Proposal: Cgy-Mtl

[LetsGoFlames]

You can't be serious saying that Brodie could be considered a #3 aka 2nd pairing defenceman. I'm an Oilers fan saying Brodie is a legit top pairing high end #2 at the least. Damn. I feel sick now. Thanks

This is my favorite post of this thread. And this is a Flames fan giving props to an Oilers fan. But yeah, in my opinion, Brodie is easily our most valuable defenseman. (Gio 2nd, Hamilton 3rd). If Larsson cost Hall, what would Brodie fetch? I hope the coach figures out how to use him soon.

 

[CaptainCrunch67]

Before I start let it be known in a habs fan. As we all are with our teams I may be a little homey with my offer but in all honesty I don't think it's as horrific as many habs offers in the past. Or many of the he proposals to begin with.

Either way here goes.

TO MTL

C BACKLUND
LD TJ BRODIE

TO CAL

LD BEAULIEU
1st Rd pick 2017
2nd round pick 2018
DD ( cap hit )

Fire away..

Thats a outright brutal offer for the Flames, they give up one of the better 2 way centers in the game and a top pairing young defenseman on a great contract for a 2nd pairing defenseman probably a mid to late 1st round pick a 2nd round pick next week and a cap dump.

Seriously that doesn't even get the conversation started, if a team wants Brodie the overpayment to get him is absolutely massive.

 

[Fazkovsky]

That's the worst offer ever

If we don't give Gallagher and beaulieu + flames hangs up

 

[Lunatik]

What a terrible suggestion in the OP, Flames hang up, change their number and give the new one to everyone but the Habs

 

[LetsGoFlames]

Why would Montreal want Brodie though, when they have Sergachev coming? And honestly, any trade for Brodie to the Habs, I'd want Sergachev coming back.

 

[The Great Weal]

Sorry flames fans

 

[Remember2004]

I didn't think there could be a worst proposal than DD+ for Hamilton...

 

[hockeyheadlines]

Why would Montreal want Brodie though, when they have Sergachev coming? And honestly, any trade for Brodie to the Habs, I'd want Sergachev coming back.

I've been saying all along, Montreal and Calgary are not realistic trading partners.

As for Sergachev, he's not going anywhere but Montreal.

 

[tony d]

Calgary's going to want more than that if they give up Brodie.

 

[hockeyheadlines]

Calgary's going to want more than that if they give up Brodie.

Then, they need to look elsewhere than Montreal for a trade.

No reason for Calgary to move Brodie, none.

 

[Jared Dunn]

Why would Montreal want Brodie though, when they have Sergachev coming? And honestly, any trade for Brodie to the Habs, I'd want Sergachev coming back.

Well adding Brodie without really giving up anything off the roster would make Montreal the definite top contender in the East imo. Doesn't make sense for Calgary to trade Brodie but if he was available, I don't think Beaulieu or Juulsen + 1st would be THAT bad of a starting point.

Going forward having Brodie and Sergachev down the left side would be real nice

 

[Skobel24]

Well adding Brodie without really giving up anything off the roster would make Montreal the definite top contender in the East imo. Doesn't make sense for Calgary to trade Brodie but if he was available, I don't think Beaulieu or Juulsen + 1st would be THAT bad of a starting point.

Going forward having Brodie and Sergachev down the left side would be real nice

Brodie plays the right side despite him being a left handed shot. He's not nearly as effective on the left.

Also, **** no to the OP's proposal.

 

[tempest2i]

Brodie plays the right side despite him being a left handed shot. He's not nearly as effective on the left.

Also, **** no to the OP's proposal.

Has your coach figured this out yet?

 

[Woodtkachuk]

I'd be sick if we traded Brodie for that entire package let alone adding backlund

 

[hockeyheadlines]

Brodie plays the right side despite him being a left handed shot. He's not nearly as effective on the left.

One more reason Brodie to Montreal isn't feasable. We'll keep Beaulieu.

 

[Some Other Flame]

Haha classic habs fan proposal

I'd be sick if we traded Brodie for that entire package let alone adding backlund

Treliving would have to be off his rocker to trade Backlund alone for that package. Habs fans are utterly delusional about how much value their marginal scraps have.

 

[Skobel24]

Has your coach figured this out yet?

Sadly, no.

 

[hockeyheadlines]

Haha classic habs fan proposal



Treliving would have to be off his rocker to trade Backlund alone for that package. Habs fans are utterly delusional about how much value their marginal scraps have.

Let the standings speak for themselves.

 

[HabsTown]

Sorry Flames fans! ouch.

Would you be interested in

DD
1st 2017
Scherbak

for

Grandlund
Ferland

 

[Some Other Flame]

Let the standings speak for themselves.

Because Beaulieu, Desharnais and the 1st are the reasons the Habs are doing so well

 

[hockeyheadlines]

Because Beaulieu, Desharnais and the 1st are the reasons the Habs are doing so well

A team is a package. Works for us. Ask yourself why it isn't for you.

 

[Some Other Flame]

A team is a package. Works for us. Ask yourself why it isn't for you.

Then keep your team (aka Price) and stop trying to peddle junk for other teams best players

 

[hockeyheadlines]

Then keep your team (aka Price) and stop trying to peddle junk for other teams best players

I've been shooting this proposal down since the beginning.

 

[Skobel24]

Sorry Flames fans! ouch.

Would you be interested in

DD
1st 2017
Scherbak

for

Grandlund
Ferland

...do you mean Granlund? If so, he was dealt last season to Vancouver.

 

[Legend123]

Then keep your team (aka Price) and stop trying to peddle junk for other teams best players

Its funny cuz even without Price, the Habs are miles ahead of your flames. But keep thinking the Habs are all about Price