR you can never have enough two way puck moving d men

 

[nightonthesun]

Leafs fans seem super touchy about Nylander in here - must be a lot of bad proposals for him floating around. I'm remembering a time when all you guys wanted to do was shoot him into the sun, so he must have really turned it on.

Girard is an underrated player as well. I think this proposal is pretty close. Maybe if Willy really has leveled up, this is a little too easy for Colorado, but I dunno. Sammy has also been excellent. 4pts and easily the team's best player last night.

 

[banks]

All the leafs fans saying this is an easy no is the exact reason why the leafs have not accomplished anything in the last 10 years. Failing to properly address their blueline. It doesn't matter if you have MR you can never have enough two way puck moving d men

Do you think the fans make the real trades?

And the Leafs recent playoff failures have been because of a lack of scoring from their big name forwards, which this trade would make worse. Or because of disasterous defensive play from their puck moving D men (namely Gardiner), which this trade would make worse.

Your totally wrong across the board.